Fragogianis and Tax Practitioners Board

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Fragogianis and Tax Practitioners Board [2023] AATA 3145 (5 October 2023)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Numbers:2023/0406 and 2023/0409         

Re:Anastasios Fragogianis  

FIRST APPLICANT

Fragogianis & Co Pty Ltd

SECOND APPLICANT

Tax Practitioners BoardAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D Mitchell

Date:5 October 2023

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal refuses the Applicants requests under section 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) for an order staying or otherwise affecting the operation or implementation of the reviewable decisions. The interim stays granted on 10 February 2023 as varied on 13 April 2023 are discharged.

…………………[SGD]……………............

Member D Mitchell

  1. This is an application for a stay which arises out of decisions made by the Tax Practitioners Board (the Respondent) to terminate the registration of both Mr Anastasios Fragogianis (the First Applicant) a registered tax agent, and Fragogianis & Co Pty Ltd (the Second Applicant) (together the Applicants), a company which conducts business as a tax agent, of whom
    Mr Fragogianis is the sole director.

  2. The First Applicant has been a registered tax agent since 1 January 2005.

  3. The Second Applicant has been a registered tax agent since 1 February 2011.

  4. By its decisions dated 8 December 2022, the Respondent determined that the Applicants failed to comply with certain aspects of the Code of Professional Conduct (the Code) under the Tax Agent Services Act2009 (Cth) (the Act) and that as such the First Applicant ceased to be a fit and proper person as required under section 20-5(1)(a) of the Act. Consequently, the Respondent determined that the Second Applicant ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirements under section 20-5(3)(a) of the Act by virtue that its director was no longer a fit and proper person.

  5. In addition to terminating the Applicants tax agent registration pursuant to sections
    40-5(1)(b) and 40-15(1)(b) of the Act respectively, the Respondent also decided, pursuant to section 40-25(1) of the Act that the Applicants may not reapply for registration as a tax agent under the Act for five years from the date of termination.

  6. The decisions were made on 8 December 2022 to take effect on 20 January 2023.  On
    20 January 2023, the Applicants made applications for review of and to stay those decisions to this Tribunal. 

  7. Interim stays were granted by consent of the parties on 10 February 2023 and were amended on 13 April 2023 making the interim stay orders subject to conditions that:

    (a)The Applicants do not undertake any new clients.

    (b)The Applicants must by close of business on 28 April 2023 inform their existing clients, by way of letter in a form approved by the Respondent, of the administrative action taken by the Respondent and the proceedings currently on foot at the Tribunal.

  8. An interlocutory stay hearing was conducted on 18 July 2023 with both the Applicants and Respondent engaging Counsel. The Tribunal notes that the First Applicant was not present at the interlocutory hearing and as such was not available to the Respondent for cross-examination or to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fragogianis and Tax Practitioners Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3145
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for a stay of a decision by the Tax Practitioners Board to cancel the registration of the applicants as tax agents. The application was heard by D Mitchell M of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant a stay of the Board's decision pending the substantive review of that decision. This required the Tribunal to consider the prospects of success of the applicants' case, the potential prejudice to the parties, and the public interest. The Tribunal also had to determine whether the applicants' case was arguable, based on the material before it, to justify granting a stay to preserve the effectiveness of the review.

The Tribunal considered the grounds for the Board's decision, which included allegations of dishonesty, failure to account for client funds, lodging false statements, non-compliance with personal tax obligations, lack of reasonable care in preparing BAS, and failure to respond to the Board's requests. The applicants, in turn, denied these allegations, attributing some delays to personal circumstances and COVID-19 restrictions, and argued that their case had good prospects of success. The Tribunal acknowledged the principles from *Birdseye v Tax Practitioners Board* [2020] FCA 1235, noting that an applicant for a stay need not demonstrate they must succeed, but rather that there is a basis for forming an opinion that a stay is desirable to preserve the effectiveness of the review. However, the Tribunal found that the matters raised by the Board, particularly concerning the honesty and integrity of tax agents, weighed against granting a stay, as the public interest is served by upholding high standards of professional conduct in the tax system.

Ultimately, the Tribunal refused the application for a stay of the decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While these other relevant matters are not determinative as to whether a stay should be granted, they do, however not weigh in favour of stays being granted.CONCLUSION The public interest is served in tax agents, upon whose honesty the system of lodgement of tax returns and activity statements depends, being held to, and being seen to be held to, the highest standard of professional and ethical conduct.[4][4] Cross and Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 1471 at [68]. The Tribunal notes that in this interlocutory matter it has been referred to several Tribunal decisions of which it has considered however is not bound by. Each case must turn on its own factual circumstances. The Applicant’s representative made extensive reference to and placed importance on the decision of Logan J in Birdseye v Tax Practitioners Board [2020] FCA 1235 (Birdseye). The Applicant’s representative put forward the reasoning of Logan J and subsequent adoption thereof by the Tribunal as being a primary consideration for this Tribunal. The Tribunal has given consideration to the decision of Logan J in Birdseye and makes its decision in line with the following principles:23.… Nonetheless, it may be accepted that an applicant for a stay is in no way required to demonstrate that he, she, or it, as the case may be, must succeed upon a review on the merits of the decision. At most, all that one must show is that there is a basis in the material before the Tribunal for forming the opinion that it is “desirable”, in order to preserve the effectiveness of the review, to grant a stay. As to that, to use the term “onus” would be inapt, having regard to the very nature of the administrative review conducted by the Tribunal. That would be to adopt language from a different discourse, namely, that of an exercise of judicial power: see Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259.24.Nonetheless, it is, obviously, in the interests of an applicant to be able to point to something in the material before the Tribunal which engenders the requisite opinion as to desirability. That might be found in what was already before the primary decision maker whose decision is under review. It might be found not in factual material before that decision maker, but rather, in the approach to the construction of the statute empowering the making of the decision concerned. Thus, it may be that there is, even aside from any factual controversy, an arguable proposition of law. It may be each of those. The foundation may also be in additional material which was not before the primary decision maker but has been introduced, or at least can be shown to be reasonably in prospect of being introduced, having regard to the particular stage of the proceedings.25.It, truly, is neither necessary, nor desirable, to set metes and bounds as to what may engender appropriately the requisite desirability opinion other than to observe that, as with any administrative decision, there must be some material before the Tribunal which is reasonably capable of engendering the requisite opinion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

These factors are not prescriptive and the weight if any to be given to any particular factor will depend on the facts and circumstances of the case, including the nature and content of the reviewable decision. CONSIDERATIONProspects of Success Where there is an obvious indication that the substantive case has good prospects, a stay is more likely to be desirable. In contrast where it is obvious that a case is devoid of merit, that will weigh against granting a stay. However, it is not for the Tribunal in stay applications to undertake an exhaustive evaluation of the merits of a case, especially in circumstances where the parties have not yet had the opportunity to file all the evidence and provide a statement of issues, facts and contentions upon which they rely. The Tribunal must however, based on the submissions made by the parties be satisfied that the Applicant’s case is arguable. The Respondent’s decisions can be summarised as having determined that the Applicants had:·failed to act honestly and with integrity and that their conduct raised issues with receipting and accounting of client funds; ·failed to provide to clients the money received on their behalf; ·lodged client statements to the Commissioner of Taxation without the company director’s knowledge or authority which in some instances amounted to making false statements; ·failed to comply with personal tax obligations; ·failed to take reasonable care when preparing and lodging BAS which led to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) making amendments on the basis that the Applicants clients were not eligible for the CFB payments; and·failed to respond to requests and directions from the Respondent. In this case, the Applicants submitted that their applications have good prospects for success. The Applicants grounds for review in this regard were succinctly summarised in their submissions filed on 14 April 2023 as follows:a)that the Applicants did not fail to act with honesty and integrity as concluded by the Board in its decision;(b)that the Applicants did not fail to comply with taxation laws in the conduct of their personal affairs as concluded by the Board in its decision;(c)that the Applicants deny failing to comply with the Code of Professional Conduct set out in s 30-10 of the TASA as concluded by the Board;(d)that whilst the Applicants accept that there are some instances where there were delays in transferring refunds or payments to clients that may be regarded as unreasonable, any shortfall in the Applicants’ duty to account is explained or mitigated by the difficult personal circumstances of [the First Applicant] at the time and/or difficulties in processing the transfer of payments and refunds during COVID-19 lockdown periods;(e)that the Applicants deny failing to act competently as concluded by the Board;(f)that the Applicants deny that they ‘knowingly obstructed’ the proper administration of a taxation law as concluded by the Board;(g)that the Applicants deny failing to respond to requests in a timely, responsible and reasonable manner as concluded by the Board; and(h)that the circumstances are not such that they warrant the making of a decision to deny the Applicants an opportunity to apply for registration under the TASA for a period of five years from the date of termination of their registration as a tax agent takes effect.