Fujian Xingxing Restaurant Pty Ltd v Eternity Trading Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fujian Xingxing Restaurant Pty Ltd v Eternity Trading Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 483

File numbers: NSD 248 of 2020
NSD 249 of 2020
Judge: STEWART J
Date of judgment: 15 April 2020
Catchwords: HIGH COURT AND FEDERAL COURT – cross-vesting – consumer law – practice and procedure – where proceedings in NSW Civil & Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) and Federal Court are related – whether NCAT proceedings can be transferred to Federal Court – meaning of “court” in cl 6(1) of Sch 4 to Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW) – whether cl 6(1) can authorise transfer of proceedings to the Federal Court
Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law (Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) ss 21, 237

Australian Consumer Law (NSW) ss 21, 237

Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW) Pt 3A, ss 16, 17, Sch 4 cls 1, 3, 6

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 138D

Constitution ss 75, 76

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 459H, 459J

Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) s 28

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 1.37, 27.13, 27.23

Interpretation Act 1987 (NSW) ss 5, 12

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (Cth) s 5

Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (NSW) s 5

Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW) s 72

Cases cited:

Agtrack (NT) Pty Ltd v Hatfield [2005] HCA 38; 223 CLR 251

BHP Billiton Ltd v Schultz [2004] HCA 61; 221 CLR 400

Burns v Corbett [2018] HCA 15; 353 ALR 386

Commissioner of Stamp Duties (NSW) v Owens (No 2) [1953] HCA 62; 88 CLR 168

CSL Australia Pty Ltd v Formosa [2009] NSWCA 363; 261 ALR 441

Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally [1999] HCA 27; 198 CLR 511

Seaegg v The King [1932] HCA 47; 48 CLR 251

Solomons v District Court of New South Wales [2002] HCA 47; 211 CLR 119

Stack v Coast Securities (No 9) Pty Ltd [1983] HCA 36; 154 CLR 261

The Owners-Strata Plan No 21372 v Banovic (No 2) [2017] NSWSC 734

Date of last submissions: 25 March 2020
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 40
Counsel for the Applicant: G Campbell
Solicitor for the Applicant: WB Legal
Solicitor for the Respondent: Mistry Fallahi Lawyers & Business Advisors

ORDERS

NSD 248 of 2020
NSD 249 of 2020
BETWEEN:

FUJIAN XINGXING RESTAURANT PTY LTD ACN 618 093 020

Applicant

AND:

ETERNITY TRADING PTY LTD ACN 096 343 903

Respondent

JUDGE:

STEWART J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 APRIL 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Proceedings NSD248/2020 and NSD249/2020 are dismissed.

2.The Registrar is directed under r 1.37 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) to close matters NSD248/2020 and NSD249/2020 and return to the NSW Civil & Administrative Tribunal the files received from it in its matters COM 19/15379…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fujian Xingxing Restaurant Pty Ltd v Eternity Trading Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 483
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Fujian Xingxing Restaurant Pty Ltd v Eternity Trading Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the applicant, Fujian Xingxing Restaurant Pty Ltd, and the respondents, Meetfresh Franchising Pty Ltd and Eternity Trading Pty Ltd. The applicant operated a franchise business under a franchise agreement and a licence to occupy premises. The dispute arose from alleged breaches of the franchise agreement, unpaid invoices, and a statutory demand issued by Meetfresh Franchising. The applicant sought various declarations, damages, and orders, including setting aside the statutory demand. The case also involved cross-claims by the respondents against the applicant.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the proceedings in the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) could be transferred to the Federal Court. The applicant had sought to transfer two related proceedings from NCAT to the Federal Court. The court had to determine the meaning of "court" in clause 6(1) of Schedule 4 to the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW) and whether this clause could authorise the transfer of proceedings to the Federal Court. The court also had to consider whether the NCAT Act provided any statutory power to transfer proceedings to the Federal Court.

The court found that the NCAT Act did not confer non-federal jurisdiction on the Federal Court. The NCAT proceedings did not invoke federal jurisdiction as they were based on the Australian Consumer Law (NSW), which is a state law. Therefore, the transfer of the NCAT proceedings to the Federal Court was not competent. The court concluded that the proceedings should not have been accepted by the Registry and opened in the Federal Court. The appropriate relief was to dismiss the proceedings and direct the Registrar to close the matters in the Federal Court and return the files to NCAT. The court also vacated the first case management hearing.

The court's final orders were to dismiss the proceedings NSD248/2020 and NSD249/2020, direct the Registrar to close these matters and return the files to NCAT, and vacate the first case management hearing. The court emphasised that its dismissal of the proceedings was without prejudice to the merits of the claims sought to be asserted in the NCAT proceedings, which should be pleaded in the existing Federal Court proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Proceedings NSD248/2020 and NSD249/2020 are dismissed.

2. The Registrar is directed under r 1.37 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) to close matters NSD248/2020 and NSD249/2020 and return to the NSW Civil & Administrative Tribunal the files received from it in its matters COM 19/15379 and COM 19/15384.

3. The first case management hearing listed for 23 April 2020 is vacated.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The question that arises for decision is whether the transfer of the proceedings from NCAT to this Court is competent.Background Before I deal with the purported transfer of the NCAT proceedings to this Court, it is necessary to first set out the background to the original FCA proceeding. The applicant, Fujian Xingxing Restaurant Pty Ltd, operates a “MeetFresh” dessert and beverage franchise business which operates under the terms of a franchise agreement with the first respondent, Meetfresh Franchising Pty Ltd, and a licence to occupy premises from the second respondent, Eternity Trading Pty Ltd. It is claimed that Meetfresh Franchising failed to supply the applicant with certain goods and marketing under the franchising agreement, that the applicant has not paid the invoices issued by Meetfresh Franchising, and that Meetfresh Franchising issued the applicant with a statutory demand for payment of its invoices. The respondents have purported to terminate the franchise agreement and the licence to occupy, and the applicant seeks declarations, damages and orders setting aside the statutory demand. The orders setting aside the statutory demand are sought under ss 459H or 459J of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). There is also relief sought against Meetfresh Franchising and Eternity Trading under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) which is Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and against Meetfresh Franchising under other provisions of that Act. This Court accordingly has jurisdiction under s 39B(1A)(c) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) as a matter arising under a law of the Parliament. There is also a cross-claim by Meetfresh Franchising against the applicant and two of its directors for unpaid invoices and other relief in relation to the franchise agreement and by Eternity Trading against the applicant in relation to the sub-lease and the licence to occupy. On 5 March 2020, the matter came before me for case management. At the hearing, the applicant’s solicitor stated that the parties intended to seek the Court’s leave to transfer two proceedings in NCAT that are related to the original FCA proceeding to this Court. The applicant tendered a copy of the following orders made by Senior Member D Bluth of NCAT on 21 January 2020:1.By consent these proceedings number COM 19/15379 and COM 19/15384 (NCAT Proceedings) are to be transferred to the Federal Court of Australia (FCA).2.The parties will make an application for leave to transfer the NCAT Proceedings to the FAC (sic) to be heard together with proceedings number NSD1567/2019 by 17th February 2019.3.The Tribunal is of the view that the NCAT Proceedings should be transferred to the FCA.4.The Tribunal notes Eternity Trading Pty Ltd’s undertaking not to take possession of the premises at level 1, 42-42A Dixon Street, Sydney until the proceedings are resolved in NCAT or the FCA.5.Costs are reserved Neither the applicant’s solicitor nor counsel for the respondents, both of whom appeared at the case management hearing, was able to identify any statutory power to transfer a proceeding from NCAT to this Court and I expressed doubt that such a power exists. Since the parties stated that they wished to make an application to transfer the NCAT proceedings, which they had not yet made, and they were not prepared to make such an application at the case management hearing, at the parties’ request I noted the following in the timetabling orders made that day:THE COURT NOTES THAT:1. The parties agree that the Applicant will make an application to transfer its applications to the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal, being proceedings COM 19/15379 and COM 19/15384 (the NCAT Proceedings), to this Court.THE COURT ORDERS THAT:1. …

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Also, under cl 6(1)(b), once transferred, the proceeding would continue as if it has been commenced in the transferee court. Non-federal jurisdiction proceedings could not have been commenced in the Federal Court, and the NCAT Act could certainly not confer non-federal jurisdiction on the Federal Court: Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally [1999] HCA 27; 198 CLR 511.Conclusion For the above reasons, the purported transfer of the NCAT proceedings to this Court is not competent. The transfers should not have been accepted by the Registry and the cases should not have been opened in this Court. It seems to me that the appropriate relief is to dismiss the proceedings and direct the Registrar under FCR r 1.37 to close the matters in this Court and return the files to NCAT. Obviously in dismissing the proceedings I say nothing about the merits of the claims sought to be asserted in the NCAT proceedings. The parties in the existing FCA proceeding should discontinue the NCAT proceedings and plead the issues that have been raised there in the FCA proceeding. The issues can be recast as raising federal jurisdiction, although even if that is not done they can be raised in the existing FCA proceeding as being within the accrued jurisdiction of the Federal Court, i.e. as matters of non-federal jurisdiction part of the “litigious or justiciable controversy between parties of which the federal claim or cause of action forms part”: Stack v Coast Securities (No 9) Pty Ltd [1983] HCA 36; 154 CLR 261 at 290 per Mason, Brennan and Deane JJ.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant submits that the original FCA proceeding raises the same central issue that is at the heart of the NCAT proceedings and indeed, the matters before NCAT are merely a small part of the much broader proceeding in this Court. As a matter of practicality and in accordance with the orders of NCAT, the applicant submits that the NCAT proceedings should be transferred to this Court to avoid a multiplicity of proceedings concerning the same issues. Consideration The NCAT proceedings as pleaded do not invoke federal jurisdiction; the character of the jurisdiction being exercised is state and not federal. The reason is that there was no “matter” within ss 75 and 76 of the Constitution. As to the fundamental importance of identifying the character of the jurisdiction being exercised in every case, see CSL Australia Pty Ltd v Formosa [2009] NSWCA 363; 261 ALR 441 at [22] per Allsop P, Basten JA and Handley AJA. The applicant’s reference to the ACL and s 39B(1A)(c) of the Judiciary Act apparently seeks to invoke s 76(ii) of the Constitution, viz. “a matter arising under any laws made by the Parliament”, but the invocation is mistaken. That is because what is relied on in the NCAT proceedings is the ACL (NSW) which, as I have said, applies as a law of the State of New South Wales by s 28(1) of the Fair Trading Act. It is not a law of the Parliament. A matter will arise in federal jurisdiction if “a party on either side of the record relies upon a right, immunity or a defence derived from a federal law”: Agtrack (NT) Pty Ltd v Hatfield [2005] HCA 38; 223 CLR 251 at [32] per Gleeson CJ, McHugh, Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ. Neither party in the NCAT proceedings did that. If the NCAT proceedings were properly characterised as raising a matter within federal jurisdiction, then they would not have been competent to be pursued in NCAT: Burns v Corbett [2018] HCA 15; 353 ALR 386. In that event, under Pt 3A of the NCAT Act they could be transferred to an “authorised court” which is defined under s 34A as either the District Court or the Local Court of NSW. If the NCAT proceedings were not within federal jurisdiction, as indeed they were not, then they could have been transferred to another “court” under cl 6(1) of Sch 4 to the NCAT Act, which is what the NCAT orders sought to do. The question is whether that “court” could have been the Federal Court? Clause 6 of Sch 4 provides as follows:6 Transfer of proceedings to courts or to other tribunals(1)If the parties in any proceedings for the exercise of a Division function so agree, or if the Tribunal of its own motion or on the application of a party so directs, the proceedings are – (a)to be transferred to a court (in accordance with the rules of that court) that has jurisdiction in the matter, and(b)to continue before that court as if the proceedings had been instituted there. One issue that arises from this provision is what rules there are of the Federal Court “in accordance with” which the transfers could occur.