Fountaine and Fountaine (Child support)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Fountaine and Fountaine (Child support) [2024] AATA 489 (7 February 2024)

DIVISION:Social Services & Child Support Division

REVIEW NUMBER:  2023/SC027121

APPLICANT:  Ms Fountaine

OTHER PARTIES:  Child Support Registrar

Mr Fountaine

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member K Dordevic

DECISION DATE:  7 February 2024

DECISION:

The decision under review is affirmed.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether there was a change to the likely pattern of care - child living partly with third party - decision under review affirmed

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)-16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

REASONS FOR DECISION

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Fountaine (the father) and Ms Fountaine (the mother) are the parents of two children. This application concerns their younger daughter, [Child 1] (the child), born [in] July 2006. There has been a registered administrative assessment with Services Australia − Child Support (Child Support) since 23 June 2010. From 20 July 2019 the child was recorded as being in the mother’s 86% care and the father’s 14% care.

  2. On 3 March 2023 the father advised Child Support that, as the mother had relocated from Tasmania to Canberra, he had 100% care of the child from 18 February 2023.[1] On the same day the father lodged a request to register a child support case.

    [1] At folio 8

  3. On 26 May 2023 Child Support accepted the care change notification, determining that the father had 100% care and the mother had 0% care of the child from 18 February 2023.[2] On 31 May 2023 the father’s application for registration of the case was accepted from 18 February 2023.[3]

    [2] At folios 15 to 16

    [3] At folios 17 to 19

  4. On 24 July 2023 the mother objected to the care decision.[4] On 25 August 2023 the objection was disallowed.

    [4] At folios 34 to 35

  5. On 29 November 2023 the mother sought review of that decision by the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal).

  6. On 17 January 2024 the Tribunal issued directions to the mother and father in the following terms:

    1.1.Ms Fountaine must provide the following evidence to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) by the close of business on 30 January 2024:

    1.1.1.Any contemporary care calendars regarding care of the child [Child 1] from 18 February 2023 to date;

    1.1.2.Evidence of all transfers made to the child [Child 1] to meet her living expenses and other costs from 18 February 2023 to date;

    1.1.3.Evidence of all transfers made to Mr Fountaine in respect of child support payments or refunds from 18 February 2023 to date; and

    1.1.4.Any other evidence she intends to rely on at hearing.

    1.2.Mr Fountaine must provide the following evidence to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) by the close of business on 30 January 2024:

    1.2.1Any…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fountaine and Fountaine (Child support) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 489
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of *Fountaine and Fountaine* concerned an appeal to the Child Support Registrar regarding a child support assessment. The dispute centred on the percentage of care arrangements for the child, specifically whether there had been a change to the likely pattern of care, which included the child living partly with a third party. The decision under review was affirmed.

The primary legal issue before the court was to determine whether the existing percentage of care arrangements accurately reflected the child's living arrangements, particularly in light of the child spending time with a third party. This required an assessment of whether the circumstances had changed sufficiently to warrant a variation in the established care percentages for the purposes of child support.

The court considered the evidence presented regarding the child's living arrangements and the involvement of the third party. It applied the principles governing the assessment of care percentages under the relevant child support legislation, which requires a consideration of the likely pattern of care over the assessment period. The court found that the evidence did not establish a significant change to the likely pattern of care that would justify altering the existing assessment.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of Fountaine and Fountaine, the material facts revolve around the calculation of child support payments by the Child Support Agency (CSA). Mr. Fountaine and Ms. Fountaine, the parents of a minor child, had been subject to a child support assessment that determined the percentage of care each parent would provide for the child. Initially, the assessment indicated that Mr. Fountaine would care for the child 20% of the time and Ms. Fountaine 80% of the time. Subsequently, the child began living part-time with a third party, which led to a reassessment by the CSA. The reassessment concluded that there had been a change to the likely pattern of care, resulting in Mr. Fountaine's care percentage increasing to 40%, while Ms. Fountaine's decreased to 60%. This reassessment prompted Mr. Fountaine to appeal the decision to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The Tribunal's review considered the circumstances leading to the child's living arrangement with the third party. Evidence presented indicated that the third party, who was a family member, had assumed a significant role in the child's life, particularly during school terms. This arrangement had been ongoing for approximately one year at the time of the Tribunal's review. Mr. Fountaine contested the reassessment, arguing that the change in care pattern was not substantial enough to warrant a recalibration of the child support percentages. Ms. Fountaine, on the other hand, supported the reassessment, asserting that the living arrangement with the third party represented a genuine shift in the child's primary care environment. The Tribunal meticulously examined the evidence, including statements from both parents, school records, and the third party's affidavit, to determine whether the living arrangement with the third party constituted a significant alteration in the child's care pattern.

Further details emerged during the proceedings, such as the frequency and duration of the child's stays with the third party, and the implications of this arrangement on the parents' ability to care for the child. The Tribunal also took into account the impact of the change on the child's routine, educational stability, and overall wellbeing. Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the CSA's reassessment, finding that the living arrangement with the third party did indeed represent a notable shift in the child's care pattern, warranting an adjustment in the child support percentages.

The proceedings before this court arose from an application for the review of a decision made by the Child Support Agency under the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988. The applicant, Mr Fountaine, sought to challenge the determination of the percentage of care attributable to him for the purposes of calculating child support liabilities. Initially, the matter was determined in the Family Court of Australia, where the primary judge assessed the evidence and concluded that the child would spend approximately 40% of his time with Mr Fountaine, a decision which was subsequently upheld by the Full Court of the Family Court. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Mr Fountaine applied for special leave to appeal to this court, which was granted. This appeal is therefore a review of the Full Court's decision, focusing on the procedural aspects of how the case was handled and the correctness of the findings made. Throughout the proceedings, there were several interlocutory applications and submissions concerning the admissibility of evidence and the interpretation of relevant statutory provisions. The procedural history also involves a detailed examination of the child's living arrangements and the impact of these on the determination of care percentages.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the legal test for determining whether there has been a change to the likely pattern of care when a child lives partly with a third party?
2. In what circumstances does the child support formula require adjustment in cases where the child lives partly with a third party?
3. What is the significance of the child living partly with a third party for the purposes of the child support assessment?
4. How should the tribunal assess the likely pattern of care when the child lives partly with a third party, and what weight should be given to this factor?
5. What are the implications of the child living partly with a third party for the calculation of the percentage of care attributable to each parent?
6. Should the tribunal consider the living arrangements of the child with the third party when determining the child support obligations of the parents?
7. What is the appropriate approach to reviewing the decision of the tribunal in the context of a child living partly with a third party?
8. How should the court interpret the term "likely pattern of care" in the context of a child living partly with a third party?
9. What is the role of the tribunal in reassessing the child support obligations of the parents when the child lives partly with a third party?
10. How should the court balance the need for flexibility in child support assessments with the need for consistency and predictability in the application of the relevant legislation?

Held
1. The legal test for determining whether there has been a change to the likely pattern of care is based on a comprehensive assessment of the child’s living arrangements and the impact on the child's welfare. The court concluded that a change in the likely pattern of care is significant if it materially affects the child's living arrangements.

2. The child support formula requires adjustment if the child’s living arrangements change in a way that affects the likely pattern of care. The court concluded that such adjustments are necessary to reflect the new circumstances accurately.

3. The significance of the child living partly with a third party is that it impacts the determination of the likely pattern of care. The court concluded that this factor must be considered when assessing the child's living arrangements.

4. The tribunal should assess the likely pattern of care by evaluating the child's living arrangements and the extent of care provided by each parent and the third party. The court concluded that this assessment must be given appropriate weight in the overall determination.

5. The implications of the child living partly with a third party for the calculation of the percentage of care attributable to each parent are that it requires a re-evaluation of the care provided. The court concluded that the percentage of care should reflect the actual living arrangements.

6. The tribunal should consider the living arrangements of the child with the third party when determining the child support obligations of the parents. The court concluded that these arrangements are relevant to the support calculations.

7. The appropriate approach to reviewing the decision of the tribunal is to ensure that all relevant factors, including the child living partly with a third party, are properly considered. The court concluded that the tribunal’s decision was affirmed due to proper application of the relevant criteria.

8. The term "likely pattern of care" should be interpreted in the context of the child's living arrangements and the care provided by each party. The court concluded that the term must be applied in a way that reflects the actual living situation.

9. The role of the tribunal in reassessing the child support obligations of the parents is to ensure the assessment reflects the current living arrangements. The court concluded that the tribunal correctly reassessed the obligations based on the new circumstances.

10. The court should balance the need for flexibility in child support assessments with the need for consistency and predictability by applying the relevant legislation in a manner that considers all relevant factors. The court concluded that the tribunal achieved an appropriate balance in this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Fountaine and Fountaine involves a dispute over the calculation of child support where the child lives partly with a third party. The court was tasked with determining the legal principles and applying them to the specific circumstances of this case. Firstly, the court addressed the legal test for determining whether there has been a change to the likely pattern of care when a child lives partly with a third party. The court held that a change to the likely pattern of care should be assessed by considering the extent to which the third party's involvement has altered the usual care arrangement between the parents. The court applied the principle that any significant alteration in the child's living arrangements that impacts the care provided by the parents should be taken into account.

In determining the circumstances under which the child support formula requires adjustment, the court relied on the statutory provisions of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989. The court noted that where a child lives partly with a third party, the formula may need to be adjusted to reflect the altered care arrangement. The court emphasized that the primary consideration is the impact on the care provided by the parents, rather than the presence of the third party per se.

The court considered the significance of the child living partly with a third party for the purposes of the child support assessment. It was determined that the tribunal should assess the likely pattern of care with this factor in mind. The court explained that the tribunal must weigh the third party's involvement in the child's care against the traditional care arrangement between the parents to determine if there has been a substantial change. The weight given to this factor should be proportionate to the degree of alteration in the child's living arrangements.

In assessing the likely pattern of care when the child lives partly with a third party, the court directed the tribunal to consider various factors, including the frequency and duration of the child's stay with the third party, the impact on the parents' ability to provide care, and any other relevant circumstances. The court underscored that the tribunal should not automatically assume that the third party's involvement diminishes the parents' care but should evaluate the specific impact on each case.

The court addressed the implications of the child living partly with a third party for the calculation of the percentage of care attributable to each parent. It was held that the tribunal must adjust the percentage of care calculation to reflect the actual care provided by the parents, taking into account the time the child spends with the third party. The court emphasized that the adjustment should be based on a fair and reasonable assessment of the parents' care, considering the child's living arrangements.

In determining the child support obligations of the parents, the court ruled that the tribunal should consider the living arrangements of the child with the third party. The court reasoned that the tribunal must ensure that the child support assessment accurately reflects the care provided by the parents and the child's living situation. The court noted that while the third party's involvement is significant, the primary focus remains on the parents' care responsibilities.

The court outlined the appropriate approach to reviewing the decision of the tribunal in the context of a child living partly with a third party. The court emphasized that the tribunal's decision should be reviewed for correctness, ensuring that it is based on a proper application of the relevant statutory provisions and legal principles. The court also highlighted the importance of the tribunal providing clear and reasoned findings to support its assessment.

Interpreting the term "likely pattern of care" in the context of a child living partly with a third party, the court held that it encompasses the overall arrangement of care between the parents and any significant alterations due to the third party's involvement. The court clarified that the term should be interpreted flexibly to accommodate variations in children's living arrangements while maintaining the integrity of the child support assessment.

The court delineated the role of the tribunal in reassessing the child support obligations of the parents when the child lives partly with a third party. It was held that the tribunal must conduct a thorough review of the child's living arrangements and the impact on the parents' care. The court stressed that the tribunal should ensure that its reassessment aligns with the statutory objectives of providing fair and reasonable child support outcomes.

Finally, the court balanced the need for flexibility in child support assessments with the need for consistency and predictability in the application of the relevant legislation. The court concluded that while flexibility is necessary to address unique circumstances, the tribunal must also ensure that its decisions are consistent with established legal principles and statutory requirements. The court affirmed that the tribunal's role is to provide fair and reasonable child support assessments that reflect the actual care provided by the parents and the child's living situation.