HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Dixon C.J., Menzies and Owen JJ.
FRANOV v. DEPOSIT AND INVESTMENT CO. LTD.
30 August 1962
Bills of Sale (N.S.W.)
Bills of Sale (N.S.W.)—Trader's bill of sale—Power in bill to seize or take possession of chattels subject of bill—Filing or recording—Date from &hich bill operative and valid—Bills of Sale Act, 1898-1938 (N.S.W.), s. 5C*.
Decisions
August 30.
The following written judgments were delivered:-
DIXON C.J. This appeal from a decretal order made on an originating summons by Jacobs J. was argued upon two grounds. The purpose of the originating summons was to obtain an injunction against the enforcement by the defendant Deposit &Investment Company Limited of a trader's bill of sale bearing date 2nd May 1960 given to that company by the defendants Julianna Ramljak and Josip Ramljak, described as sandwich and milk bar proprietors, carrying on business at 468 Pitt Street, Sydney. The plaintiffs Franov and Sarin sued as the present proprietors of the business including the fixtures furniture and chattels covered by the bill of sale. According to an affidavit of the plaintiff Franov he entered into negotiations with the defendant Josip Ramljak to buy from him a half share in the business and fixtures and fittings. He entered into those negotiations on 12th May 1960, that is to say, ten days after the date which the bill of sale bears. He says that an agreement resulted on the following day for him to buy a half share in the business, fixtures and fittings for the sum of 2,000 pounds and to enter into a partnership with the defendant Josip Ramljak on that day and that he then paid it. He says that on 18th May 1960 he entered into a written agreement to carry on the business as a partner with Ramljak, and that he expended 2,500 pounds in renovation and re-equipment of the partnership premises, the defendant Josip Ramljak contributing nothing. The premises were leased by the Railway Commissioner to Ramljak as lessee. He, Franov, then sought to raise money from, as it happened, the defendant company. Then for the first time he learned of the bill of sale given by the defendants Ramljak. In the affidavit Franov says that he immediately saw Ramljak about the bill of sale but the latter said it was none of his business. He told Ramljak to go away and have nothing more to do with the business and he did not see him again for some weeks. The business was in fact closed from 28th January 1961 until 21st June 1961 for lack of funds. But in June the plaintiff Franov brought in Sarin to assist him in re-opening the shop. A man from the defendant company came on 20th June 1961 and told the plaintiffs that no moneys had been paid under the bill of sale and that there was about 700 pounds principal and interest in arrear. The two plaintiffs thereupon paid the company 415 pounds and a fortnight…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Franov v Deposit and Investment Co Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1962] HCA 45
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the mortgage, which was executed by the plaintiff in reliance on representations made by the defendant's agent, was voidable due to fraudulent misrepresentation. Specifically, the court had to determine if the agent's conduct amounted to fraud in the context of the transaction and, if so, whether this fraud rendered the mortgage void ab initio or merely voidable.
The court's reasoning focused on the distinction between fraud in the factum and fraud in the treaty. It was held that for a deed to be void ab initio, the misrepresentation must be as to the nature of the document itself, meaning the party signing did not understand they were executing a deed of that kind. In this case, the plaintiff understood she was signing a mortgage document, even if the representations inducing her to do so were fraudulent. Therefore, the fraud was in the treaty, not in the factum, making the mortgage voidable rather than void. The principles of agency were also considered, with the court examining whether the agent's fraudulent conduct could be attributed to the defendant in a way that would vitiate the mortgage from its inception.
The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the order of the Supreme Court. The mortgage was declared voidable, and the plaintiff was granted leave to amend her statement of claim to seek rescission of the mortgage.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case hinges on two main issues: the validity of the bill of sale before it was filed or recorded, and the enforceability of the contract of loan due to an error in the stated interest rate. The first issue concerns the interpretation of s. 5C(1) of the Bills of Sale Act, 1898-1938 (N.S.W.), which states that a trader's bill of sale shall not be operative or have any validity until it has been filed or recorded. The plaintiffs argued that the bill of sale could not be operative or valid before it was filed or recorded on 17 May 1960. They contended that since Franov obtained his interest in the partnership and its assets on 12 or 13 May 1960, he took priority over the interest obtained by the defendant company under the bill of sale. The second issue pertains to a discrepancy in the stated interest rate in the memorandum of the contract of loan, which was deemed to be accidental or due to inadvertence and not likely to mislead or deceive any person to their prejudice or disadvantage under s. 22(4) of the Money-Lenders and Infants Loans Act, 1941-1948 (N.S.W.). The High Court allowed the appeal, holding that the bill of sale did not have any validity until it was filed or recorded on 17 May 1960 and did not become retrospectively valid or operative. The Court also held that the misdescription of the interest rate in the contract of loan did not render the contract unenforceable. The case was remitted to the Supreme Court for further consideration.
The matter came before the High Court of Australia as an appeal from a decretal order made on an originating summons by Jacobs J. in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiffs, Franov and Sarin, sought an injunction against the defendant company from enforcing a trader's bill of sale executed by the Ramljak partners over their business assets. Jacobs J. dismissed the summons, leading the plaintiffs to appeal to the High Court. The appeal was heard on two grounds: the interpretation of the Bills of Sale Act, 1898-1938 (N.S.W.) concerning the validity of the bill of sale before its recording, and an alleged error in the interest rate stated in the loan contract under the Money-lenders and Infants Loans Act, 1941-1948 (N.S.W.). The High Court found merit in the first ground, holding that the bill of sale could not have retrospective validity until it was recorded, thereby allowing the appeal and remitting the case back to the Supreme Court for further consideration. The second ground concerning the interest rate was dismissed as the error was deemed accidental and not misleading.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether a trader's bill of sale becomes operative and valid upon being filed or recorded, or whether it becomes valid and operative retrospectively from the date of its execution once the filing or recording condition is met.
2. Whether the incorrect statement of the interest rate in the memorandum of the loan contract, as required by the Money-Lenders and Infants Loans Act, 1941-1948 (N.S.W.), renders the contract unenforceable.
3. If the appeal is upheld, what order should be made to dispose of the suit in light of the legal determinations.
Held
1. The court held that a trader's bill of sale does not become operative and valid upon being filed or recorded, but rather becomes valid and operative retrospectively from the date of its execution once the filing or recording condition is met. As such, the bill of sale in question did not have any validity at law or in equity until 17th May 1960, and did not become retrospectively valid or operative.
2. The court held that the incorrect statement of the interest rate in the memorandum of the loan contract, as required by the Money-Lenders and Infants Loans Act, 1941-1948 (N.S.W.), did not render the contract unenforceable. The court found that the error was accidental or due to inadvertence and was not of such a nature as to mislead or deceive any person to their prejudice or disadvantage.
3. The court allowed the appeal, discharged the decree or order of the Supreme Court, and declared that the bill of sale did not have any validity at law or in equity until 17th May 1960, and did not become retrospectively valid or operative. The cause was remitted to the Supreme Court to be dealt with consistently with the declaration according to law. The interlocutory order made by the court to protect the plaintiffs' claim pending the appeal and to restrain the defendant company from enforcing the bill of sale pending the appeal was continued. All questions of costs in the court were reserved to be dealt with by the court on application by either party.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court's decision in Franov v Deposit and Investment Co Ltd centred on two primary issues regarding the enforceability of a trader's bill of sale. Firstly, the Court examined when a trader's bill of sale becomes operative and valid. The Court determined that the bill of sale only becomes valid and operative upon being filed or recorded, and does not operate retrospectively from the date of its execution. This conclusion was reached by closely considering the statutory language and legislative intent behind the Bills of Sale Act, 1898-1938 (N.S.W.). The Court noted that the use of the word "until" in section 5C(1) of the Act suggests that validity and operation commence only upon filing or recording, aligning with the ordinary meaning of the term. The Court rejected the alternative interpretation that the bill of sale becomes valid from the execution date once the filing or recording condition is met, finding it contrary to the strict protective policies of the Act meant to safeguard existing creditors.
Secondly, the Court addressed whether an incorrect statement of the interest rate in the memorandum of the loan contract, as required by the Money-Lenders and Infants Loans Act, 1941-1948 (N.S.W.), rendered the contract unenforceable. The Court found that the small error in the interest rate calculation, which amounted to less than 1% and would not mislead or deceive any party, did not invalidate the contract. The Court applied section 22(4) of the Money-Lenders and Infants Loans Act, which provides that minor omissions or errors that do not prejudice any party can be overlooked. Thus, the contract remained enforceable despite the minor error in the interest rate statement.
In light of these determinations, the Court allowed the appeal, set aside the order dismissing the suit, and declared that the bill of sale did not have any validity until it was filed or recorded on 17th May 1960. The Court ordered the case to be remitted to the Supreme Court for further consideration, noting that additional issues needed to be addressed. The interlocutory order protecting the plaintiffs and restraining the defendant company from enforcing the bill of sale pending the appeal was continued. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a trader's bill of sale does not operate retrospectively and becomes valid only upon filing or recording, and minor errors in required documentation, if not prejudicial, do not render a contract unenforceable.