Fraser & Anor v. Beaudesert Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

[2008] QPEC 21

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

JUDGE RACKEMANN

No 911 of 2007

MICHAEL WILLIAM FRASER and
CHERRYL MARIE FRASER
Appellants

and

BEAUDESERT SHIRE COUNCIL & ORS Respondent

BRISBANE

..DATE 24/04/2008

JUDGMENT

HIS HONOUR:  This is an applicant appeal against conditions attaching to the council's approval of an application for an extractive industry, namely a sand mine at Mundoolun Connection Road, Boyland on land more particularly described as Lot 58 on Crown Plan W31869 and Lot 74 on Registered Plan 897486 County of Ward, Parish of Logan.

The approval was for a development permit for material change of use for an extractive industry and for environmentally relevant activities.  The approval will authorise sand mining activities extracting up to 350,000 tonnes per annum over the life of the permit.  The sand mine is an existing operation which has historically been operated under an earlier approval and extensions thereof. 

The planning history is summarised in the planning and development committee report, which is Exhibit 11A.  There is no need to dwell on that detail.  In 2003 the council purported to refuse an extension of the earlier approval, prompting the subject application to be made later the same year.  Sand mining has continued to date, notwithstanding.  There is an unresolved appeal and an application for declarations in respect of the council's refusal to renew.  While making no formal admission, counsel for the appellant was prepared for the application to be treated as if it were one to regularise an activity which has been carried on without appropriate approvals. 

The subject site falls within a rural area but has some proximity to an area of rural residential properties.  The subject approval will authorise the sand mining activity to continue for the life the permit, will permit activities to expand into a new part of the site and will also permit extraction at rates higher than previously approved. 

That is set against a background where it would seem that previous operations have not, in all respects, been in conformity with the earlier approval and the council has not, in all respects, been effective in promptly securing compliance.  Past compliance issues are also summarised in the Planning and Development Committee report, the details of which I need not dwell upon. 

It should be acknowledged that neither the recommending officer, nor the parties to this appeal, contend that the non compliance issues should preclude approval of the operation of the sand mine.  These issues do however, underlie residual concerns held by the objectors and in particular by Mr Copely, to ensure that the conditions of approval provide an appropriate and effective mechanism for controlling future operations. 

The sand mine is obviously a significant operation in the context of the locality.  Public notification of the application attracted a relatively large number of submissions and a number of submitters elected to become co-respondents to this appeal.  The matter was the subject of extensive alternative dispute resolution through the Courts' ADR registrar.  This led to a resolution of all issues…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fraser & Anor v. Beaudesert Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QPEC 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fraser & Anor v Beaudesert Shire Council [2008] QPEC 21 involved an appeal against conditions attached to a council's approval of a sand mine at Mundoolun Connection Road, Boyland. The appeal was brought by Michael William Fraser and Cheryl Marie Fraser, the applicants, against the Beaudesert Shire Council, the respondents. The primary dispute centred around the appropriate duration for the operation of the sand mine permit, with the applicants advocating for a 12-year period and Mr. Copely, one of the co-respondents, pushing for a shorter timeframe, specifically not extending beyond 2017.

The court had to determine the appropriate duration for the sand mine's operation permit, considering the planning provisions and the need for flexibility while ensuring effective management and compliance. The court considered the views of independent town planners, who supported a 12-year period based on the application documents, planning perspectives, and the improbability of significant changes within that timeframe. The court examined the relevance of the predicted resource life and extraction rates, but emphasized the importance of the terms of approval in managing the operation and ensuring compliance.

In its reasoning, the court acknowledged the importance of the sand mine resource, as recognized in both local and state planning provisions. These provisions aimed to protect the resource from incompatible developments. The court concluded that a 12-year period was appropriate, considering the terms of the approval, the nature and situation of the use, and the relative likelihood of significant changes within that timeframe. The court also noted that ensuring compliance through the conditions of approval was a more effective way to achieve the desired level of control over the sand mine operations.

The final orders were made subject to an amendment in the draft order, which was initialled by the judge and placed with the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.