Francis Plumbing & Gasfitting Pty Ltd v Davine

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND APPEALS LIST

S ECI 2023 06084

FRANCIS PLUMBING & GASFITTING PTY LTD Plaintiff
v
PROFESSOR DAVID HUNTER-SMITH First Defendant
and
ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR MICHAEL LEUNG Second Defendant
and
SHAUN DAVINE Third Defendant

---

JUDGE:

O’Meara J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

23 August 2024

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

6 September 2024

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Francis Plumbing & Gasfitting Pty Ltd v Davine & Ors

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2024] VSC 538

---

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Judicial review – Medical panel opinion – Left forearm injury in the course of employment on 2 October 2020 – Surgery performed in respect of extensor tendons and superficial radial nerve – Subsequent treatment in outpatient clinic – Substance abuse and mental health issues – Prior and subsequent injuries, including prior opinion of differently constituted medical panel in respect of different left limb injury in 2018 – Claim for impairment benefit in respect of 2020 injury – Worker disputed assessment based on report of consultant rheumatologist – Referral of medical questions to a medical panel – Differences between the history to the panel and the results of the panel’s assessments and those of the earlier medical panel and subsequent consultant rheumatologist – Panel opinion in respect of whole person impairment – Employer claims denial of procedural fairness and other or related errors – Wingfoot Australia Partners Pty Ltd v Kocak (2013) 252 CLR 480; Wagstaff Cranbourne Pty Ltd v Hashimi [2020] VSCA 33; Akbari v Victorian WorkCover Authority & Ors [2022] VSC 84; and Noureddine v Adlard [2022] VSC 719 considered and discussed – Proceeding dismissed.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff M Norton SC with
CN Viney
Hall & Wilcox
For the First Defendant No appearance
For the Second Defendant No appearance
For the Third Defendant PA Czarnota with
Y Al-Azzawi
Arnold Thomas & Becker

HIS HONOUR:

A.       Introduction

  1. The third defendant (‘Worker’) was born on 19 December 1990 and seems to have resided at all material times in the Latrobe Valley.

  1. In April 2018, he was working at an abattoir outside Moe when he suffered a left volar forearm injury in an incident involving a knife (‘2018 injury’).  On 22 December 2021, a medical panel assessed the Worker as having suffered a 7% whole person impairment resulting from the ‘accepted left wrist relevant to claimed left forearm and scarring injury’ (‘2021 panel’).

  1. On 2 October 2020, the Worker was in employment with the plaintiff (‘Employer’) as a handyman/labourer.  He sustained a dorsal left forearm injury when a drop saw came into contact with his arm (‘2020 injury’).  There was a gaping laceration and extensive damage to the extensor muscle tendon unit as well as the superficial radial nerve.  The Worker underwent surgery the following day and subsequently attended the outpatient clinic.

  1. The Worker had difficulty when he returned to employment.  He also seems…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Francis Plumbing & Gasfitting Pty Ltd v Davine and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] VSC 538
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Francis Plumbing & Gasfitting Pty Ltd v Davine, the parties were engaged in a dispute concerning the assessment of a worker’s claim for an impairment benefit related to a left forearm injury sustained during employment on 2 October 2020. The injury necessitated surgery for extensor tendons and superficial radial nerve, with follow-up treatment at an outpatient clinic. The respondent, Davine, had a history of substance abuse and mental health issues, and had previously been the subject of a medical panel opinion regarding a different injury to a left limb in 2018. The employer disputed the assessment based on the report of a consultant rheumatologist. The medical questions were referred to a medical panel, but there were discrepancies between the history provided to the panel and the results of their assessments compared to those of the earlier medical panel and the consultant rheumatologist. The case came before the court to determine whether the employer's claims of procedural unfairness and other errors were valid.

The court was tasked with determining whether the process followed in the assessment of the worker’s impairment was fair and whether the employer's claims of procedural unfairness and other related errors were substantiated. The legal issues encompassed whether the employer had been afforded procedural fairness in the assessment process and whether there were any material errors in the decision-making process. The court considered relevant cases such as Wingfoot Australia Partners Pty Ltd v Kocak, Wagstaff Cranbourne Pty Ltd v Hashimi, Akbari v Victorian WorkCover Authority & Ors, and Noureddine v Adlard to evaluate the principles of procedural fairness and the nature of errors that could render a decision unjust.

The court reviewed the evidence and concluded that the employer had not demonstrated that the process was unfair or that there were any material errors in the decision-making process. The court found that the differences in medical opinions were addressed appropriately and did not indicate a failure to adhere to principles of procedural fairness. The court emphasised that the medical panel's assessment was based on a comprehensive evaluation and that the employer had not provided sufficient grounds to overturn the panel's decision. Consequently, the court dismissed the proceeding, affirming the decision of the medical panel regarding the impairment benefit assessment.

In light of the findings, the proceeding was dismissed. The court determined that the employer had not successfully demonstrated procedural unfairness or material errors in the assessment of the worker’s impairment benefit claim. The employer’s claims were rejected, and the decision of the medical panel was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.