FRYAR & COMMISSIONER for ACT REVENUE (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

FRYAR & COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE (Administrative Review) [2012] ACAT 73 

AT 12/04 & AT 12/09

Catchwords:  ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – liability for land tax under the Rates and Land Tax Act 1926 (repealed) and Land Tax Act 2004 – penalty tax and interest for tax default – onus in relation to objection to tax assessment - whether notice of intention to rent property was received by the Revenue Office – inaccuracies in Applicant’s information – whether Applicant took reasonable care to fulfil tax obligations.

List of legislation:                 ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, s.68

Land Tax Act 2004, ss.8, 9, 14, 15, 19, 19A, 38 &
Part 7 45, 47 & 48

Rates and Land Tax Act 1926

(repealed), ss.22AAB,


           

22A, 22B, 22DA, 22EB, 22EC

Taxation Administration Act 1999

, ss.30, 31, 37, 100,


101, 105 & 107A

List of cases:    Casarotto v Austalian Postal Commission
(1989) 86 ALR 399

Commissioner for ACT Revenue v Dataflex Pty Ltd
  
[2010] ACTSC 117

East v Repatriation Commission (1987) 74 ALR 518,

Jokhan and Johkan v Commissioner for ACT Revenue  
  (Administrative Review)
[2012] ACAT 15

Touma v Commissioner of State Revenue
[2012] NSW ADT 2

Tribunal:         Wilhelmena Corby, Senior Member

Date of Orders:  24 October 2012
Date of Reasons for Decision:         24 October 2012

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     ) AT 12/4 & AT12/9

BETWEEN:

JOANNE HEATHER FRYAR

Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Wilhelmena Corby, Senior Member

DATE:  24 October 2012

ORDER

  1. In relation to application AT 12/04, pursuant to subsection 68 (3)(c)(ii) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACAT Act) the decision under review, being the December 2011 determination, is set aside and remitted to the Respondent for reconsideration in accordance with the following directions:

    a.That for the flat at the O’Connor property (that is, block 12 section 83, O’Connor at 25 Miller Street, O’Connor, ACT), which occupies 20.52% of the dwelling for the purpose of section 22DA of the Rates Land Tax Act 1926 (repealed) (RLTA),

    i.land tax be imposed under section 22A of the RLTA for the period Quarter 3, 2000/2001 to Quarter 4, 2003/2004, and

    ii.penalty tax be imposed pursuant to section 22EB of the RLTA.

    b.That for the flat at the O’Connor property, which occupies 20.52% of the dwelling for the purpose of section 15 of the Land Tax Act 2004 (LTA),

    i.land tax be imposed under section 9 of the LTA for the period Quarter 4, 2004/2005 to Quarter 1, 2007/2008;

    ii.penalty tax pursuant to subsection 19A(5) of the LTA and subsection 31(2) of the Taxation Administration Act 1999 (TAA) be imposed at the rate of 50%.

    c.That land tax be imposed pursuant to section 9 of the LTA on the flat and the house at the O’Connor property for the period Quarter 2, 2007/2008 to Quarter 2, 2010/2011.

    d.That penalty tax pursuant to subsection 19A(5) of the LTA and subsection 31(2) of the TAA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FRYAR & COMMISSIONER for ACT REVENUE (Administrative Review) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] ACAT 73
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Fryer and Commissioner for ACT Revenue, the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal was called upon to review two determinations made by the Commissioner. The first determination, made in December 2011, pertained to the imposition of land tax on a property owned by the applicant, specifically a flat located at O'Connor. The second determination, made in February 2012, involved a separate application by the applicant regarding the same property. The legal issues before the tribunal were whether the Commissioner correctly imposed land tax on the applicant's property and, if not, what the correct tax liability should be.

The tribunal found that the Commissioner had not correctly imposed land tax on the applicant's property. The tribunal set aside the December 2011 determination and remitted it for reconsideration in light of the tribunal's directions. The tribunal concluded that land tax should be imposed on the flat for specific quarters, and penalty tax should also be imposed at a certain rate. Regarding the February 2012 determination, the tribunal upheld the Commissioner's decision.

The tribunal's reasoning was grounded in the statutory provisions governing land tax and the specific circumstances of the property in question. The tribunal considered the application of the legislative framework to the facts, ensuring that the tax imposed aligned with the legal requirements. In setting aside and remitting the first determination, the tribunal provided clear directions to the Commissioner to impose the correct tax and penalty amounts. In affirming the second determination, the tribunal found the Commissioner's decision to be legally sound based on the evidence and arguments presented.

In summary, the tribunal set aside and remitted the December 2011 determination with specific directions for the imposition of land and penalty tax. The February 2012 determination was affirmed, upholding the Commissioner's decision. The tribunal's outcome ensures that the applicant's tax liability is correctly determined in accordance with the relevant legislation.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

In relation to application AT 12/04, pursuant to subsection 68 (3)(c)(ii) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACAT Act) the decision under review, being the December 2011 determination, is set aside and remitted to the Respondent for reconsideration in accordance with the following directions:

a. That for the flat at the O’Connor property (that is, block 12 section 83, O’Connor at 25 Miller Street, O’Connor, ACT), which occupies 20.52% of the dwelling for the purpose of section 22DA of the Rates Land Tax Act 1926 (repealed) (RLTA),

i. land tax be imposed under section 22A of the RLTA for the period Quarter 3, 2000/2001 to Quarter 4, 2003/2004, and

ii. penalty tax be imposed pursuant to section 22EB of the RLTA.

b. That for the flat at the O’Connor property, which occupies 20.52% of the dwelling for the purpose of section 15 of the Land Tax Act 2004 (LTA),

i. land tax be imposed under section 9 of the LTA for the period Quarter 4, 2004/2005 to Quarter 1, 2007/2008;

ii. penalty tax pursuant to subsection 19A(5) of the LTA and subsection 31(2) of the Taxation Administration Act 1999 (TAA) be imposed at the rate of 50%.

c. That land tax be imposed pursuant to section 9 of the LTA on the flat and the house at the O’Connor property for the period Quarter 2, 2007/2008 to Quarter 2, 2010/2011.

d. That penalty tax pursuant to subsection 19A(5) of the LTA and subsection 31(2) of the TAA be imposed for the period Quarter 2, 2007/2008 to Quarter 2, 2010/2011at the rate of 50%.

2.

In relation to application AT 12/09, pursuant to subsection 68(a) of the ACAT Act, the decision under review, being the February 2012 determination is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns the imposition of land tax by the Commissioner for ACT Revenue on a parcel of land known as the O'Connor property located at 25 Miller Street, O'Connor, ACT. The property comprises a flat and a house. The property was leased for residential purposes at various times between Quarter 3, 2000/2001, and Quarter 2, 2010/2011. The land tax in question was imposed under sections 22A and 9 of the Rates Land Tax Act 1926 (repealed) and the Land Tax Act 2004 respectively. The case arose from the applicants' appeal against the Commissioner's determinations regarding the imposition of land tax and penalties for late payment. The applicants argued that the Commissioner had incorrectly determined the periods for which land tax should apply and the associated penalties.

The matter came before the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) as an appeal against the Commissioner's determinations issued in December 2011 and February 2012. The applicants challenged the imposition of land tax and penalties for late payment. The ACAT reviewed the Commissioner's decisions and heard arguments from both parties. The tribunal considered the applicable legislation, including the Rates Land Tax Act 1926 (repealed), the Land Tax Act 2004, and the Taxation Administration Act 1999. The ACAT delivered its decision, setting aside and remitting certain parts of the Commissioner's determination for reconsideration, while affirming other parts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Review of decisions(1)This section applies if the tribunal reviews a decision by an entity.(2)The tribunal may exercise any function given by an Act to the entity for making the decision.NoteA reference to an Act includes a reference to the statutory instruments made or in force under the Act, including regulations (see Legislation Act, s 104).(3)The tribunal must, by order—(a)confirm the decision; or(b)vary the decision; or(c)set aside the decision and—(i)make a substitute decision; or(ii)remit the matter that is the subject of the decision for reconsideration by the decision-maker in accordance with any direction or recommendation of the tribunal. When is something rented for pt 2?(1)For this part, a parcel of land or dwelling is not taken to be rented only because a tenant is liable to pay for rates, land tax, repairs, maintenance or insurance in relation to the parcel or dwelling.NoteFor provision about multiple dwellings on a parcel of land, see s 15.(2)For this part, a parcel of land or dwelling is taken to be rented if it is rented on the 1st day of a quarter.(3)For this part, a parcel of land or dwelling is taken to be rented on the 1st day of a quarter if—(a)it is leased for residential purposes on that day; and(b)it was rented at any time in the previous quarter.(4)However, the parcel of land or dwelling is taken not to be rented on the 1st day of a quarter if—(a)the owner gives written notice to the commissioner before the beginning of the quarter that the parcel or dwelling will not be rented at any time in the quarter; or(b)the owner gives written notice to the commissioner during the quarter that the parcel or dwelling has not been, and will not be, rented at any time in the quarter; or(c)the owner gives written notice to the commissioner after the quarter that the parcel was not rented at any time in the quarter; or(d)the owner gives written notice to the commissioner that the parcel or dwelling was not rented during a continuous period of at least 91 days that—(i)begins in a quarter after the 1st day of the quarter; and (ii)ends in the following quarter.(5)Also, if the owner of a parcel of land becomes the owner on the 1st day of a quarter or during the previous quarter, the parcel is taken to be not rented on the 1st day of the quarter unless—(a)the owner advises under section 14 that the parcel is rented; or(b)the commissioner is otherwise satisfied that the parcel is rented. Imposition of land tax(1)Land tax at the appropriate rate is imposed for a quarter on each parcel of rateable land that is—(a)rented residential land; or(b)residential land owned by a corporation or trustee; or(c)commercial land.(2)The appropriate rate of land tax for a parcel of land is the amount worked out for the parcel as follows: Commissioner to be told if residential land rented(1)This section applies in relation to a parcel of land that—(a)is leased for residential purposes; and (b)is rented by a tenant.(2)A relevant person must tell the commissioner, in writing—(a)that the parcel is rented; and(b)when the rental began.Note 1If a form is approved under the Taxation Administration Act 1999, s 139C, the form must be used. Note 2It is an offence to fail to notify the commissioner under this section (see Taxation Administration Act 1999, s 67 (2)).Note 3It is also an offence to knowingly avoid paying, or disclosing a liability to pay, part or all of an amount of tax (see Taxation Administration Act 1999, s 65 (1)). (3)The relevant person must tell the commissioner the information mentioned in subsection (2) not later than 30 days after—(a)if there is a change of ownership of the parcel—the day the ownership changes; or(b)in any other case—the day the rental begins.(4)This section does not apply if the owner of the parcel of land is a corporation.(5)In this section:relevant person means—(a)the owner of the parcel of land; or(b)if the owner has authorised an agent to act on the owner’s behalf in relation to the rental of the parcel—the agent. Examples—agentaccountant, real estate agent, solicitorNoteAn example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears (see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court reviewed the December 2011 and February 2012 determinations made by the Commissioner for ACT Revenue. The December 2011 determination was set aside and remitted for reconsideration because it did not properly consider the specific percentages of the dwelling that were rented and the corresponding periods for which land tax should be imposed. The court found that the Commissioner had misapplied the relevant provisions of the Rates Land Tax Act 1926 (repealed) and the Land Tax Act 2004. The court provided detailed directions for the reconsideration, specifying the exact periods for which land tax and penalty tax should be imposed based on the correct application of the statutory provisions.

In contrast, the February 2012 determination was affirmed. The court found that the Commissioner had correctly applied the law in this instance, taking into account all relevant factors and statutory provisions. The court was satisfied that the decision was made in accordance with the applicable legislation and that there were no errors warranting a variation or setting aside of the decision.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that when reviewing administrative decisions regarding the imposition of land tax and penalties, the reviewing tribunal must ensure that the decision-maker correctly identifies and applies the relevant statutory provisions and that all material considerations are properly taken into account. Where there are errors in the application of the law or the decision-maker has failed to consider relevant factors, the decision may be set aside and remitted for reconsideration. However, where the decision-maker has correctly applied the law and considered all relevant factors, the decision will be affirmed.