Francis v Christies Beach Medical Centre

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

Equal Opportunity Tribunal

(District Court Administrative and Disciplinary Division)

FRANCIS v CHRISTIES BEACH MEDICAL CENTRE

[2013] SAEOT 1

Judgment of His Honour Judge Costello (ex tempore)

16 January 2013

DISCRIMINATION LAW

Application by the respondent for an order from the Tribunal dismissing the Complaint.  No reasonable possibility of Complaint, alleging discrimination within the meaning of the Act, being made out.  Complaint dismissed.

Equal Opportunity Act (SA) 1984; Limitation of Actions Act 1936, referred to.
Ellson v PB Taxi Co Ltd & Anor [2008] SAEOT 6; Pazios v Pulteney Grammar School [2008] SAEOT 7; Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioner (1949) 78 CLR 62; A.G v Wenthworth (1988) 14 NSWLR 481, 487, considered.

FRANCIS v CHRISTIES BEACH MEDICAL CENTRE
[2013] SAEOT 1

INTRODUCTION

  1. In this matter the respondent has applied for an order dismissing the complaint.

  2. The Tribunal has power to dismiss a complaint at any stage of the proceedings.[1]  In considering the test to be applied with respect to an application to dismiss a complaint, I am content to adopt the approach taken by various divisions of this Tribunal namely that the applicant for dismissal must show that the complaint is lacking in merit, in that there is no likelihood of success of the complaint.[2]

  3. In the context of an application made at a preliminary stage in the proceedings, I must be satisfied that the view that the complaint has no likelihood of success is one which could not be altered by any evidence which could be adduced at trial.[3]

    The Applicant’s Case for Dismissal

  4. The applicant puts its case on two bases.  First, that many of the “facts” alleged or adverted to by the complainant in her initial Complaint and subsequent Further and Better Particulars, relate to allegations which occurred a number of years ago and in any event, more than 12 months prior to the lodging of the complaint in July 2012.  As such, it is said that the complaint is “out of time”.[4]

    [4] See S 93(2) of the Act.

  5. Although the Act provides the Commissioner with power to extend the time for lodging a complaint (s 93(2)(b)), no application was made to the Commissioner to extend the time and no such order has been made by the Commissioner.

  6. On reading the Complaint and the Further and Better Particulars, it is apparent that many of the concerns (to use a neutral term) raised by the complainant, relate to issues more than 12 months prior to the lodging of the Complaint.  In response the complainant points to the provisions of s 93(2)(a) of the Act which permit (in circumstances where the alleged contraventions are constituted by a series of acts) a Complaint to be lodged within 12 months of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Francis v Christies Beach Medical Centre and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] SAEOT 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Francis v Christies Beach Medical Centre, the respondent sought an order from the Tribunal to dismiss the complaint filed by the complainant, Francis, who alleged discrimination by the medical centre. The Equal Opportunity Tribunal (EO Tribunal) considered the application under the Equal Opportunity Act 1984, determining whether there was a reasonable possibility of the complaint being substantiated. The primary legal issue was whether the complaint, which included allegations of discrimination based on disability, identity, appearance, and race, disclosed any facts that could establish a breach of the Act. The respondent argued that the complaint was time-barred and lacked merit.

The Tribunal examined the timeliness of the complaint, noting that some allegations predated the statutory limitation period. The Tribunal concluded that the concept of a series of acts under the Act did not extend to separate acts by unrelated bodies. Additionally, the Tribunal found that the complaint did not adequately support claims of discrimination on the grounds of identity, appearance, or race. Regarding disability, the Tribunal observed that the treatment provided to the complainant appeared consistent with standard medical practice, and no evidence suggested unfavorable treatment based on disability.

The Tribunal ultimately found the complaint to be both frivolous and vexatious, lacking any reasonable possibility of success. This conclusion was based on the absence of credible evidence supporting the discrimination claims and the failure to meet the criteria set out in the Act. Consequently, the Tribunal dismissed the complaint, noting that the application for dismissal could be upheld even without considering the power to extend time under the Limitation of Actions Act 1936. The Tribunal emphasized that the complaint did not disclose any material suggesting unlawful discrimination.

The formal order issued by the Tribunal was that the complaint was dismissed, and no further action would be taken regarding the allegations made by Francis against Christies Beach Medical Centre.