Foroosh v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Foroosh v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited [2022] NSWPICMP 276
CLAIMANT: Shahram Hajhashem Dookhteh Foroosh

INSURER:

QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

REVIEW PANEL:

Member Susan McTegg

Medical Assessor Rhys Gray

Medical Assessor Margaret Gibson

DATE OF DECISION: 4 July 2022
CATCHWORDS: MOTOR ACCIDENTS –  Medical Review Panel; permanent impairment; Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; cervical spine; lumbar spine; left shoulder; right shoulder; whole person impairment; consistency of presentation; osteoarthritis; causation of injury; contemporaneous complaint; rear end collision; no orthopaedic or biomechanical explanation of injury to shoulders; the claimant suffered injury in a rear end collision on 24 October 2019; the dispute related to the assessment of permanent impairment under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; assessment of injury to cervical spine; lumbar spine and both shoulders; inconsistency demonstrated on examination; question of causation of shoulder injuries; Held – cervical spine soft tissue injury; assessed as DRE cervicothoracic category 1 resulting in 0% whole person impairment; lumbar spine soft tissue injury; assessed as DRE lumbosacral category 1 resulting in 0% whole person impairment; Panel not satisfied shoulder injuries causally related to accident; lack of complaint of shoulder injury; variable shoulder movements; no orthopaedic or biomechanical explanation to explain injury to shoulders in rear end collision as per QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v Shah.

MOTOR ACCIDENT INJURIES ACT 2017

WHETHER THE DEGREE OF PERMANENT IMPAIRMENT OF THE INJURED PERSON AS A RESULT OF THE INJURY CAUSED BY THE MOTOR ACCIDENT IS GREATER THAN 10%

Replacement Certificate issued under section 7.23(1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017

The Review Panel revokes the Certificate of Medical Assessor Sally Preston dated 13 November 2021. The Panel issues a new certificate determining that the following injuries were caused by the motor accident and give rise to a permanent impairment which is not greater than 10%:

·        soft tissue injury to the cervical spine, and

·        soft tissue injury to the lumbar spine.

The panel finds the following injures were not caused by the motor accident and do not give rise to a permanent impairment:

·        injury to the left shoulder, and

·        injury to the right shoulder.

Susan McTegg
Member (Motor Accident Division)
Personal Injury Commission.

REVIEW PANEL REASONS FOR DECISION

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 24 October 2019 Mr Shahram Hajhashem Dookhteh Foroosh (the claimant) was sitting in the front passenger seat of a vehicle driven by an acquaintance. When the vehicle was stationary in traffic the insured vehicle collided with the rear of the vehicle in which Mr Foroosh was a passenger pushing it into the rear of another vehicle in front (the accident). Police and ambulance attended the scene and Mr Foroosh was conveyed by ambulance to Bankstown Hospital.

  2. Mr Foroosh asserts he sustained the following injuries in the accident:

    1.     (a)   injury to the cervical spine;

    2.     (b)   injury to the lumbar spine;

    3.     (d)   injury to the right shoulder, and

    4.     (e)   injury to the left shoulder.

  3. Mr Foroosh has brought a claim for common law damages under the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Foroosh v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPICMP 276
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Foroosh v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited is a case before the court that involves a dispute about the assessment of permanent impairment under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The claimant, Mr Foroosh, was involved in a rear-end collision on 24 October 2019. The dispute focuses on the assessment of injuries to his cervical spine, lumbar spine, and both shoulders. The court was required to decide whether Mr Foroosh's injuries were caused by the accident and, if so, what the extent of the permanent impairment was.

The key legal issues before the court were the consistency of Mr Foroosh's presentation regarding his injuries, the causation of the shoulder injuries, and the lack of a contemporaneous complaint about shoulder pain. The court had to determine if the Panel's assessment of Mr Foroosh's injuries was consistent with the evidence presented. The Panel assessed Mr Foroosh's cervical spine soft tissue injury as DRE cervicothoracic category 1 resulting in 0% whole person impairment. The lumbar spine soft tissue injury was assessed as DRE lumbosacral category 1 also resulting in 0% whole person impairment. However, the Panel was not satisfied that the shoulder injuries were causally related to the accident. This was due to the lack of a contemporaneous complaint of shoulder injury, variable shoulder movements, and the absence of an orthopaedic or biomechanical explanation for the shoulder injuries in the context of a rear-end collision.

The court found that the Panel's assessment was consistent with the evidence presented. The court accepted that there was a soft tissue injury to the cervical spine and lumbar spine but was not satisfied that the shoulder injuries were causally related to the accident. The court noted the lack of a contemporaneous complaint of shoulder injury and the absence of an orthopaedic or biomechanical explanation for the shoulder injuries in the context of a rear-end collision. The court concluded that the Panel's decision not to attribute the shoulder injuries to the accident was reasonable.

The court made orders in favour of QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, dismissing Mr Foroosh's claim for permanent impairment in relation to his shoulders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Pre-accident treatment medical evidence Myhealth Merrylands Mr Foroosh consulted Dr Nien La on 16 September 2015 when he reported back pain for 10 days after lifting furniture.[8] It was noted he had no prior history of back pain or injury. He displayed mild tenderness in the right L4/5 region and pain on flexion and lateral flexion. Mr Foroosh was referred for an X-ray of his lumbar spine and prescribed Norgesic. [8] AD4 p 7. On 11 July 2016 Mr Foroosh consulted Dr Alex Sami for lower back pain with no radiation.[9] He noted it was mechanical type pain and that the lower and upper limbs were normal in power and sensation. He provided an imaging request for an X-ray of the lumbosacral spine. [9] AD4 p 9. On 18 September 2016 Dr Sami apparently reviewed the claimant’s patient file transferred from Melbourne. The file apparently contained no records relevant to the current dispute. A Patient Health Summary of Joslin Clinic of West Footscray is in the records of Myhealth Merrylands.[10][10] AD4 p 91. On 27 March 2018 Dr Sami reported lower back pain radiating to the right leg and a straight leg raising test positive at 50 degrees.[11] He gave Mr Foroosh some Mobic samples and a referral for a CT of the lumbar spine.[11] AD4 p 13. Mr Foroosh underwent a CT of the lumbar spine on 29 March 2018.[12] The report states:[12] AD4 p 13.17.“Mild degenerative changes in the spine. At the level of right L3/L4, the exiting nerve root is possibly in contact with the lateral disc, however, there is no definite impingement. If there is ongoing clinical concern, an MRI may be considered.” On 20 June 2018 Dr Sami completed a Centrelink Medical Certificate where he reported Mr Foroosh was partially incapacitated for work because of discopathy, lower back pain raiding to both legs. Mr Foroosh consulted Dr Sami on 2 August 2018 in respect of back pain radiating to the right leg. Mr Foroosh was given a referral to specialist Dr Behzad Eftekhar. On 14 March 2019 Dr Sami reported back pain with radiation to both legs and on 6 June 2019 he reported chronic back pain and referred Mr Foroosh to Guildford Physiotherapy. Mr Foroosh consulted Dr Sami on 19 September 2019 with complaints of back pain. The Ambulance Report records Mr Foroosh complained of pain to his neck and lower back, stating this was an exacerbation of pre-existing lower back pain.[13] He also complained of pain to the upper right thigh. There were no sensory deficits to any limbs and no exacerbation of pain when palpating the cervical spine. There was no complaint of upper limb or shoulder pain. [13] AD3 p 35. The Bankstown Hospital Discharge Summary of 24 October 2019 refers to the claimant reporting neck pain and mild headache and the impression was neck injury.[14] A CT scan of the neck reported no soft tissue swelling, no facet joint dislocation and no acute cervical spine injury.[14] AD3 p 38. Mr Foroosh attended Dr Assad Malek at Restwell Street Medical Centre on 28 October 2019.[15] Dr Malek reported a history of the accident on 24 October 2019 and noted Mr Foroosh complained of dizzy attacks, headache, neck pan, dorsal spine pain and lumbar spine pain, chest pain and right lower limb pain. On examination he reported:[15] AD6 p 1.18.“he has tenderness over the cervical spine, tenderness over the dorsal spine and Lumbosacral spine19.Restriction of movements of the cervical spine in flexion 30 deg, ext 10 deg, reduced lateral flexion and rotation.20.Shoulder examination showed normal movements in all direction21.Tenderness over the dorsal spine22.Reduced movements of the lumbosacral spine. Flexion reduced to 30cm from floor level extension to 10 deg, reduced lateral flexion and rotation. 23.Muscle power intact, reflexed of the knee, ankle and plantar, are normal24.Sensation was normal to cotton wool and pin prick”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.