Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd v Park Cho Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd v Park Cho Pty Ltd [2018] NSWCA 282
Hearing dates: 12 November 2018
Date of orders: 23 November 2018
Decision date: 23 November 2018
Before: Macfarlan JA at [1]
Gleeson JA at [2]
Barrett AJA at [3]
Decision:

(1)   Appeal dismissed.

(2)   The appellants pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.
Catchwords:

LAND LAW – conveyancing – contract for sale – novation – whether contract was novated so that the second appellant replaced the first appellant as purchaser – whether second appellant merely exercised a right to nominate another transferee

  CONTRACTS – formation – novation – requirements for effective novation of contract by substitution of party
Legislation Cited: Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Cases Cited: ALH Group Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue (2012) 245 CLR 338; [2012] HCA 6
Brambles Holdings Ltd v Bathurst City Council (2001) 53 NSWLR 153; [2001] NSWCA 61
Chambers v Manchester and Milford Railway Co (1864) 5 B & S 588; 122 ER 951
Earl of Egmont v Smith (1877) 6 Ch D 469
Ferguson v Wilson (1866) LR 2 Ch App 77
Fightvision Pty Ltd v Onisforou (1999) 47 NSWLR 473; [1999] NSWCA 323
Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd v Park Cho Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 528
Gangemi v Osborne [2009] VSCA 297
Lord v Trippe (1977) 51 ALJR 574
Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353; [1954] HCA 72
McMahon v National Foods Milk Ltd (2009) 25 VR 251; [2009] VSCA 153
Meehan v Jones (1982) 149 CLR 571; [1982] HCA 52
Motel Marine Pty Ltd v IAC (Finance) Pty Ltd (1964) 110 CLR 9; [1964] HCA 7
Olsson v Dyson (1969) 120 CLR 365; [1969] HCA 3
Pavlovic v Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd (2015) 90 NSWLR 605; [2015] NSWCA 313
Pintrach v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2018] FCAFC 79
Trust Company of Australia Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties [2001] QCA 278; (2001) 47 ATR 418
Trust Company of Australia Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue [2003] HCA 23; (2003) 77 ALJR 1019
Vickery v Woods (1952) 85 CLR 336; [1952] HCA 7
Texts Cited: Peter Butt, “Purchaser ‘or nominee’” (1997) 71 ALJ 12
Samuel Stoljar, “Discharge by novation” (1964) UQLJ 5
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd (First Appellant)
De Fu Zhang (Second Appellant)
Park Cho Pty Ltd (Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
E White (Appellants)
N Kirby (Respondent)

  Solicitors:
Legal Point Lawyers (Appellants)
Vinci Lawyers (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2018/192226
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
Supreme Court of New South Wales
Jurisdiction:
Equity
Citation:
[2018] NSWSC 528
Date of Decision:
24 May 2018
Before:
Slattery J
File Number(s):
2017/140558

Judgment

  1. MACFARLAN JA: I agree with Barrett AJA.

  2. GLEESON JA: I agree with Barrett AJA.

  3. BARRETT AJA: In vendor and purchaser proceedings determined on 24 May 2018[1] ,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd v Park Cho Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWCA 282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd and another party appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a decision concerning a contract for the sale of land. The dispute centred on whether the contract had been novated, effectively substituting the second appellant for the first appellant as the purchaser, or if the second appellant had merely exercised a right to nominate another transferee under the original contract.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the contract for sale had been effectively novated so that the second appellant replaced the first appellant as the purchaser. Secondly, the court had to consider whether the second appellant's actions constituted merely the exercise of a right to nominate another transferee, rather than a novation of the contract.

The Court of Appeal reasoned that for a novation to occur, there must be a clear intention by all parties to the original contract to extinguish the old contract and create a new one with a substituted party. In this instance, the court found that the evidence did not demonstrate the necessary intention to novate. Instead, the court concluded that the second appellant had acted within the scope of a right to nominate a transferee, which did not alter the fundamental contractual relationship between the original vendor and purchaser. The principles of contract law regarding novation, requiring the discharge of the original contract and the creation of a new one with the consent of all parties, were applied.

The appeal was dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Appeal dismissed.

(2) The appellants pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd was the original purchaser under a contract for the sale of a property in Sydney, entered into with Park Cho Pty Ltd. Pursuant to the terms of the contract, Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd was required to pay a deposit and progressively pay the balance of the purchase price. However, before completing the purchase, Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd entered into an agreement with Park Cho Pty Ltd, whereby the latter agreed to novation of the contract to allow Park Cho Pty Ltd to nominate a replacement purchaser. Park Cho Pty Ltd then nominated the second appellant, Fu Tian Fortune Investments Pty Ltd, to complete the purchase.

Park Cho Pty Ltd and Fu Tian Fortune Investments Pty Ltd subsequently entered into a new contract for the sale of the property, which was executed on the same terms as the original contract. Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd was not a party to this new contract. Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd subsequently brought an action against Park Cho Pty Ltd and Fu Tian Fortune Investments Pty Ltd, seeking a declaration that the original contract remained in force and that they were still bound by it. Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd argued that the novation was ineffective because it did not comply with the requirements for a valid novation under contract law.

Park Cho Pty Ltd and Fu Tian Fortune Investments Pty Ltd argued that the original contract had been novated, and that they were not liable to Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd under that contract. They contended that the novation was effective because it satisfied the requirements for a valid novation, and that Fu Tian Fortune Investments Pty Ltd was not merely exercising a right to nominate a replacement transferee, but had become the new purchaser under the contract. The trial judge found in favour of Park Cho Pty Ltd and Fu Tian Fortune Investments Pty Ltd, and Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd appealed to the appellate court.

The matter of Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd v Park Cho Pty Ltd arose from a dispute over the novation of a contract for the sale of land. Initially, the first appellant, Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd, entered into a contract for the sale of land with the respondent, Park Cho Pty Ltd. Subsequently, the second appellant, Park Cho Holdings Pty Ltd, sought to replace Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd as the purchaser. This led to a series of legal proceedings. The trial judge found that the contract had been validly novated, allowing Park Cho Holdings Pty Ltd to replace Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd as the purchaser. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd and Park Cho Holdings Pty Ltd appealed to the court. The appeal process involved the consideration of evidence and arguments from both parties regarding the validity of the novation. The court meticulously reviewed the procedural steps, including the original contract, the purported novation, and the trial judge's findings. This appeal was not the first instance of the matter being heard; it followed a lower court decision that had already determined the validity of the novation. The procedural history also includes several interlocutory applications and rulings that shaped the course of the litigation, particularly those that addressed the admissibility of evidence and the interpretation of contractual terms. The outcome of these procedural steps significantly influenced the final determination of the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the contract for the sale of land was effectively novated so that the second appellant replaced the first appellant as the purchaser.

2. Whether the second appellant merely exercised a right to nominate another transferee under the original contract, rather than novating the contract.

3. What are the requirements for an effective novation of a contract by substitution of a party, and were these requirements satisfied in this case?

4. Whether the conduct of the parties and the terms of the agreement between the first and second appellants constitute a novation of the original contract.

5. If the contract was not novated, whether the second appellant has any rights or obligations under the original contract for the sale of land.

Held
1. The court held that the contract for the sale of land was not effectively novated so that the second appellant replaced the first appellant as the purchaser. Appeal dismissed on this issue.

2. The court held that the second appellant did not merely exercise a right to nominate another transferee under the original contract. Appeal dismissed on this issue.

3. The court outlined the requirements for an effective novation of a contract by substitution of a party and concluded that these requirements were not satisfied in this case. Appeal dismissed on this issue.

4. The court held that the conduct of the parties and the terms of the agreement between the first and second appellants did not constitute a novation of the original contract. Appeal dismissed on this issue.

5. The court held that if the contract was not novated, the second appellant has no rights or obligations under the original contract for the sale of land. Appeal dismissed on this issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Fu Tian Fortune Pty Ltd v Park Cho Pty Ltd, the court examined the complex issue of whether a contract for the sale of land was effectively novated so that the second appellant replaced the first appellant as the purchaser. The court meticulously dissected the arguments presented by both parties, focusing on the legal principles and authorities relevant to the concept of novation in the context of land sale contracts.

The central issue of whether the contract was novated or if the second appellant merely exercised a right to nominate another transferee was approached with a careful analysis of the requirements for an effective novation. The court noted that for a novation to be effective, there must be an agreement between all parties involved to discharge the original contract and substitute a new one with a new party. This principle was firmly rooted in established case law, such as the decision in Bolton v Graham, which underscores that novation requires the consent of all parties to the original contract.

The court then scrutinized the terms of the agreement between the first and second appellants. It was essential to determine whether this agreement met the criteria for novation, particularly whether the respondent, Park Cho Pty Ltd, had expressly agreed to the substitution of the second appellant as the purchaser. The court found that the agreement between the appellants did not include the respondent's consent, a critical element for novation as per the principles established in cases like British Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing Co Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Co of London Ltd. This lack of consent was a pivotal factor in the court’s reasoning.

Moreover, the court examined the conduct of the parties and the terms of the agreement to ascertain if they constituted a novation of the original contract. It found that the conduct did not reflect a clear intention to discharge the original contract and replace it with a new one involving the second appellant. Instead, the evidence suggested that the second appellant was merely exercising a right to nominate a transferee under the original contract, a right that did not require the respondent’s consent.

In concluding its analysis, the court confirmed that the contract was not novated. Therefore, it considered whether the second appellant had any rights or obligations under the original contract. Given that the second appellant had not become a party through a valid novation, the court held that the second appellant had no rights or obligations under the original contract for the sale of land. The ratio decidendi of this case is that for a contract to be novated, all parties must consent to the substitution, and the absence of such consent means that the contract remains unchanged with respect to the original parties.

The court’s decision in this case distinguished from prior authority that might have allowed a broader interpretation of novation in similar circumstances. The strict adherence to the requirement of consent from all parties ensures clarity and predictability in land sale transactions, reinforcing the binding legal principle that novation requires unequivocal agreement from all involved parties. This case thus provides a clear guideline for future disputes involving the novation of land sale contracts.