Freedman Brothers Limited v Scovell

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY A MEMBER

CITATION:

Freedman Brothers Limited v Scovell [2025] NSWPICPD 48

APPELLANT:

Freedman Brothers Limited

RESPONDENT:

Andrew Scovell

INSURER:

Gallagher Bassett Services Pty Ltd

FILE NUMBER:

A1-W29186/24

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:

Deputy President Elizabeth Wood

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:

18 June 2025

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.     Leave to appeal the Principal Member’s Certificate of Determination is granted.

2.     The Principal Member’s Certificate of Determination dated 18 February 2025 is revoked.

3.     The matter is remitted to a non-presidential Member for referral to a Medical Assessor no earlier than seven days after the publication of this decision for assessment in accordance with Order 1 of the referral dated 14 January 2025.

4.     The documents to be included in the referral are:

(a)   the application and attached documents;

(b)   the reply and attached documents (including the surveillance report dated 6 December 2024);

(c)   the surveillance recording undertaken on 27, 28 and 29 November 2024, and

(d)   the supplementary report of Dr Stephen Rimmer dated 23 January 2025.

5.     The respondent (the applicant below) may apply to the Commission within seven days after the publication of this decision in order to make any application in respect of further evidence.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION – Rule 109 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021– whether exceptional circumstances exist for the inclusion of surveillance recordings in the documents provided to the Medical Assessor – Yacoub v Pilkington (Australia) Ltd [2007] NSWCA 290 applied – QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v BTR [2024] NSWPICMP 325; Gandhi v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2022] NSWPIC 475 discussed – NSW Workers Compensation Guidelines for the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 1.43 and 1.44 – medical evidence and assessments to be provided to the Medical Assessor – requirement to include a supplementary report where the medical expert changes his or her opinion expressed in an earlier report – referral for a further assessment pursuant to s 329 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 – Target Australia Pty Ltd v Mansour [2006] NSWWCCPD 286; Inner West Council v McQuade [2025] NSWPICPD 32 discussed

HEARING:

On the papers

REPRESENTATION:

Appellant:

Mr D Talintyre, counsel

HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

Respondent:

Mr A Davis, counsel

Chamberlains Law Firm Pty Ltd

DECISION UNDER APPEAL

PRINCIPAL MEMBER:

Mr J Harris

DATE OF MEMBER’S DECISION:

18 February 2025

INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Andrew Scovell (the respondent) was employed as a stable hand by Freedman Brothers Limited (the appellant). On 19 October 2020 he was feeding one of the appellant’s horses when a horse nearby was startled by the noise of a tractor passing by and reared onto its back hooves. This caused the horse in the care of the respondent to react, and it kicked the respondent in the left knee. The respondent was taken to hospital by ambulance, an x-ray and a CT scan were performed, he was given painkillers and discharged. The respondent then came under the care of a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Freedman Brothers Limited v Scovell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPICPD 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Freedman Brothers Limited sought a determination from the Principal Member regarding the admissibility of surveillance recordings in the context of a workers compensation case. The dispute involved whether the recordings, which were intended to be used as evidence in assessing the respondent's permanent impairment, should be forwarded to the Medical Assessor. The issue arose under Rule 109 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 and required the Principal Member to consider whether there were exceptional circumstances justifying the inclusion of the surveillance material in the documents provided to the Medical Assessor.

The court needed to decide whether the surveillance recording was illegally obtained, and if it was not, whether it should be forwarded to the Medical Assessor in accordance with the relevant rules and guidelines. The Principal Member addressed these issues by first determining that the surveillance recording was not obtained illegally. The subsequent issue was whether the recording should be considered as evidence in the assessment of the respondent's whole person impairment. The Principal Member held that the surveillance recording should not be referred to the Medical Assessor, noting that the doctor who suggested the surveillance believed the respondent was exaggerating his condition. The Principal Member reasoned that the recording would not contribute to a fair assessment of the respondent's impairment, given the different opinions of the medical experts involved.

The Principal Member concluded that the surveillance recording should not be included as evidence in the assessment of the respondent's impairment. This decision was based on the belief that the recording would not provide relevant or reliable information for the assessment and could potentially skew the evaluation. The Principal Member's decision was grounded in the need to ensure that the assessment of the respondent's impairment was based on credible and relevant evidence. The Principal Member's decision did not result in any specific orders but addressed the procedural issue of whether the surveillance recording should be forwarded to the Medical Assessor.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The power to order a further assessment or reconsideration of a medical assessment lies in accordance with s 329 of the 1998 Act, which provides as follows:“329 Referral of matter for further medical assessment or reconsideration(1) A matter referred for assessment under this Part may be referred again on one or more further occasions for assessment in accordance with this Part, but only by—(a)the President as an alternative to an appeal against the assessment as provided by section 327, or(b)a court of the Commission.(1A) A matter referred for assessment under this Part may be referred again on one or more further occasions by the President to the medical assessor for reconsideration.(2) A certificate as to a matter referred again for further assessment or reconsideration prevails over any previous certificate as to the matter to the extent of any inconsistency.” The dispute about the admission of the surveillance recording was listed for an urgent arbitration hearing before the Principal Member on 14 February 2025, given that the appointment for the respondent to attend the Medical Assessor was listed for 18 February 2025. The arbitration was adjourned and listed for further hearing on 17 February 2025. The first issue to be determined was whether the surveillance recording had been illegally obtained. The Principal Member determined that the surveillance recording was not obtained illegally. The second issue was whether the surveillance recording should be forwarded to the Medical Assessor to be considered as evidence relevant to the assessment of the respondent’s whole person impairment, or whether it should be excluded, in accordance with r 109 of the 2021 rules. The Principal Member discussed and heard submissions in relation to whether the surveillance recording should be referred to the Medical Assessor, recorded in the transcript of proceedings dated 17 February 2025 (T) from T4.29 to T7.21 and then again from T13.13 to T30.28. The Principal Member then proceeded to deliver ex tempore reasons for his determination that the surveillance recording should not be referred to the Medical Assessor.[15] He observed that Dr Rimmer suggested to the appellant that surveillance of the respondent should be undertaken because he was of the view that the respondent was exaggerating his condition. He noted that the respondent was to be assessed in respect of his whole person impairment of the left leg following the total left knee replacement. He referred to the points system used to assess the loss and said that one of the main components of the assessment was the degree of pain.[15] T32.8–T43.20. The Principal Member noted that Dr New had assessed the respondent as having a permanent impairment of 30% based upon a poor outcome from the surgery, and that Dr Rimmer had originally assessed the result as a fair outcome with an impairment of 20%, but then changed his opinion to a good result, which attracted 15% (sic, 14%) whole person impairment.