Frugtniet and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

Frugtniet and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) [2017] AATA 1393 (30 August 2017)

Division:TAXATION & COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number:           2013/0717

Re:Rudy Frugtniet

APPLICANT

AndTax Practitioners Board

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr Gordon Hughes, Member

Date:30 August 2017

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

..........................[sgd]..............................................

Dr Gordon Hughes, Member

TAX AGENTS – Termination of registration as a tax agent – applicant prevented from applying for registration for a period of five years – tax practitioner registration requirements – whether a fit and proper person to be registered as a tax agent – decision affirmed

TAX AGENTS – Jurisdiction – whether Board conducted an investigation under Subdivision 60-E of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) – no investigation conducted – investigation unnecessary where Board concerned about whether practitioner was a fit and proper person – Tribunal has jurisdiction

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Evidence – power of Tribunal to have regard to transcript of Tribunal proceedings that were the subject of a successful Federal Court appeal – having regard to transcript not inconsistent with any directions of the Court remitting the matter to the Tribunal to be re-heard

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth); ss 10A, 19A, 19D, 37, 44
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth); ss 251A, 251J(3)
Legal Practice Act 1996 (Vic)
Legal Profession Act 2004 (Vic)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth); s 309(2)

Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth); ss 20-5, 20-15, 20-45, 40-5, 40-25, 60-95, 60-125, 90-1

Tax Agent Services Regulations 2009 (Cth)

Tax Agent Services (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Cth); Item 24 of Sch 2

Cases
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321
Frugtniet v Board of Examiners [2002] VSC 140
Frugtniet v Board of Examiners [2005] VSC 332
Re Frugtniet and Tax Practitioners Board (2014) 148 ALD 401
Frugtniet v Law Institute of Victoria Limited [2012] VSCA 178
Frugtniet v Tax Practitioners Board (2015) 67 AAR 336
Hughes & Vale Pty Ltd v New South Wales (No 2) (1955) 93 CLR 127
Industrial Equity v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1990) 170 CLR 649
Law Institute of Victoria Limited v Frugtniet [2011] VCAT 596
Stasos v Tax Agents’ Board of New South Wales (1990) 21 ATR 974
Su v Tax Agents’ Board, South Australia (1982) 61 FLR 1
Toohey v Tax Agents Board of Victoria (No 2) (2008) 106 ALD 506

Secondary Materials

Administrative Appeals Tribunal, Delegations and authorisations pursuant to subsections 10A(2) and 59A(1) Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, dated 1 July 2015

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Gordon Hughes, Member

30 August 2017

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Frugtniet applied to the Tax Agents’ Board of Victoria (TABV) on 30 May 2008 for registration as a tax agent.  He completed a period of work experience and his application was approved for a period of three years effective from 1 January 2010. 

  2. The Tax Practitioners Board (the Board) was established by the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (the TAS Act) and assumed responsibility for the registration of tax agents…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Frugtniet and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1393
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Frugtniet for registration as a tax practitioner, which was refused by the Tax Practitioners Board. Mr Frugtniet sought review of this decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The dispute centred on whether Mr Frugtniet had provided false or misleading information in his application, and whether he was a fit and proper person for registration, particularly in light of past conduct.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr Frugtniet had knowingly provided false answers to questions in his application for registration. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether his failure to disclose previous decisions by the Board of Examiners and the Supreme Court of Victoria regarding his fitness for admission to legal practice constituted a knowing false answer. Furthermore, the Tribunal had to assess whether Mr Frugtniet was a fit and proper person for registration, having regard to his past conduct, including a VCAT decision finding him disqualified from legal practice for three years due to misrepresentations, and an earlier instance where he failed to disclose pending criminal charges when applying for migration agent registration.

The Tribunal found that Mr Frugtniet had knowingly given false answers to two questions in his application. This conclusion was based on his failure to disclose that the Board of Examiners had not been satisfied of his fitness for legal practice in 2001 and 2005, and that his subsequent appeals to the Supreme Court of Victoria had been dismissed. The Tribunal considered these omissions to be relevant to his fame, integrity, and character. The Tribunal also had regard to the VCAT decision, which found Mr Frugtniet lacked insight into his behaviour and had denied transgressions despite objective evidence. His prior failure to disclose pending criminal charges when applying for migration agent registration further supported the finding that he had not been truthful in his current application.

The Tribunal affirmed the Tax Practitioners Board's decision to refuse Mr Frugtniet's application for registration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In respect of the application to the TABV in 2008, the Tribunal finds that questions 17 and 18 should have been answered differently, in that Mr Frugtniet was obliged to disclose that the Board of Examiners, whose function was similar to a registration authority, had not been satisfied that Mr Frugtniet had established that he was a fit and proper person for admission to legal practice in Victoria in both 2001 and 2005. Similarly, Mr Frugtniet had an obligation to disclose that in each case the Supreme Court of Victoria had dismissed his appeal against the decision. He must have understood that these matters would be relevant to any consideration of his fame, integrity and character, yet he neglected to disclose them. For these reasons, the Tribunal finds that Mr Frugtniet knowingly gave false answers to two of the questions asked of him in his application.The 2011 VCAT decision On 8 April 2011 the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) granted an application by the Law Institute of Victoria and decided that Mr Frugtniet was, for three years, a disqualified person under the Legal Profession Act 2004 (Vic) (Law Institute of Victoria Limited v Frugtniet [2011] VCAT 596). Judge Jenkins, Vice President, stated that Mr Frugtniet had failed to demonstrate any insight into his behaviour and failed to express any responsibility or remorse. Indeed he has denied any transgressions whatsoever, notwithstanding clear and objective evidence. The basis for the decision was that on 25 May 2010, at the Werribee Magistrates’ Court, Mr Frugtniet had deliberately and falsely represented to a Magistrate and a barrister that he was a sole practitioner and solicitor. On 13 August 2012 the Victorian Court of Appeal dismissed Mr Frugtniet’s appeal against the decision other than the finding by VCAT of contempt and VCAT’s decision regarding costs (Frugtniet v Law Institute of Victoria Limited [2012] VSCA 178). Mr Frugtniet offered to the Tribunal partial explanations and stated that he was not acting in a professional capacity at the Magistrates’ Court when he misled the Magistrate and the barrister. He added that the proceedings were preliminary rather than substantive, and he was helping a group of families, but he accepted that he had made an error of judgment. Mr Frugtniet described the episode as a “brain snap” born out of misguided loyalty to a friend in need of legal assistance and emphasised that the period of three years’ disqualification from being a lay associate had expired.Application to the Migration Agents Registration Authority On 27 October 1999 Mr Frugtniet applied to MARA for repeat registration as a migration agent and answered No to a question asking whether he was the subject of criminal charges still pending before a court, or whether he had been convicted of an offence which was not spent. However, at the time, he was the subject of the pending criminal charges concerning his employment with the ANZ Bank. In March 2000, he was acquitted of the charges.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The expression tax practitioner registration requirements is defined in s 90-1 as:tax practitioner registration requirements means the matters about which the Board must, under Subdivision 20-A, be satisfied before the Board is obliged to grant an application for registration under this Act. Subdivision 20-A sets out the eligibility requirements for registration. Section 20-5(1) provides:20‑5Eligibility for registration as registered tax agent, BAS agent or tax (financial) adviserIndividuals(1) An individual, aged 18 years or more, is eligible for registration as a *registered tax agent or BAS agent if the Board is satisfied that:(a)the individual is a fit and proper person; and(b)the individual meets the requirements prescribed by the regulations (including, but not limited to, requirements relating to qualifications and experience) in respect of registration as a registered tax agent or BAS agent; and(c)the individual maintains, or will be able to maintain, professional indemnity insurance that meets the Board’s requirements; and(d)in the case of a renewal of registration – the individual has completed continuing professional education that meets the Board’s requirements. Section 20-15 lists out the criteria for determining whether an individual is a fit and proper person, and provides:20‑15Criteria for determining whether an individual is a fit and proper personIn deciding whether it is satisfied that an individual is fit and proper person, the Board must have regard to:(a)whether the individual is of good fame, integrity and character; and(b)without limiting paragraph (a):(i)whether an event described in section 20-45 has occurred during the previous 5 years; and(ii)whether the individual had the status of an undischarged bankrupt at any time during the previous 5 years; and(iii)whether the individual served a term of imprisonment, in whole or in part, at any time during the previous 5 years. Section 40-25 sets out the period during which a person may not apply for registration, and provides:40‑25Period during which you may not apply for registration(1)If the Board terminates your registration, the Board may also determine a period, of not more than 5 years, during which you may not apply for registration.… Finally, as outlined later in these reasons for decision, Mr Frugtniet raises a jurisdictional issue as a result of an alleged subdivision 60-E investigation by the Board. Subdivision 60-E sets out the provisions for investigations by the Board and relevantly provides:…60‑95Investigations(1)The Board may investigate:(a)your application for registration; or(b)any conduct that may breach this Act; or(c)other matters prescribed by the regulations.(2)The Board must notify you in writing if the Board decides to investigate you. The notice must be given within 2 weeks after the decision is made.(3)An investigation is taken to commence on the date of the notice.…60‑125Outcomes of investigations…Investigation relating to whether conduct breaches this Act(2) If the Board investigates conduct under section 60-95 and finds that the conduct breaches this Act, the Board must either:(a)make a decision that no further action will be taken; or(b)do one or more of the following:(i)impose one or more sanctions under Subdivision 30-B;(ii)terminate an entity’s registration under Subdivision 40-A;(iii)apply to the *Federal Court for an order for payment of a pecuniary penalty under Subdivision 50-C;(iv) apply to the Federal Court for an injunction under section 70-5Note:The Board may terminate an entity’s registration under Subdivision 40-A without investigating conduct under section 60-95Period within which a decision must be made(3)The Board must make a decision under subsection (2):(a)within 6 months after the day on which the investigation is taken to have commenced under subsection 60‑95(3); or(b)if a longer period is determined by the Board under subsection (4)—within that period(4)If the Board is satisfied that, for reasons beyond the control of the Board, a decision under subsection (2) cannot be made within the period mentioned in paragraph (3)(a), the Board may determine a longer period within which the Board must make a decision under subsection (2).(5)If the Board determines a longer period, the Board must do so not later than 2 weeks before the expiry of the period mentioned in paragraph (3)(a).(6)The reasons mentioned in subsection (4), include, but are not limited to, the following:(a)undue delay that has been caused by an entity other than the Board and that has affected the conduct of the investigation to which the decision relates;(b)the complexity of the investigation.Decision not made(7)If:(a)a decision is not made within the period mentioned in paragraph (3)(a) and the Board does not determine a longer period; or(b)the Board determines a longer period but does not make a decision within that period;the Board is taken to have decided to take no further action in relation to the matter that was the subject of investigation.…ISSUES