ANTHONY FOSTER v THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
Criminal Injuries Compensation
Judge Lunn
Background
At about 1am on New Years Day 1996 the plaintiff was in a disco room on the first floor of the Crown Hotel at Victor Harbour. As a result of some incident there he suffered a broken left jaw and some other less serious injuries. He alleged these resulted from some person or persons unknown having assaulted him. He now sues the State of South Australia under the Criminal Injuries Compensation Act 1978 (“the Act”) for compensation for his injuries.
The evidence
The plaintiff himself was the only witness who was present at the time of the alleged assault. While there were numerous persons present in the disco room at the time the plaintiff is not aware of their identities. He alleged that some bouncers at the hotel were involved. Some weeks later the police spoke to some of the security staff who denied any knowledge of the incident and they were unable to ascertain the identities of the other security staff who were working at the time. The police inquiries, such as they were, did not reveal any other witnesses to the incident. Accordingly, in this trial the plaintiff’s evidence about what actually occurred in the alleged assaults stands alone.
The plaintiff also called his father and a friend, Reuben Walker, who saw him shortly after he incurred the broken jaw. I accept their evidence. The defendant called Constable Bell who had investigated the incident. I do not accept her evidence that she spoke to the plaintiff by telephone in mid to late January 1996 and I make no findings concerning her allegations of the plaintiff’s alleged intoxication when she first saw him at about 2-2.30am on 1 January 1996. Otherwise I accept her evidence.
The only medical evidence was the tendering by consent of a number of medical reports. There was no evidence from any doctor or nurse who saw the plaintiff at the South Coast Hospital on 1 January 1996 before he was transferred to the Flinders Medical Centre later that day.
The plaintiff’s evidence
I have had considerable difficulty in assessing how reliable the plaintiff’s evidence was about what occurred in the alleged assaults. He claims to have been hit from behind without prior warning on the left hand side of his head by someone whom he did not see. He says he immediately fell to the floor and as a result of the blow and/or striking the floor he became unconscious. He does not know for how long he was unconscious, but when he next regained consciousness he was at the top of a set of metal back stairs leading from the outside disco room down to footpath alongside the hotel. He says he was then surrounded by three or four bouncers one of whom was holding onto his right arm. This was about fifteen feet from where he had been standing immediately before he says he was hit. Presumably, he…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Foster v State of SA No. DCCIV-96-760 Judgment No. D3766 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] SADC 3971
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining whether the plaintiff's evidence was sufficient to prove the alleged assaults beyond reasonable doubt and whether there was corroborative evidence to support his claims. The court found that the plaintiff's account was equivocal and lacked sufficient detail to substantiate the claims. Specifically, the plaintiff could not recall the force of the blow that caused his initial injury, nor could he definitively link the blow to the broken jaw. Furthermore, the court noted the lack of evidence regarding possible retrograde amnesia or intoxication, which could have impacted the plaintiff's recollection and credibility.
In its reasoning, the court concluded that the plaintiff's evidence did not meet the legal standards required under the Act. The court found that the plaintiff had not proved the first assault beyond reasonable doubt due to the lack of evidence about the intent of the striker. Additionally, the plaintiff's evidence regarding the second assault was insufficient as it did not exclude the possibility that the bouncer was merely using reasonable force to evict him. The court also determined that the plaintiff's evidence was not corroborated in a material particular as required by the Act, particularly since the injuries were not directly linked to the alleged push.
Ultimately, the court dismissed the plaintiff's claim, finding that he had not provided sufficient evidence to meet the legal criteria for compensation under the Act. The court left open the possibility of reopening the case if the plaintiff could provide additional evidence, such as expert testimony on retrograde amnesia or intoxication. However, based on the existing evidence, the court ruled in favour of the defendant, the State of South Australia.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi