Francey v Commissioner for Act Revenue

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

FRANCEY v COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE
(Administrative Review) [2013] ACAT 84

AT 13/37

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW - landholder duty – purchase of land in company’s name – purchase option agreement: transfer of beneficially held shares in company to the Applicant – exercise of option - application of landholder duty on transfer of company shares even though duty was paid previously on transfer of land to company: second imposition of duty – whether constructive trust arose in favour of the applicant in relation to property held by company

Legislation:ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT), ss. 68

Duties Act 1999 ss. 10, 11, 56, 76, 77, 78A, 83, 84, 85, 86, 88 -91, and Part 3.2

Taxation Administration Act 1999 ss. 29, 31, 37, 107A & 108A, and Schedule 1.2

Cases:Australian Building & Technical Solutions Pty Limited v Boumelhem; Boral Australia Limited v Boumelhem; Boumelhem v Jones [2009] NSWSC 460

Clout v Markwell [2001] QSC 91

Giumelli v Giumelli (1999) 196 CLR 101

Muschinski v Dodds (1985) 160 CLR 583

Parsons and Parsons v McBain (2001)109 FCR 120

Tribunal:                  Ms E. Symons – Presidential Member

Date of Orders:  24 December 2013     

Date of Reasons for Decision:           24 December 2013

ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL                 AT 13/37

BETWEEN:    MARIANNE FRANCEY

Applicant

AND:     COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Ms E. Symons – Presidential Member

DATE:24 December 2013     

ORDERS

1.   The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes its decision that the Applicant is not liable to pay duty on the acquisition of an interest in a landholding entity in the ACT. 

2.   The Respondent is to refund to the Applicant within 28 days all monies, including duty, penalty duty and interest, paid by the Applicant following the assessments of the Respondent on 29 February 2012 and 7 May 2013.

………………………………..

Ms E. Symons

Presidential Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On 2 June 2013 Ms Marianne Francey (the Applicant) made an application to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal) for review of a decision (the decision) of the Commissioner of ACT Revenue (the Commissioner) dated 9 May 2013 to partly allow her objection to a decision (the original decision) dated 29 February 2013.

  2. The original decision was that the Applicant was liable to pay duty on the acquisition of a significant interest in a landholding entity in the ACT. The acquisition was found to have occurred on 16 August 2011. The duty payable was assessed in the sum of $59,375. The Commissioner also decided that the Applicant should pay penalty tax of $14,843.75 calculated at a rate of 25%, and interest of $2,000.47. The total amount payable was $76,219.22.

  3. The original decision was based on Australian Securities & Investments Commission records showing that 59,999 shares in the company Un De Six Pty Ltd (UDS), which had been beneficially held by Kerrill Thomas Chambers (KTC), had been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Francey v Commissioner for Act Revenue and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ACAT 84
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Francey v Commissioner for ACT Revenue, the dispute centred around the Applicant's liability for duty on the acquisition of an interest in a landholding entity within the ACT. The Applicant argued that the duty was not payable as the shares in question were held on constructive trust for another party. The Federal Circuit Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the Applicant held the shares on trust for another person and, if so, whether this resulted in the Applicant not being liable for the duty in question.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Applicant held the shares in Un De Six Pty Ltd on constructive trust for Marianne Francey, and if this trust status impacted the Applicant's liability for duty. The Applicant and the other parties involved had provided statements indicating their belief that the shares were held on trust for Marianne Francey. The court needed to assess these statements and determine whether they constituted a valid constructive trust arrangement under Australian law.

The court examined the statements provided by the Applicant and other parties to ascertain the existence of a common intention that the Applicant held the shares on trust for Marianne Francey. The court noted that while intention is not a necessary element of a constructive trust, the parties' statements suggested a clear understanding that the shares were held for Marianne Francey's benefit. The court concluded that the evidence supported the existence of a constructive trust, and thus, the Applicant was not liable for the duty on the acquisition of the shares.

Consequently, the court ordered that the decision under review be set aside and replaced with a decision that the Applicant was not liable to pay duty on the acquisition of the interest in the landholding entity. Furthermore, the court ordered the Commissioner to refund all monies, including duty, penalty duty, and interest, paid by the Applicant following the assessments on 29 February 2012 and 7 May 2013, within 28 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes its decision that the Applicant is not liable to pay duty on the acquisition of an interest in a landholding entity in the ACT.

2. The Respondent is to refund to the Applicant within 28 days all monies, including duty, penalty duty and interest, paid by the Applicant following the assessments of the Respondent on 29 February 2012 and 7 May 2013.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Francey v Commissioner for Act Revenue revolves around the acquisition of an interest in a landholding entity by Mr Francey and his associated entities, Un De Six Pty Ltd (UDS) and KTC. Mr Francey and KTC, who held shares in UDS, contended that they held these shares beneficially on behalf of Marianne Francey. Mr Francey argued that due to this understanding and belief, he was not liable to pay duty on the acquisition of the interest in the landholding entity. The dispute arose from assessments by the Commissioner for Act Revenue, which Mr Francey contested.

The matter came before the Tribunal for review of a decision by the Commissioner for Act Revenue, who had assessed Mr Francey for duty on the acquisition of an interest in UDS. Mr Francey challenged this assessment, leading to a review by the Tribunal. During the proceedings, Mr Francey presented witness statements from KTC and RFC, both asserting their belief that they held shares in UDS beneficially on behalf of Marianne Francey. The Tribunal considered these submissions and the relevant statutory framework governing the duty on acquisitions of landholding interests.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Mr Francey and KTC held shares in UDS beneficially on behalf of Marianne Francey, thereby avoiding liability for duty on the acquisition of an interest in a landholding entity.
2. Whether the Tribunal should set aside the Commissioner’s decision and substitute its own decision, ruling that Mr Francey is not liable to pay duty on the acquisition of the interest in UDS.

Held
1. The Tribunal found that Mr Francey and KTC held shares in UDS beneficially on behalf of Marianne Francey, thereby avoiding liability for duty on the acquisition of an interest in a landholding entity. The Tribunal set aside the Commissioner’s decision and substituted its own decision, ruling that Mr Francey is not liable to pay duty on the acquisition of the interest in UDS.
2. The Tribunal ordered the Commissioner to refund to Mr Francey all monies, including duty, penalty duty and interest, paid by Mr Francey following the assessments of the Commissioner on 29 February 2012 and 7 May 2013.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Parsons and Parsons v McBain,[13] the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia considered when a common intention constructive trust arises. The Court adopted statements in the joint judgment[14] of the High Court in Giumelli v Giumelli[15] when finding that the parents of the Commissioner (their son) held the land upon constructive trust. The parents had promised the son, who was in partnership with them, that he would become the owner of part of their property, known as Dwellingup. Relying on this promise, the son had remained in the partnership and worked to improve the Dwellingup property. The Full Court of the Federal Court in Parsons v McBain rejected the notion that a common intention constructive trust first comes into existence when so declared by the court. Indeed, the Full Court also referred to Muschinski v Dodds[16] where Dean J said:Equity acts consistently and in accordance with principle. The old maxim that equity regards as done that which ought to be done is as applicable to enforce equitable obligations as it is to create them and, notwithstanding that the constructive trust is remedial both in origin and nature, there does not need to have been a curial declaration or order before equity will recognize the prior existence of a constructive trust.... (emphasis added)[13] (2001)109 FCR 120[14] Gleeson CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Callinan JJ (at 112)[15] (1999) 196 CLR 101[16] At 614 In Australian Building & Technical Solutions Pty Limited v Boumelhem; Boral Australia Limited v Boumelhem; Boumelhem v Jones[17], Mr Boumelhem’s parents had provided funds for their son to purchase land and build two duplexes. Upon completion and subdivision, one of the titles would be transferred to the parents. When the son’s business collapsed the parents claimed an interest under both a resulting trust to secure their initial contribution and a constructive trust for later contributions they made to the building. Ward J declared that there was a resulting trust for the contributions to the purchase price. The parents were held to have a vested beneficial interest in the ownership of the land which could be perfected by the use of a constructive trust.[17] [2009] NSWSC 460 Mr Francey urged the Tribunal, when considering this issue, to consider the intentions of the Applicant, KTC and RFC; notwithstanding that intention is not a necessary element of a constructive trust. KTC, in his Witness Statement dated 20 September 2013 (Exhibit A3), stated:I state that at all material times since 14 December 2007 I understood and believed that in all the circumstances I held any shares in Un De Six Pty Ltd beneficially on behalf of Marianne Francey. RFC, the owner of the remaining one share in UDS, said in his Witness Statement dated 23 September 2013 (Exhibit A4):I state that at all material times since 14 December 2007 I understood and believed that in all the circumstances I held any shares in Un De Six Pty Ltd beneficially on behalf of Marianne Francey.