Francis Cullen and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

[2013] AATA 578

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Numbers

2011/3056 and 2012/3700

Re

Francis Cullen

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Miss E A Shanahan, Member 

Date 16 August 2013  
Place

Melbourne

1.The Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision of 17 August 2012 in application no  2012/3700; and

2.The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision of 20 July 2011 in application no 2011/3056 and in substitution decides that:

a.in accordance with s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act) the Respondent is liable to pay compensation to the Applicant in respect of the claim for right supraspinatus tear with subacromial bursitis; and

b.The Applicant is entitled to payment for incapacity under section 19 of the Act as of 21 May 2011 and at the present date on the basis that his ability to earn in any particular week is equal to his actual earnings from employment as a school crossing supervisor with the Baw Baw Shire Council; and

3.The Respondent shall pay the Applicant’s reasonable costs and disbursements of the proceedings in accordance with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal General Practice Direction.

[sgd]........................................................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member 

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS' COMPENSATION – shoulder injury – secondary or separate psychological injury – termination of entitlement to compensation – alternative employment – continuing disability and incapacity for work – availability of suitable employment.

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 sections 4, 5A, 5B, 14, 16, 19 and 24

Cases

Abrahams v Comcare (2006) 93 ALD 147

Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535

Comcare v Mooi (1996) 69 FCR 439

Secondary Materials

The Comcare Guide to the Assessment of Degree of Permanent Impairment (2nd Edition)

The American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th Edition)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

16 August 2013

  1. On 1 August 2011 Mr Francis Cullen lodged an application for a review of Australia Post’s reviewable decision dated 20 July 2011 (application no 2011/3056 – Exhibit R1).  The decision denied any current liability for Mr Cullen’s right shoulder injury, eventually diagnosed as a right supraspinatus tear and subacromial bursitis. Mr Cullen had sustained the right shoulder injury at work on 9 October 2007, and Australia Post had initially accepted liability on 13 November 2007.

  2. On 27 August 2012 Mr Cullen lodged a further application for a review of Australia Post’s decision of 17 August 2012 (application no 2012/3700 – Exhibit R3), denying liability for an adjustment disorder with anxiety and depressed mood.

  3. Mr Cullen sought a review of a third Australia Post decision (application no 2012/0923 – Exhibit R2).  He withdrew this application on 13 May 2013. 

  4. Mr Cullen was represented by Mr Mark Carey of Counsel, instructed by Mr Stuart Coutts of Maurice Blackburn Solicitors. Australia Post was represented by Ms Cathy Dowsett of Counsel, instructed by Mr Damian Clarke of Clarke Legal. The Tribunal was provided with three sets of documents pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Exhibits…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Francis Cullen and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 578
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) involved a dispute between Francis Cullen and the Australian Postal Corporation. Mr Cullen, who had been employed by Australia Post, suffered a right shoulder injury in the course of his duties and subsequently claimed compensation for the injury and related psychological effects. The case was presided over by the AAT, which had to determine the liability of Australia Post in relation to Mr Cullen's injury and his entitlement to compensation for the physical injury and any psychological impact arising from it.

The primary legal issues the AAT had to resolve included whether Australia Post was liable for Mr Cullen's right shoulder injury, and if so, the extent of this liability. Additionally, the Tribunal had to assess whether Mr Cullen's psychological condition constituted a compensable injury under the applicable legislation, and if so, whether it was related to his physical injury or an independent condition. The Tribunal also had to consider the appropriate compensation for both the physical and psychological injuries.

In its decision, the AAT first acknowledged Australia Post's liability for Mr Cullen's right shoulder injury. It then turned to the question of the psychological condition. The AAT considered the opinions of various medical experts, who had differing views on the nature and extent of Mr Cullen's psychological injury. While some experts diagnosed an adjustment disorder, others did not find a significant impact on Mr Cullen's capacity for work. The Tribunal ultimately found that Mr Cullen's psychological condition, while acknowledged, did not meet the threshold for a compensable injury under the legislation. The AAT also noted that the psychological injury was not to be considered as a sequelae of the physical injury for the purposes of determining compensation.

Consequently, the AAT affirmed the reviewable decision regarding the physical injury but set aside the decision concerning the psychological injury. It ordered Australia Post to compensate Mr Cullen for the physical injury and for incapacity from a certain date, based on Mr Cullen's actual earnings from his employment as a school-crossing supervisor. The Tribunal also directed Australia Post to pay Mr Cullen's reasonable costs and disbursements of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Cullen was represented by Mr Mark Carey of Counsel, instructed by Mr Stuart Coutts of Maurice Blackburn Solicitors. Australia Post was represented by Ms Cathy Dowsett of Counsel, instructed by Mr Damian Clarke of Clarke Legal. The Tribunal was provided with three sets of documents pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Exhibits R1, R2 and R3). Both parties tendered further documents, a list of which is attached as an appendix to this decision. Mr Cullen, Dr John Gill, Mr Thomas Kossman, Mr Ian Jones, Mr Paul Hartley and Professor George Mendelson gave oral evidence before the Tribunal.BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION Mr Cullen commenced employment with Australia Post in June 1999 as a mail officer. After a four-year apprenticeship, Mr Cullen had worked first as a painter, in Public Works and Police Department building maintenance; then as a storeman and packer; and then in truck body works, which involved painting, riveting, wiring and roofing of semi‑trailers. Mr Cullen’s first position at Australia Post was in mail sorting. In July 2006 he transferred to the position of a Postal Transport Officer initially on a casual basis and then permanently. Mr Cullen usually worked between the hours of 11:00 pm and 7:40 am. Initially, Mr Cullen lived in Pearcedale and worked at the Dandenong Transport Facility. In December 2007 he moved to a property in Central Gippsland in Trafalgar East. As a transport officer he worked from the Dandenong Facility and this involved considerable driving to and from work. On 9 October 2007, while transporting mail to and from Dandenong to the Australia Air Express office at Tullamarine, he experienced pain in his right shoulder while unloading mail. Mr Cullen lodged an incident report on 12 October 2007 (Exhibit R1, T3) and subsequently lodged a claim for compensation on 16 October 2007 (Exhibit R1, T5). The stated injury was pain in right shoulder. Mr Cullen had seen his general practitioner, Dr Vicki Miezis, on 12 October 2007. Dr Miezis referred him for an ultrasound of the right shoulder and certified his attendance but did not declare him unfit for work at Mr Cullen’s insistence (Exhibit R1, T21). The ultrasound, conducted on 16 October 2007 revealed a high-grade partial thickness tear in the anterior aspect of Mr Cullen’s right supraspinatus tendon, with subacromial bursal thickening, suggesting bursitis (Exhibit R1, T6). On 13 November 2007 Australia Post accepted liability for Mr Cullen’s right shoulder injury. Dr Miezis referred Mr Cullen to Mr Andrew Weber, an orthopaedic surgeon, for an opinion. Mr Weber advised conservative treatment in the form of physiotherapy but continued to review Mr Cullen. As part of this review, several ultrasounds of the right shoulder were performed. Following the ultrasound findings of 22 April 2008, coupled with Mr Cullen’s failure to improve with physiotherapy, Mr Weber advised surgical intervention. On 22 May 2008 Mr Cullen was involved in a motor vehicle accident. However, there was no evidence that this had an impact on his right shoulder injury.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal asked Mr Cullen what type of saddle he used when horse riding. Mr Cullen estimated his saddle weighed 6 kilograms. The Tribunal also asked whether the reason he worked the night shift at Australia Post was in order to provide more care to his disabled children. Mr Cullen said he had elected to work night shift for purely financial reasons. ORAL EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL Mr Cullen’s evidence, including the content of his proof of evidence, is summarised above under BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION.Dr John Gill Dr Gill is a psychiatrist who saw Mr Cullen on 28 August 2012 at the request of the Applicant’s solicitors (Exhibit A1). On the history obtained from Mr Cullen, Dr Gill dated the onset of his symptoms of worsening mood from the time he was given a poor prognosis regarding his shoulder by Mr Ashley Carr. Mr Cullen described himself as worried, irritable, short-tempered and suffering from insomnia, but had benefited from his counselling with Mr Gary Lawler. Dr Gill recorded that Mr Cullen’s speech was somewhat halting and vague, but he did not stutter as had been claimed. Dr Gill diagnosed an adjustment disorder with depressed and anxious mood, secondary to the physical injury and its negative prognosis. However, he did not believe this affected Mr Cullen’s capacity for work or employment. Dr Gill estimated a whole person impairment, on psychological grounds alone, of 5% in accordance with The Comcare Guide to the Assessment of Degree of Permanent Impairment (2nd Edition) (the Comcare Guide). In his evidence before the Tribunal, Dr Gill confirmed his written opinion. However, when informed that Mr Cullen had suffered from insomnia since he commenced shift work, Dr Gill considered this information reduced the significance of insomnia as a symptom of an adjustment disorder.Mr Paul Hartley Mr Hartley conducted a vocational assessment of Mr Cullen on 11 March 2013 (Exhibit R2). He assessed Mr Cullen’s education, training and experience, and job availability and suitability within the relevant geographical location at a reasonable driving distance. Having addressed all possibilities in detail, Mr Hartley concluded there were currently no further suitable employment options for Mr Cullen other than his current role as a school-crossing supervisor on a very part-time basis. Despite recommending Mr Cullen could benefit from an intense multi-disciplinary pain management program, Mr Hartley was of the opinion that the combined effects of Mr Cullen’s right shoulder disability and persistent pain, essentially renders Mr Cullen unavailable for work. Mr Thomas Kossman Mr Kossman, an orthopaedic surgeon, saw Mr Cullen on 19 September 2012 (Exhibit A3). Mr Kossman obtained the already known history in relation to Mr Cullen’s right shoulder. On examination, Mr Kossman found significant restriction of the right shoulder range of movement, leading to a whole person impairment rating of 11 per cent, in accordance with the Comcare Guide. Mr Kossman regarded Mr Cullen’s prognosis as poor and that he may ultimately be a candidate for a right shoulder replacement procedure.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Dr Markov, Dr Gill and Professor Mendelson have all recommended that Mr Cullen could benefit from a multi-disciplinary pain management program in order to increase his work capacity. The Tribunal notes that Mr Cullen has not been offered or participated in a structured rehabilitation program.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision of 17 August 2012 in application no 2012/3700; and The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision of 20 July 2011 in application no 2011/3056 and in substitution decides that:a.in accordance with s 14 of the Act, the Respondent is liable to pay compensation to the Applicant in respect of the claim for right supraspinatus tear with subacromial bursitis; and b.The Applicant is entitled to payment for incapacity under s 19 of the Act as of 21 May 2011 and at the present date, on the basis that his ability to earn in any particular week is equal to his actual earnings from employment as a school‑crossing supervisor with the Baw Baw Shire Council; and The Respondent shall pay the Applicant’s reasonable costs and disbursements of the proceedings in accordance with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal General Practice Direction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Dowsett pointed out that while Drs Gill and Markov and Professor Mendelson had advised that Mr Cullen participate in a multi-disciplinary pain management program to be paid for by Australia Post, this was not before the Tribunal, as no claim for, or a decision in respect of, such treatment had been the subject of a reviewable decision. THE TRIBUNAL’S DELIBERATIONS Ms Dowsett submitted that the Tribunal is bound to follow the decision of the High Court in Canute and consider Mr Cullen’s claimed physical and psychological conditions as separate injuries. Mr Carey distinguished the decision on the basis that Canute was a claim for permanent impairment under s 24 of the Act and differed factually to Mr Cullen’s claim in that Mr Canute’s psychological impairment became manifest several years after his initial physical injury. Both submissions have merit. The High Court has stressed that the Act speaks exclusively in terms of “an injury” and while the matter before the Tribunal relates to s 14 and s 19 of the Act, the High Court’s decision and statutory interpretation is applicable. The Tribunal will consider the claimed injuries as two separate injuries, as opposed to a physical injury with psychological sequelae. Despite the expert medical support for the latter relationship, the Tribunal does so in order to establish the factual basis for the claimed psychological injury.Psychological Injury (Application no 2012/3700) Dr Gill diagnosed Mr Cullen to be suffering from an adjustment disorder with depressed and anxious mood, secondary to or as a sequelae of his right shoulder injury, albeit aggravated by the poor prognosis he received in late 2011. By definition under the DSM-IV-TR, an adjustment disorder is a psychological response to a stressor. Thus, medically speaking, it is a direct result of the right shoulder injury as submitted by Mr Carey. Professor Mendelson did not identify the existence of a psychiatric disorder. He considers Mr Cullen’s reaction to his shoulder condition to be within the normal emotional range of response to such an injury. Both psychiatrists and Dr Markov recommended a multi-disciplinary pain management program to assist Mr Cullen in dealing with his chronic right shoulder pain. However, neither Dr Gill nor Professor Mendelson, regardless of their diagnoses, are of the opinion that Mr Cullen’s psychological injury/symptoms impact on his capacity for work or result in permanent impairment (to the necessary degree), as required by s 14 and s 24 (in relation to permanent impairment) of the Act.. Neither psychiatrist appears to be have been fully acquainted with Mr Cullen’s general practitioner’s (as referred to above) medical records (Exhibit R4), which reveal that his insomnia dates from the time he commenced shift work (2006), and that his so-called depression was attributed to his father’s death in 2009. Dr Gill, when informed of the duration of Mr Cullen’s insomnia, discounted this symptom’s significance as a diagnostic feature of an adjustment disorder. Both psychiatrists have acknowledged an increase in Mr Cullen’s symptoms on receiving a poor prognosis in 2011.