Foster v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

FOSTER v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2025] SASC 68

Judgment of the Honourable Justice B Doyle  

19 May 2025

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE - GENERALLY

The appellant entered a plea of guilty to a charge of failing to comply with a condition of a bail agreement.  The relevant condition required that he not communicate with any child under the age of 18 years unless the child was accompanied by their parent or guardian.  In sentencing the appellant for the breach of bail, the magistrate referred to the seriousness of the underlying offences with which the appellant had been charged and made reference to the appellant having been charged with maintaining a sexual relationship with a child.  In fact, the appellant had not been charged with that offence.  He was charged only with a single count of possessing child exploitation material.  The magistrate sentenced the appellant to a term of imprisonment of 10 days, suspended upon his entry into a good behaviour bond.

The circumstances of the breach of bail included that a 17 year old female known to the appellant visited his home.  Earlier in the afternoon, the appellant had foreshadowed to police his concern that this might occur.  When the female arrived, he declined to answer the door for a period.  Eventually, he communicated with her through the screen door for a period of approximately 20 minutes, in the course of which he told her he was not able to speak to her.  The female was sitting on a chair outside the screen door of the appellant’s residence when police attended.  The appellant was taken into custody for a period of about 24 hours before he was sentenced for the breach of bail condition.  He had no prior convictions.

The appellant contends that the magistrate erred by:

1.   taking into account an irrelevant consideration, namely the seriousness of the underlying charged offending;

2.   sentencing on an incorrect factual basis, in that the magistrate referred to the appellant having been charged with multiple offences including offending in relation to the female;

3.   failing to provide adequate reasons in relation to the factual basis for sentencing and the extent to which it was accepted facts proffered by the appellant were mitigatory; and

4.   imposing a sentence that was manifestly excessive.

Held, allowing the appeal and re-sentencing the appellant:

1.   the magistrate sentenced the appellant on the basis of a mistaken apprehension as to the nature of the underlying charged offending;

2.   the circumstances of the breach of bail condition placed the offence towards the lower end of the scale of seriousness;

3. in view of the appellant’s lack of prior criminal history, his relatively transparent approach with authorities, his early plea of guilty and the fact he had served nearly 24 hours in custody by the time he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Foster v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASC 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Foster v Commissioner of Police is a case that involves an appeal against a sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court of South Australia. The appellant was convicted of breaching a bail condition by communicating with a 17-year-old girl, who was his ex-girlfriend, in contravention of his bail terms. The appellant was sentenced to a suspended imprisonment term and ordered to pay a fine. The appellant appealed the sentence on the grounds that the magistrate had erred in considering irrelevant factors and had a mistaken factual basis for the sentence. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of South Australia. The legal issues before the court were whether the sentence was affected by a material misapprehension of the facts and whether the sentence was appropriate in the circumstances. The court found that the sentence was indeed affected by a material misapprehension of the facts, as the magistrate had considered irrelevant factors and had a mistaken factual basis for the sentence. The court held that the sentence was not appropriate in the circumstances, and it was affected by a material misapprehension of the facts. The court re-sentenced the appellant to a fine of $600 and ordered that the conviction be recorded.

The court's reasoning was that the magistrate had erred in considering irrelevant factors and had a mistaken factual basis for the sentence. The magistrate had referred to the appellant being the subject of 'offences' or 'charges', whereas in fact the appellant had only been charged with a single offence. Moreover, the magistrate wrongly referred to the existence of a charge of maintaining a sexual relationship with a child, and described the 17-year-old girl as 'the complainant'. Whilst the concerns of police in relation to the appellant having entered into a relationship with the girl before she was 17 years old are noted in the facts of charge, and whilst their relationship to one another forms part of the factual context of the admitted breach of bail, the magistrate wrongly apprehended that the appellant had been charged with an offence in relation to his relationship with the girl. The court held that the sentence was not appropriate in the circumstances, and it was affected by a material misapprehension of the facts. The court re-sentenced the appellant to a fine of $600 and ordered that the conviction be recorded.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, the sentence was affected by a material misapprehension as to the relevant facts. I would re-sentence the appellant on the basis set out later in these reasons.Background On 5 January 2025, police attended the appellant’s home, and he was arrested and charged with having knowingly been in possession of child exploitation material. He was granted police bail. Condition 7 of the bail agreement provided that:I must not contact or communicate, either directly or indirectly, or attempt to contact or communicate with any child under the age of 18 years unless that child is accompanied by a parent or guardian other than myself. The ‘Facts of Charge’ that were before the magistrate when sentencing the appellant stated that when police attended at the appellant’s home on 5 January 2025 there was a 17 year-old female (to whom I will refer as AB) present, who identified herself as the appellant’s girlfriend. Police believed that a relationship started between the appellant and AB when she was 16 years old, and that she was currently pregnant by him. Police observed the vehicle that AB was driving. The appellant was not charged with any offending in relation to AB. On 14 January 2025, police attended the appellant’s home. He volunteered to them that earlier in the afternoon he had arrived home from Tea Tree Plaza to find personal items and a note on his doorstep, which suggested to him that AB had been present and would return. He was advised that if that occurred, he should tell AB he was not able to talk to her and he should contact police. After about an hour, police returned to his address and observed AB’s car parked in the driveway. As police approached the premises, they observed AB sitting on a chair just outside the front door. The front door was open, but the screen door remained closed. The appellant was seated on a chair inside the dwelling and behind the screen door. He was communicating with her. Police moved AB on and arrested the appellant, alleging breach of his bail agreement. The appellant was conveyed to Adelaide City Watch House where he participated in a recorded interview. He indicated that AB was his ex-partner and that they had been in a romantic relationship for a number of months during 2024, but he declined to say precisely how many months. He told police that AB had arrived at his premises about an hour before police arrived, crying and begging to speak with him. The appellant ignored her for about half an hour before opening the front door and speaking with her through the screen door for a period of about 20 minutes. In his interview, he fully accepted that he had failed to comply with his bail agreement. The appellant appeared before a magistrate the following afternoon, having spent the intervening period in custody. He entered a plea of guilty at the earliest opportunity. The submissions on sentence It is common ground that, in the course of the sentence hearing:·the prosecutor outlined the facts by reference to the ‘Facts of Charge’ document but without reading the contents verbatim, with the appellant’s counsel confirming the facts as outlined were admitted by the appellant;·the appellant’s counsel made submissions regarding the circumstances of the offending, explaining that the appellant had been in a relationship with AB for a period, and further that when AB attended, the appellant did not let her into the residence and told her he was unable to speak with her or see her. Counsel submitted that the appellant nevertheless accepted he ought to have contacted police and closed the door;·the appellant’s counsel outlined the appellant’s relevant personal circumstances (including his age, absence of criminal history, mental and physical health issues) and submitted that he ought to be discharged without penalty in light of the time he had spent in custody;·the prosecutor countered that the offence was concerning because the appellant was on bail for serious offending with a specific condition that he not have contact with children. The prosecutor submitted that while it was ‘unusual’ for a person with no criminal history, the prosecution was seeking ‘some form of custodial sentence’;·the appellant submitted that AB was not ‘just a child’, but rather was someone known to the appellant. The appellant had not proactively engaged with a child. He had remained inside and advised AB that he was unable to speak with her. These circumstances were ‘atypical’;·the magistrate gave ex tempore sentencing remarks, which are reproduced below.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Having regard to the nature of the grounds of appeal, it is convenient to reproduce the sentencing remarks in their entirety.Mr Foster, you have pleaded guilty, at the first opportunity, to having breached a bail condition on 14 January 2025. I take into account your plea, together with the time that you have spent in custody, overnight. Further, you have no prior criminal history, and I take on board your lawyer’s submissions. I accept the unusual factual basis of the charge, but having said that, there are a number of countervailing considerations which have been raised by Ms Noble for the prosecution. One of these is the seriousness of the substantive offences. You were arrested and bailed on 5 January in respect of a number of charges, including being in possession of child exploitation material. In my view all of your bail conditions were pretty clear. One concerning aspect of the breach of bail is that the substantive offences contain disturbing allegations. Your mobile phone is said to contain in excess of 35,000 images, at least 75 of which comprise child exploitation material of children between the ages of 13 and 14. One of the images is of a girl, believed to be 10 years old, naked and exposing her genitalia. The other is that, in respect of the charge of maintaining a sexual relationship with a child, you are 37 and the complainant is only 17. The onus is on you to put your ‘big boy pants on’ and not commit this type of offence of breaching bail. It is really concerning that someone on bail for such serious charges would have anything to do with the complainant, although I accept that there are some factors that mitigate the offence itself, for example, there is no suggestion that you initiated the contact. Further, you did tell the police about the items that the complainant had placed there and so on. In my view, given all of those matters, notwithstanding your lack of prior history, a sentence of imprisonment is the only appropriate penalty, particularly given the need for general deterrence in matters such as these. But for your plea of guilty, I would have sentence you to 20 days imprisonment. I reduce this to 12 days given your early plea. I reduce this by a further two days, allowing for the time you have spent in custody. I find good reason exists to suspend this sentence and I place you on a Bond to be of Good Behaviour for a period of six-months. The amount of the Bond is $600. A conviction is recorded. Irrelevant consideration and mistaken factual basis It is convenient to deal with the first two grounds together. More than once in the course of the sentencing remarks, the magistrate referred to the appellant being the subject of ‘offences’ or ‘charges’, whereas in fact the appellant had only been charged with a single offence. Moreover, the magistrate wrongly referred to the existence of a charge of maintaining a sexual relationship with a child, and described AB as ‘the complainant’. Whilst the concerns of police in relation to the appellant having entered into a relationship with AB before she was 17 years old are noted in the facts of charge, and whilst their relationship to one another forms part of the factual context of the admitted breach of bail, the magistrate wrongly apprehended that the appellant had been charged with an offence in relation to his relationship with AB.