Fraser Coast Regional Council v Alderton

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Fraser Coast Regional Council v Alderton [2020] QIRC 001

PARTIES:

Fraser Coast Regional Council
(Applicant)

v

Alderton, Sally
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

TD/2018/40

PROCEEDING:

Application for costs

DELIVERED ON:

8 January 2020

HEARING DATE: 

18 November 2019
Applicant's Submissions - 02 December 2019
Respondent's Submissions - 16 December 2019
Applicant's Reply Submissions - 20 December 2019

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Thompson IC

Brisbane and on the papers

ORDER:

1.   The application for costs is granted.

2.   The Respondent is to pay the Applicant's costs as follows:

(i)         Application for reinstatement (TD/2018/40) being $8347.20; and

(ii)       Application in existing proceedings being $626.20.

INDUSTRIAL LAW - APPLICATION FOR REINSTATMENT - APPLICATION FOR COSTS - where application by respondent for reinstatement refused - where respondent afforded procedural fairness and natural justice - where respondent refused offer of settlement - where respondent put on notice applicant would seek costs if she continued to prosecute her application - whether application without reasonable cause or reasonable prospects of success - whether the refusal of the settlement offer was vexatious or without reasonable cause

LEGISLATION:

Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 316, s 317, s 320, s 322, s 530, s 545

Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld)

CASES:

Alderton v Fraser Coast Regional Council [2019] QIRC 137

Kanan v Australian Postal and Telecommunications Union (1992) FCA 366, 43 IR 257
State of Queensland (South West Hospital and Health Service) v Tania Crews-Bradley [2016] QIRC 093
Colin Ferry v GHS Regional WA Pty Ltd T/A GHS Solutions [2016] FWC 3120

Alderton v Fraser Coast Regional Council [2019] QIRC 058

State of Queensland (Department of Justice and Attorney-General, Queensland Corrective Services) v Timmins (No 2) [2018] QIRC 117

Marriage v Devine Ltd [2005] 178 QIRC 118

Walters v BT Equipment Pty Ltd (No 2) [2002] 169 QGIG 227

Latoudis v Casey [1990] 170 CLR 534
Gambaro v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2017] ICQ 005
Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) v Chapman [2015] QIRC 086
O'Reilly v Coco's Trading Pty Ltd [2003] 173 QGIG 337

APPEARANCES:

Mr D. Chen of NB Lawyers for the Applicant.
Ms S. Alderton, Respondent.

Reasons for Decision

Background

  1. This is an application in existing proceedings filed on 16 October 2019 by Fraser Coast Regional Council (the Council/Applicant) pursuant to s 545 of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (the IR Act), seeking costs against Ms Sally Alderton (Alderton/Respondent) in respect of a decision issued by the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (the Commission) as constituted on 17 September 2019, refusing Ms Alderton's application for reinstatement in matter TD/2018/40[1].

  2. The Applicant seeks the following decision:

    (a) the Applicant applies to the Commission for an Order pursuant to s 545(2)(a) of the IR Act that the Respondent pay the costs incurred by the Applicant in responding to the Respondent's application for reinstatement filed in the Industrial Registry on 12 April 2018;

    (b)      pursuant to paragraph 178 of the Decision delivered on 17…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fraser Coast Regional Council v Alderton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QIRC 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fraser Coast Regional Council has applied for costs against Alderton pursuant to section 545(2) of the Industrial Relations Act 1996 (Qld) on the basis that the application for reinstatement brought by Alderton was vexatious, without reasonable cause or had no reasonable prospect of success. The dispute was heard before the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission and a decision was made on 17 September 2019. In that decision, the Commission found that the allegations against Alderton were substantiated and the termination of her employment was justified, and her application for reinstatement was refused. The question for the Commission in the current proceedings is whether the application for costs should be granted. The Commission found that the application for costs should be granted on the basis that Alderton made her application without reasonable cause and without reasonable prospects of success, and she unreasonably rejected settlement offers. The Commission ordered that Alderton pay the costs of the application for reinstatement as well as the costs of the current proceedings. The total amount of the costs ordered is $9073.40.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for costs is granted.

2. The Respondent is to pay the Applicant's costs as follows:

(i) Application for reinstatement (TD/2018/40) being $8347.20; and

(ii) Application in existing proceedings being $626.20.

Background

Background to the litigation

The following chronology supporting the application for costs is extracted from the information deposed by Mr Chen in his affidavit filed in the Commission on 16 October 2019:Initial Events· I received instructions to represent the Applicant on 26 November 2018 and filed a Form 36 - Notice of Change of Lawyer or Agent with the Industrial Registry on the same date.· I reviewed the documents provided by the Applicant and formed a view that the Respondent had little to no prospects of success having regard to the documented evidence which demonstrated that the Applicant had afforded the Respondent procedural fairness and natural justice at all material times and that the conduct engaged in by the Respondent was sufficiently serious, as a whole to justify termination of employment.· I was instructed by the Applicant to make a "Without Prejudice" settlement offer of eight (8) weeks' gross pay to the Respondent.· The offer put the Respondent on notice that her application had no reasonable prospects of success and that the Applicant would seek costs against her if she continued to prosecute her application.· On 14 December 2018, I served on the Respondent a Form 23 - List of Documents in accordance with the Amended Further Directions Order dated 29 November 2018.· On 19 December 2018, the Respondent sent me correspondence by way of email indicating that she was rejecting the offer provided on 11 December 2018 and proposed a counter-offer of twenty (20) weeks' gross pay.· On 20 December 2018, I spoke to Ms Caitlin Noble, Employee Relations Manager of the Applicant in respect of the Respondent's counter-offer. I informed Ms Noble that the counter-offer was quite close to the statutory limit prescribed by s 322 of the IR Act and therefore only likely to be awarded in compelling applications. Having regard to the little prospects of success of the Respondent's application I advised that twenty (20) weeks' pay was unlikely to be awarded by the Commission.· Ms Noble advised that the highest offer she was authorised by the Applicant to advance to the Respondent was twelve (12) weeks' gross pay and provided instructions to make an offer to the Respondent on such terms. I considered these instructions to be putting the Applicant's best offer forward to the Respondent.· On 21 December 2018, I served on the Respondent the documents she requested from the Applicant's Form 23 - List of Documents.· Later on 21 December 2018, I sent correspondence to the Respondent rejecting her counter‑offer dated 19 December 2018 and making a further "Without Prejudice" settlement offer of twelve (12) weeks' gross pay.· The offer put the Respondent on notice that the Applicant would incur significant costs in defending the application and the Applicant would be relying on the offer to seek a costs order in the event the Respondent's application is determined by the Commission to have been brought vexatiously, without reasonable cause, without reasonable prospects of success or in circumstances where the Respondent obtains a result that is less beneficial than the offer.· On 4 January 2019, the Respondent sent me correspondence by way of email indicating that she was rejecting the offer provided on 21 December 2019 and proposed a counter-offer of twenty (20) weeks' gross pay. This was the same position in the Respondent's correspondence dated 19 December 2018, however the Respondent provided general comments on the substantive application.· By 4 January 2019, the Respondent had access to the documents that were to be relied upon by the Applicant in the substantive proceedings (and she had been provided a number of documents as requested). Accordingly, the Respondent was in a better position to consider the merits of her application.· On 11 January 2019, I was instructed by the Applicant to send email correspondence to the Respondent rejecting her counter-offer dated 4 January 2019. I was not instructed to make a counter-offer given the Applicant's offer dated 21 December 2018 was their best offer and was rejected by the Respondent.· The email correspondence reiterated that the Applicant would incur significant expense in defending the Respondent's application and put her on notice that her unreasonable rejection of a genuine settlement offer would be used to form the basis of an application for costs in the event she was unsuccessful.· No further communications in respect of offers to settle were made by the Applicant after 11 January 2019.· On Friday 5 April 2019, I attended a mention before the Commission. During the course of the mention, the Commission drew the Respondent's attention to the Unfair dismissal and reinstatement application guide (the Guide) published by the Commission in consideration of the Respondent's status as a self-represented litigant.· The Respondent informed the Commission that she was "very familiar with the guide".· Given the Respondent's assertion that she was familiar with the Guide, a reasonable inference can be drawn that she was familiar with the relevant considerations of the Commission in determining an application made under s 317 of the IR Act, specifically the provisions contained in s 320 of the IR Act.· Part 3.2 of the Guide, which the Respondent indicated she was "very familiar" with, sets out the basis on which the Respondent's application would have been decided upon having regard to s 320 of the IR Act.Events at the Hearing· The Respondent's application was allocated for a three (3) day hearing (Hearing) in Hervey Bay from Tuesday 18 June 2019 to Thursday 20 June 2019. I continued to act for the Applicant as their solicitor advocate for the duration of the Hearing.· During the course of the Hearing, a number of issues became reasonably apparent that demonstrated the Respondent's application had been brought without reasonable cause, having regard to the fact that the onus was on the Respondent to establish, by way of evidence, that her dismissal was unfair within the meaning of s 320 of the IR Act. Some of the issues are briefly summarised as follows:(a)in respect of the Respondent's assertion that employees of the Applicant had "corroborated" against her in an attempt to have her cease employment, the Respondent readily conceded that she had "no evidence" to support her assertion.(b)in respect of the Respondent's assertion that a change in her position description was bullying, undermining and applied pressure for the Respondent to cease her employment, the Respondent readily conceded that the change in position description had "very little impact".(c)leading a large amount of irrelevant material during the Hearing more applicable to a Workcover claim as opposed to the Respondent's application for reinstatement.(d)continuing to disagree with the decision of Local Government Workcare (LGW) and the subsequent review of its decision by the Office of Industrial Relations that the Deed of Settlement offered on 20 October 2017 by the Applicant did not constitute unreasonable management action. In any event, the Deed of Settlement was irrelevant to the Respondent's application.(e)making assertions, without any apparent basis, that Ms Noble had falsified the written warning issued on 2 May 2017.(f)adopting a misconceived view that the Applicant should have issued a final written warning prior to making a decision to terminate the Respondent's employment which is contradictory to a plain reading of the Applicant's Discipline Procedure which does not compel the Applicant to issue a final written warning if circumstances are sufficiently serious to justify termination of employment; and(g)at all material times, the Respondent had been offered the opportunity to bring a support person, access to the Applicant's Employee Assistance Program, provided an opportunity to respond to the allegations against her, provided extension of time to respond in addition to paid time off to respond in October 2017.· I understand the words "without reasonable cause" used in s 545(2)(a)(i) of the IR Act to refer to an application where on the Applicant's own version of facts, it is clear that the proceeding must fail having regard to the comments of Wilcox J in Kanan v Australian Postal and Telecommunications Union[3].[3] Kanan v Australian Postal and Telecommunications Union (1992) FCA 366, 43 IR 257.· The matters listed in paragraphs (a)-(g) of this Affidavit support an inference that a significant number of the Respondent's arguments were unsupported by evidence or otherwise irrelevant to the application which may give rise to a finding the application must fail. This is particularly so given that:(a)the matters listed in paragraphs (a)-(g) were reasonably within the knowledge of the Respondent at the time of the application;(b)the Respondent had previously acknowledged, prior to the Hearing, that she was aware of the Guide and therefore the relevant considerations for her application for the reasons set out above in this Affidavit; and(c)notwithstanding her knowledge, she persisted with her application.· The issue of an unreasonable refusal of a settlement offer was considered in the matter of State of Queensland (South West Hospital and Health Service) v Tania Crews-Bradley[4] which was an application for costs before the Commission. In this Decision, O'Connor DP referred to comments made by Williams C in the matter of Colin Ferry v GHS Regional WA Pty Ltd T/A GHS Solutions that:"failure to accept the offer of settlement involved the continuation of proceedings in wilful disregard of known facts and also was an imprudent refusal of an offer to compromise and this delinquent conduct warrants the Commission exercising its discretion to award indemnity costs".[5]· In the circumstances, the Respondent's conduct in rejecting two (2) offers of settlement despite being in full knowledge she did not have evidence to support her application and relitigating medical issues that had been rejected by LGW and the Office of Industrial Relations (which was in any event irrelevant) suggests she wilfully disregarded known facts and imprudently refused a reasonable offer of settlement. This is a factor in favour of the exercise of discretion by the Commission to order costs against the Respondent.· The Applicant reserves its right to make further submissions upon appropriate directions being issued by the Commission for an application for costs pursuant to s 545(2) of the IR Act.· On that basis and for the reasons set out above, the Applicant requests that appropriate directions be made by the Commission as referred to by the Commissioner in his Decision for matter TD/2018/40 dated 17 September 2019[6].[4] State of Queensland (South West Hospital and Health Service) v Tania Crews-Bradley [2016] QIRC 093.[5] Colin Ferry v GHS Regional WA Pty Ltd T/A GHS Solutions [2016] FWC 3120, [75].[6] Alderton v Fraser Coast Regional Council [2019] QIRC 137.Background

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Costs should be awarded in favour of the Applicant.ConclusionBackground On 17 September 2019 the Commission (as constituted) released a decision in which an application for reinstatement (by the Respondent in these proceedings) was refused. In doing so, the Commission found that:· the allegations relevant to the conduct engaged in by Alderton were reasonably open to be substantiated by the decision maker;· the disciplinary process engaged in by the decision maker had been compliant with the legislative and policy procedures relevant to the circumstances with Alderton being afforded procedural fairness and natural justice at all times;· the penalty of termination was warranted in circumstances where the conduct and behaviour displayed by Alderton over an extensive period of time had breached the Council's Code of Conduct;· the decision to terminate Alderton's employment effective from 22 March 2018 was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable; and· the application for reinstatement is refused.[14][14] Alderton v Fraser Coast Regional Council [2019] QIRC 137.General Powers to award costs In the course of the substantive proceedings the Applicant (in this proceeding) foreshadowed the filing of an application for costs pursuant to s 545(2) of the Act that was subsequently lodged with the Industrial Registry on 16 October 2019. In essence the Applicant relied upon the conduct of the Respondent in the substantive matter which was said to have enlivened s 545(2)(a)(i) and (ii) of the Act in that:(i) the party made the application or responded to the application vexatiously or without reasonable cause; or(ii) it would have been reasonably apparent to the party that the application or response to the application had no reasonable prospect of success . . . With regard to "reasonable cause" it was argued that on her own version of the facts it was the case that the reinstatement application was without substantial prospects of success as there has been a range of informal and formal warnings given over a period of time regarding the failure to comply with the Code of Conduct, and the claim that other employees had "corroborated" against her to bring about the termination of her employment was not supported by any evidence to that effect. Other matters relied upon in the prosecution of the reinstatement application were clearly of no relevance in establishing the termination had been harsh, unjust or unreasonable and this was known to the Respondent at the time of commencing the action against the employer. These included:· changes to her position description which had no material impact on her employment and were not associated with the termination;· the offer of a "without prejudice" Deed of Settlement to exit the employment in October 2017 which had been found to be reasonable management action in another place;· the claim that the Employee Relations Manager had falsified a written warning without any reason, which was ultimately determined to be "spurious in nature"; and· she had not been offered procedural fairness and natural justice which was not the case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.