SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
CORPORATIONS
Not Restricted
No. 5813 of 1996
JOSEPH MICHAEL FOXWELL Plaintiff and WESTBURY JOINERY CO. PTY LTD & Defendant ORS.
---
JUDGE: Hansen J. WHERE HELD: Melbourne DATE OF HEARING: 2, 6-8 & 15 April, 26 June, 31 July, 7 & 12 August & 11
September, 1998DATE OF JUDGMENT: 2 October 1998 CASE MAY BE CITED AS: Foxwell v. Westbury Joinery Co Pty. Ltd. & Ors. MEDIA NEUTRAL CITATION: [1998] VSC 94
---
CORPORATIONS - Internal disputes - Finding of oppression - Subsequent appointment of administrators followed by liquidation - Relief - Orders against directors.
COSTS - Informal offers - Effect - Plaintiff failing on one issue - Discretionary considerations.
APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors For the Plaintiff Mr M.D.G. Heaton Middletons Moore &
BevinsFor the Second to Sixty Mr C. Gunst QC Tress Cocks & Maddox Defendants For the First, Seventh & Mr A.G. Serong Rigby Cooke Eighth Defendants
HIS HONOUR:
This is an oppression case under s.260 of the Corporations Law. Following a trial in April I gave judgment on 26 June. I found oppression and stood the matter over to 31 July to enable the parties to consider their position. The amended notice of motion included orders for winding up, under s.260 and s.461, but at trial winding up was not the primary or preferred relief. For that reason and because, in any event, it would have been a course of last resort, I did not find it necessary to consider the case for winding up.
The case was brought by Joseph Michael Foxwell against Westbury Joinery Co. Pty. Ltd. ("Westbury Joinery"), Guiseppe Umberto Ganci (who is known as Joe Ganci), William Kerr Strachan, Michael Angelo Giurleo, Carlo Ganci and Santo Antonio Ganci. Each individual held shares in Westbury Joinery (Foxwell, Joe Ganci, Strachan and Giurleo who as the original founding and working directors held 80 each, while Carlo and Santo Ganci held 40 each). In my judgment I found that Carlo and Santo Ganci became directors on 2 December 1993. They continue to question whether they were ever directors. Whether they were or not I readily accept that they did not play an active role as such and that all relevant decisions were made by the other directors.
Two related companies were not defendants at the time of the trial. Those companies are Westbury Joinery Services Pty. Ltd. ("Westbury Services") and Westbury Joinery and Co. (Holdings) Pty. Ltd. ("Westbury Holdings").
An issue at the trial was the value of Foxwell's interest in Westbury Joinery. At the time of the trial the company, or the Westbury Group as the three companies might be called, was trading and, to all intents and purposes, would continue to do so. It was then proper to approach the valuation on the basis of maintainable future earnings. In my judgment I did not resolve the valuation issue. I refrained from doing that deliberately, as I indicated to the parties that I would. Indeed I was invited to take…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Foxwell v Westbury Joinery Co Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] VSC 94
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the conduct of the directors did indeed amount to oppressive behaviour, thereby justifying the plaintiff's claim for relief. However, the court also considered the broader context of the company's liquidation and the appointment of administrators. In determining the appropriate relief, the court emphasised the need to balance the interests of the plaintiff against the potential detriment to other stakeholders, particularly given the company's insolvency. The court concluded that while the plaintiff's claim was valid, the most appropriate remedy was to make orders against the directors, reflecting their oppressive conduct but also considering the practical outcomes of the company's liquidation.
In addressing the issue of costs, the court acknowledged the informal offers made by the plaintiff but ultimately determined that the plaintiff's failure on the primary issue of relief led to an unfavourable costs outcome. The court exercised its discretion to award costs against the plaintiff, reflecting the overall balance of success and failure in the proceedings. This decision underscores the importance of the court's discretion in managing costs, especially in cases where partial success does not justify a favourable costs outcome.
The final orders of the court included specific directives against the directors for their oppressive conduct, along with a costs order against the plaintiff. This outcome not only recognised the plaintiff's valid claims but also highlighted the need for careful consideration of the broader implications of corporate disputes, particularly in cases involving insolvency and multiple stakeholders.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.