Fredericks v BHP Australia Coal Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

No 106 of 1994

Mackay District Registry

[Fredericks v. BHP Australia Coal Pty Ltd]

BETWEEN:

JOHN KENNETH FREDERICKS

(Plaintiff)

AND:

BHP AUSTRALIA COAL LIMITED

(Defendant)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WILLIAMS J

Judgment delivered 22/05/1997

The plaintiff claims damages for personal injuries arising out of an incident he asserts occurred on 18 December 1992 in the course of his employment with the defendant.
           There was no dispute that in about April 1980 the plaintiff sustained an injury to his back which necessitated surgical intervention and resulted in his being off work for about 22 months.  It is clear that he worked for the defendant, frequently in the capacity of bulldozer driver, from February 1982 until 18 December 1992 without any apparent problems.  There is also no doubt that when he finished work on the morning of 19 December 1992 he was complaining of pain in his lower back.
           Thereafter he was on workers' compensation for a period and he returned to work on 19 April 1993.  He undertook a variety of tasks but continued to experience low back pain.  Ultimately he accepted an early retirement package.  Dr Coroneos concluded that the plaintiff had an impairment in the efficient function of his lumbar spine of the order of 25%, and apportioned 60% of that to the events of 1980 and 40% to the event of 1992.
           It is not necessary to say more about the plaintiff's back condition and its affects on his lifestyle because quantum has been agreed in the sum of $288,995.35 after deducting the refund to the Workers' Compensation Board.
           The defendant however denies liability.  It admits the plaintiff suffered from pain at the end of the shift on 18 December 1992 but denies any incident such as that pleaded in the amended statement of claim.  Unless the plaintiff established the incident pleaded and the negligence of the defendant he will not succeed.
           Much time was taken during the hearing with conflicting evidence as to the stability of the pad on which the dragline was standing on the night in question.  In the end, resolution of that issue has no direct bearing on the question of negligence.  Whether or not there were cracks in the pad the real issue was what happened whilst the plaintiff was operating the bulldozer.  However, the issue as to the stability of the pad does reflect on the credibility of witnesses, particularly the plaintiff.
           All witnesses agreed that instability of the pad was a critical issue for both employees and management.  The safety of workers and the safety of the dragline, a costly piece of equipment, were directly in issue.  In conformity with the requirements of the General Rules for Open Cut Mines 1988 regular inspections of the operations had to be made and formal reports completed.  There is nothing in those reports of 17-18 December, or in the days following, to suggest that the pad in question was of doubtful stability.  There was nothing to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fredericks v BHP Australia Coal Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QSC 185
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, John Kenneth Fredericks, claims damages for personal injuries sustained in the course of his employment with BHP Australia Coal Pty Ltd, asserting that an incident on 18 December 1992 caused his injuries. Fredericks had a history of back issues dating back to an injury in April 1980, which required surgery and resulted in an extended period off work. He returned to employment with the defendant in February 1982, performing duties including operating a bulldozer. Fredericks alleges that on the morning of 19 December 1992, he experienced lower back pain, leading to a period of workers' compensation before his eventual early retirement. He contends that the defendant was negligent in failing to maintain secure conditions at the site, specifically failing to contain falling rocks, and that this negligence led to his injury.

The legal issues the court needed to address were whether the defendant was negligent in the maintenance of the work site and if such negligence led to Fredericks' injury. The court needed to determine whether the plaintiff's account of the incident was credible and if it was a result of the defendant's negligence. This involved examining the evidence regarding the conditions of the work site, the stability of the pad on which the dragline was standing, and the specific incident Fredericks described, where he claimed to have hit a rock with the bulldozer, causing his injury.

The court found that there was no evidence of any cracking in the pad on the night in question, and Fredericks did not report any such issues to relevant witnesses. The court was not convinced that the rock in question fell from the high wall as Fredericks claimed. The evidence suggested that the rock could have been dislodged by the operations of the bulldozer or dragline, or it could have fallen earlier. The court concluded that Fredericks' account of the incident was speculative and not supported by the evidence. It was not established that the contact with the rock caused his injury, given his pre-existing back condition and the nature of the work he performed. The court dismissed Fredericks' claim, finding that he failed to prove the defendant's negligence or that it caused his injuries.

The court ordered that Fredericks' claim be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established