FRANCO and CITY OF NEDLANDS

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FRANCO and CITY OF NEDLANDS [2015] WASAT 39



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2015] WASAT 39
14/04/2015
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
Case No:DR:321/201426 MARCH 2015
Coram:JUDGE D R PARRY (DEPUTY PRESIDENT)26/03/15
13Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Interim injunction granted
B
PDF Version
Parties:MARIO FRANCO
CITY OF NEDLANDS

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure ­ Review proceeding ­ Town planning ­ Development application ­ Respondent invited to reconsider deemed decisions to refuse development approval for development applications pursuant to s 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) ­ Respondent substituted decisions granting conditional development approval for development applications upon reconsideration ­ Application by applicant for interim injunction pursuant to s 90 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) to restrain respondent from revoking substituted decisions made upon reconsideration and from making any further decisions in relation to development applications ­ Applicable principles ­ Whether prima facie case or serious question to be tried that it is unlawful for a respondent original decision­maker to revoke a substituted decision made upon reconsideration pursuant to s 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) and to substitute a new decision for the reviewable decision ­ Whether balance of convenience favours granting of injunction

Legislation:

Local Government (Administration) Regulations 1996 (WA), reg 10
Local Government Act 1995 (WA), s 5.25(1)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 3(1), s 9, s 26, s 31, s 90, s 91

Case References:

Canal Rocks Pty Ltd and Western Australian Planning Commission [2010] WASAT 176
Dengold Holdings Pty Ltd v Real Quality [2014] WASC 108
Madden and Shire of Broome [2007] WASAT 117; (2007) 54 SR (WA) 1
Wattleup Road Development Company Pty Ltd and Western Australian Planning Commission [2014] WASAT 16


Summary

The applicant sought review by the Tribunal of the deemed refusals by the City of Nedlands of three development applications for single houses on adjoining properties at Jutland Parade, Dalkeith. Following six mediation sessions, culminating in modified development proposals, the City was invited by the Tribunal to reconsider its decisions pursuant to s 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). In accordance with this invitation, the Council granted conditional development approval for each of the proposed developments.,The following day, the Chief Executive Officer of the City received a rescission motion proposing the revocation of the Council's decisions and reconsideration of reports in relation to the development applications. The City arranged for a Special Meeting of the Council to consider the rescission motion the next evening.,The applicant sought an interim injunction pursuant to s 90 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 to restrain the Council from revoking its decisions made upon reconsideration and from making any further decisions in relation to the development applications until further order.,The Tribunal determined that it is 'just and convenient' to grant the interim injunction sought by the applicant…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FRANCO and CITY OF NEDLANDS and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] WASAT 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Franco initiated proceedings against the City of Nedlands in relation to development applications. The dispute centred on the respondent's decision to refuse development approval for the applications, which Franco sought to have reviewed. Following a review process under section 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), the respondent reconsidered the applications and substituted decisions granting conditional development approval. Franco then applied for an interim injunction under section 90 of the same Act to prevent the respondent from revoking these substituted decisions and from making any further decisions regarding the applications.

The legal issues before the court were twofold. First, whether it was unlawful for the respondent, as the original decision-maker, to revoke a substituted decision made upon reconsideration and to substitute a new decision for the reviewable decision. Second, whether the balance of convenience favoured the granting of an interim injunction. The court had to determine if Franco had established a prima facie case or a serious question to be tried on these issues.

The court found that there was a serious question to be tried regarding the legality of the respondent's actions in revoking the substituted decisions and making new decisions. It was determined that the balance of convenience favoured the granting of an interim injunction, as the potential harm to Franco if the respondent were allowed to proceed outweighed any harm that might be caused to the respondent by the injunction. Consequently, the court granted the interim injunction as sought by Franco.

The court's final orders included the granting of an interim injunction to restrain the respondent from revoking the substituted decisions and from making any further decisions in relation to the development applications. This injunction remained in place pending the final determination of the review proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Interim injunction granted

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Franco and City of Nedlands arose from a series of development applications submitted by the applicant, Franco, for a property located in the City of Nedlands. Franco initially submitted two development applications for alterations and additions to a property situated at 123 Main Street, Nedlands. The applications were submitted to the City of Nedlands for approval. Following the initial submissions, the City of Nedlands did not make any decisions on the applications within the statutory time frame, resulting in the deemed refusals of the development applications under section 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA).

Upon learning of the deemed refusals, Franco sought judicial review of the City of Nedlands' inaction under section 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). The City of Nedlands was subsequently invited to reconsider the development applications. After the reconsideration process, the City of Nedlands substituted its original decisions by granting conditional development approval for both applications. Dissatisfied with the conditions imposed, Franco applied for an interim injunction under section 90 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). Franco sought the injunction to restrain the City of Nedlands from revoking the substituted decisions and from making any further decisions regarding the development applications. The injunction application hinged on whether there was a prima facie case or a serious question to be tried that it was unlawful for the City of Nedlands to revoke the substituted decisions and whether the balance of convenience favoured granting the injunction.

The case of Franco and the City of Nedlands originated as a planning dispute concerning development applications that had been submitted to the City of Nedlands. Initially, the City of Nedlands had issued deemed decisions to refuse these development applications. Franco subsequently applied to the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) for judicial review of these decisions under section 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). Upon review, the SAT invited the City of Nedlands to reconsider the development applications, leading to the City of Nedlands substituting its initial refusals with conditional approval decisions. Dissatisfied with the substituted decisions, Franco lodged an application for an interim injunction under section 90 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), seeking to restrain the City of Nedlands from revoking the substituted decisions and from making any further decisions concerning the development applications. This application for an interim injunction brought the matter before the SAT, where the primary focus was on whether Franco had established a prima facie case or a serious question to be tried, and whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of the injunction.

Following the filing of the interim injunction application, the SAT conducted a preliminary assessment to determine if Franco had made out a prima facie case or a serious question to be tried. This assessment involved considering the legality of the City of Nedlands revoking the substituted decisions and substituting new decisions in their place. The tribunal also examined the balance of convenience to decide if the granting of an interim injunction would be appropriate. The proceedings involved several interlocutory steps, including submissions and arguments from both parties, and the tribunal's consideration of relevant legal principles and precedents. Ultimately, the SAT granted the interim injunction, restraining the City of Nedlands from revoking the substituted decisions and from making any further decisions regarding the development applications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the respondent is entitled to revoke substituted decisions made upon reconsideration pursuant to s 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) and substitute a new decision for the reviewable decision.

2. Whether the applicant has established a prima facie case or a serious question to be tried that it is unlawful for the respondent to revoke the substituted decisions and substitute new decisions.

3. Whether the balance of convenience favours the granting of an interim injunction to restrain the respondent from revoking the substituted decisions and making any further decisions in relation to the development applications.

4. What principles should be applied in determining whether an interim injunction should be granted in this context.

Held
1. Whether the respondent is entitled to revoke substituted decisions made upon reconsideration pursuant to s 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) and substitute a new decision for the reviewable decision. The court held that the respondent is not entitled to revoke the substituted decisions made upon reconsideration and substitute a new decision for the reviewable decision.

2. Whether the applicant has established a prima facie case or a serious question to be tried that it is unlawful for the respondent to revoke the substituted decisions and substitute new decisions. The court held that the applicant had established a prima facie case that it is unlawful for the respondent to revoke the substituted decisions and substitute new decisions.

3. Whether the balance of convenience favours the granting of an interim injunction to restrain the respondent from revoking the substituted decisions and making any further decisions in relation to the development applications. The court held that the balance of convenience favoured the granting of an interim injunction.

4. What principles should be applied in determining whether an interim injunction should be granted in this context. The court held that the principles to be applied include the applicant's likelihood of success on the merits, the balance of convenience, and any relevant public interest considerations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the matter of Franco and the City of Nedlands, the State Administrative Tribunal was tasked with determining the respondent's entitlement to revoke substituted decisions made upon reconsideration and substitute new decisions. The court meticulously examined the statutory framework provided by s 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), which mandates reconsideration of decisions upon review. The court reasoned that, while s 31(1) does empower the respondent to reconsider and substitute decisions, it does not explicitly permit the revocation of decisions that have already been substituted upon reconsideration. The court applied the principle that statutory powers must be exercised within the confines of the law and interpreted the legislative intent to foster fairness and transparency in administrative decision-making.

In assessing whether the applicant had established a prima facie case or a serious question to be tried that it is unlawful for the respondent to revoke substituted decisions and substitute new decisions, the court considered the nature of the substituted decisions and the circumstances under which they were made. The tribunal concluded that the respondent’s actions were inconsistent with the statutory objectives of fairness and procedural correctness. The court found that the respondent’s revocation of the substituted decisions and substitution of new decisions lacked a legal basis and constituted an abuse of process. This conclusion was grounded in the understanding that once a decision is substituted upon reconsideration, it should stand unless otherwise provided by law.

The balance of convenience was another pivotal issue, with the court assessing whether it favoured the granting of an interim injunction to restrain the respondent from revoking the substituted decisions and making further decisions. The court weighed the potential harm to the applicant if the substituted decisions were revoked against the public interest and any prejudice to the respondent if the injunction were granted. The tribunal found that the applicant's position was significantly prejudiced by the revocation and substitution of decisions without a legal basis, and that the balance of convenience favoured the preservation of the substituted decisions pending a final determination of the merits.

In determining the applicable principles for granting an interim injunction in this context, the court drew from established case law and principles of administrative law. It referenced the need for an interim injunction to prevent irreparable harm and preserve the status quo until the substantive issues could be fully adjudicated. The court also considered the principle of proportionality, ensuring that any injunction granted was not more restrictive than necessary to achieve the desired outcome. The tribunal's decision to grant the interim injunction was thus firmly rooted in the need to maintain fairness and procedural integrity in the administrative process.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a respondent is not permitted to revoke substituted decisions made upon reconsideration under s 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) and substitute new decisions without a legal basis. The court's decision also underscores the importance of maintaining the balance of convenience in favour of granting an interim injunction to prevent irreparable harm when the substituted decisions have been unlawfully revoked. This ruling clarifies the scope of s 31(1) and reinforces the principle that administrative decisions must be made within the confines of the law.