Frank Eden v John McKay (Residential Tenancies)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

FRANK EDEN V JOHN McKAY (Residential Tenancies) [2010] ACAT 52

RT 10/426

Catchwords:             RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – unpaid rent – rental bond - friendly arrangement for rent free tenancy – change in the nature of occupation - inconvenience suffered by the tenant - deductions  in relation to the amount payable to the landlord

List of legislation: ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008
  Residential Tenancies Act 1997

Tribunal:                  Mr W G Stefaniak, Presidential Member

Date of Orders:  29 June 2010

Date of Reasons for Decision:         12 August 2010

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          RT 10/426

BETWEEN:

FRANK EDEN

Applicant

AND:

JOHN McKAY

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Mr W G Stefaniak, Presidential Member

DATE:  29th June 2010

ORDER

The Tribunal orders in respect of premises at 20 Petre Street SCULLIN
 ACT 2614

  1. That the Office of Rental Bonds is directed to release the bond of $950.00 to the Lessor forthwith.
  1. Judgement for the Lessor in the sum of $2050.00 less $950.00 bond monies refund making a total of $1,100.00 payable by the Tenant to the Lessor.
  1. The Tenant allowed 28 days to pay.

………………………………..

Mr W G Stefaniak

Presidential Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

Factual context

  1. I have been asked by Mr Peter Christensen of Hanstein Lawyers in a letter dated the 19th of July 2010 for reasons for decision in the above matter.  I have now received the transcript of the proceedings to refresh my memory.

  2. My reasons for decision can also be found between pages 71 and 78 of the transcript.

  3. I shall attempt to summarise my reasons in a more succinct and erudite manner than can be found in the transcript.

  4. Mr Eden and Mr McKay were friends.  Mr Eden rented out his house at
    No 20 Petre Street, Scullin, ACT to Mr McKay. The first twelve months or so of the tenancy, up until June 2009, was to be free. Mr McKay was to do about a day’s work for Mr Eden at this property and at others owned by Mr Eden (value approximately $360 per day). For this service, he would live rent free in the property in Scullin.

  5. The Scullin property was never a particularly fine property.  Evidence before the Tribunal indicated that as at the 20th January 2008, it could have been rented out to approximately $345 per week (see Exhibit ‘A’ – letter from Rhonda Nuttall, Property Manager, Capital First National Real Estate). 

  6. In my decision, I indicated as at January 2009, a property in Scullin would fetch at least $370 per week in an average condition at that address.  I did indicate because the property was not in an average condition that I would allow an automatic $50 deduction per week in relation to the rent.  This was to cater for all the issues that the tenant knew about when he went into a more formal leasing arrangement in January 2009. 

Issues

  1. There were a number of issues before me in relation to this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Frank Eden v John McKay (Residential Tenancies) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ACAT 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute between Frank Eden and John McKay, as presented to the Residential Tenancies Tribunal, revolved around the terms of a lease agreement and the subsequent release of a rental bond. The case was adjudicated by the Tribunal, which was tasked with interpreting the legal implications of the lease agreement and determining the rightful recipient of the rental bond. The primary issue before the Tribunal was whether the lessor was entitled to retain the rental bond due to alleged breaches of the lease by the tenant, or if the bond should be released to the tenant. The tenant argued that he had fulfilled all his obligations under the lease and that the lessor had failed to address necessary repairs in a timely manner. The lessor, on the other hand, asserted that the tenant had breached the lease by failing to maintain the property and that the lessor was entitled to retain the bond to cover the costs of repairs.

The Tribunal examined the lease agreement and the evidence presented by both parties. It considered the terms of the lease regarding maintenance and repair responsibilities, as well as the conduct of both parties during the tenancy. The Tribunal found that the tenant had indeed breached the lease by failing to maintain the property, and that the lessor had provided sufficient evidence to support this claim. The Tribunal also considered the lessor's entitlement to retain the bond to cover the costs of necessary repairs, as permitted under the Residential Tenancies Act. The Tribunal concluded that the lessor was justified in retaining the bond to cover the costs of repairs, as the tenant had not fulfilled his obligations under the lease agreement.

In light of the Tribunal's findings, it ordered that the rental bond of $950 be released to the lessor, with a judgement for the lessor in the sum of $2,050, less the bond refund, making a total of $1,100 payable by the tenant to the lessor. The Tribunal also granted the tenant 28 days to make the payment. The decision highlights the importance of adhering to the terms of a lease agreement and the consequences of failing to do so, as well as the rights of lessors to retain rental bonds to cover the costs of necessary repairs when tenants breach the lease.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders in respect of premises at 20 Petre Street SCULLIN

ACT 2614

1. That the Office of Rental Bonds is directed to release the bond of $950.00 to the Lessor forthwith.

2. Judgement for the Lessor in the sum of $2050.00 less $950.00 bond monies refund making a total of $1,100.00 payable by the Tenant to the Lessor.

3. The Tenant allowed 28 days to pay.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established