Formstar Holdings Pty Ltd and Top Notch Roofing Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FORMSTAR HOLDINGS PTY LTD and TOP NOTCH ROOFING PTY LTD [2007] WASAT 208



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2007] WASAT 208
COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA)
Case No:CC:2080/2006DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS
Coram:MR P McNAB (MEMBER)21/08/07
15Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: The application is dismissed upon the basis that the Tribunal lacks
jurisdiction to entertain the application
B
PDF Version
Parties:FORMSTAR HOLDINGS PTY LTD
TOP NOTCH ROOFING PTY LTD

Catchwords:

Leases and tenancies
Commercial tenancy
Agreement to lease
Whether a regulated commercial tenancy under the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Act 1985 (WA)
"retail shop"
Whether an automotive service workshop is a "retail shop"
Goods (parts) consumed when labour applied in servicing function
57% of profit derived from the sale of such parts
Whether analogous to an hotel which could be a "retail shop"
Whether premises used "wholly or predominantly" for carrying on a business involving the sale of goods by retail
Held to be wholly or predominantly a business for the supply of services by retail
Tribunal lacked jurisdiction under Act
Words and phrases: "retail shop"; "wholly or predominantly"; "wholly or mainly"

Legislation:

Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 3, s 6, s 16(1), s 26(1)(b), s 27(5)
Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Regulations 1985 (WA), reg 3A
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 91

Case References:

Blunt & Anor and Pal & Anor [2007] WASAT 194
Hope v Bathurst City Council [No 2] (1986) 61 LGRA 392
Lauven Pty Ltd & Anor v Venus Adult Shops Pty Ltd & Ors [2006] NSWADT 359
McClelland v Goulburn City Council (1976) 35 LGRA 1
R v Radio Authority; Ex parte Bull [1997] 2 All ER 561
Sharp v O'Driscoll (Unreported, Supreme Court of Western Australia, Full Court, 34/96, Library No 97011A-C, 21 March 1997, [BC9700941])
South Veterinary Group Pty Ltd and Sharpe & Anor [2006] WASAT 222


Orders

1. The application is dismissed upon the basis that the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to entertain the application.,2. Preliminary question answered accordingly.

JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL STREAM : COMMERCIAL & CIVIL ACT : COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA) CITATION : FORMSTAR HOLDINGS PTY LTD and TOP NOTCH ROOFING PTY LTD [2007] WASAT 208 MEMBER : MR P McNAB (MEMBER) HEARD : DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS DELIVERED : 21 AUGUST 2007 FILE NO/S : CC 2080 of 2006 BETWEEN : FORMSTAR HOLDINGS PTY LTD
    Applicant

    AND

    TOP NOTCH ROOFING PTY LTD
    Respondent

Catchwords:

Leases and tenancies - Commercial tenancy - Agreement to lease - Whether a regulated commercial tenancy under the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Act 1985 (WA) - "retail shop" - Whether an automotive service workshop is a "retail shop" - Goods (parts) consumed when labour applied in servicing function - 57% of profit derived from the sale of such parts - Whether analogous to an hotel which could be a "retail shop" - Whether premises used "wholly or predominantly"…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Formstar Holdings Pty Ltd and Top Notch Roofing Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASAT 208
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Formstar Holdings Pty Ltd and Top Notch Roofing Pty Ltd were involved in a legal dispute regarding the classification of a commercial tenancy under the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Act 1985 (WA). The primary issue was whether the tenancy constituted a regulated commercial tenancy, specifically a "retail shop," and whether an automotive service workshop could be considered analogous to a retail shop. This was examined in light of the significant proportion of profit derived from the sale of parts consumed during the servicing process and whether the premises were used "wholly or predominantly" for this purpose. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The legal issues that the court had to address included determining the precise definition of a "retail shop" under the Act, whether an automotive service workshop could fall under this definition, and if the substantial revenue generated from the sale of parts consumed during servicing qualified the premises as a "retail shop." The court also needed to consider if the premises were used predominantly for the sale of these parts and whether this was analogous to an hotel, which could potentially be classified as a "retail shop." These questions were pivotal in deciding whether the tenancy was regulated under the Act.

The court concluded that the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to entertain the application, leading to the dismissal of the case on that basis. The reasoning provided was that the premises in question did not predominantly function as a "retail shop" as defined by the Act. The court found that while the sale of parts consumed during servicing contributed significantly to the business's revenue, the primary function of the premises was the provision of automotive servicing, not the retail sale of goods. The court also held that the analogy to an hotel did not apply in this context, as the primary activity was not the sale of goods but the application of labour to parts in the course of servicing. Consequently, the preliminary question was answered accordingly.

The orders of the court were that the application was dismissed on the basis that the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to entertain it. Additionally, the preliminary question was answered in line with the court's findings, clarifying the jurisdictional boundaries of the Tribunal in this matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed upon the basis that the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to entertain the application. 2. Preliminary question answered accordingly.

Background

Background to the litigation

Formstar Holdings Pty Ltd, the respondent, is the owner of a commercial property located in Perth, Western Australia. In the course of their property management business, Formstar entered into an agreement to lease the property to Top Notch Roofing Pty Ltd, the appellant, for the purpose of operating an automotive service workshop. The agreement included terms for a fixed-term lease and specified the intended use of the premises as an automotive service facility. The appellant, Top Notch Roofing Pty Ltd, intended to use the premises for offering automotive repair and maintenance services, which included the sale of automotive parts that would be consumed during the servicing process. This arrangement led to a significant portion of the appellant’s profits, approximately 57%, being derived from the sale of these automotive parts.

As part of the lease agreement, the appellant applied to the Western Australia Civil and Administrative Tribunal (WCAT) for a declaration that the proposed tenancy did not constitute a regulated commercial tenancy under the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Act 1985 (WA). The appellant sought this declaration to avoid the stringent protections and regulations applicable to retail tenancies. The Tribunal was asked to determine whether the operation of an automotive service workshop, with a significant portion of its profits coming from the sale of consumable goods, could be considered analogous to a retail shop under the Act. The appellant argued that because the premises would not be used "wholly or predominantly" for the purposes of a retail shop, the tenancy should not be regulated under the Act. Formstar Holdings Pty Ltd opposed the application, contending that the premises would indeed be used for a retail shop, and thus, the tenancy should be subject to the Act’s regulations.

The matter of Formstar Holdings Pty Ltd and Top Notch Roofing Pty Ltd came before the Tribunal following an application by the respondent, Top Notch Roofing Pty Ltd, seeking a determination on the classification of a commercial tenancy under the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Act 1985 (WA). The initial proceedings involved an application by Top Notch Roofing to ascertain whether their automotive service workshop constituted a "retail shop" for the purposes of the Act. This determination was pivotal, as it would affect the applicability of specific tenancy protections and obligations. The application was filed in light of an ongoing tenancy dispute, and the Tribunal was tasked with addressing a preliminary question of statutory interpretation before proceeding with the substantive issues.

Top Notch Roofing argued that the automotive service workshop, which sold goods such as parts consumed during the servicing function, should be classified as a "retail shop" given that 57% of their profit derived from the sale of such parts. They posited an analogy to a hotel, which could be considered a "retail shop" if it met the criteria of being used "wholly or predominantly" for retail purposes. In response, Formstar Holdings contended that the workshop did not fit the statutory definition of a "retail shop" and that the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to entertain the application. The Tribunal was required to navigate through the statutory language and relevant case law to determine whether the premises were being used "wholly or predominantly" for retail purposes. Throughout the proceedings, both parties filed submissions and evidence to support their respective positions, with the Tribunal considering the implications of the statutory definition and its application to the specific facts of the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the premises in question constituted a "retail shop" as defined by the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Act 1985 (WA).
2. Whether an automotive service workshop could be considered a "retail shop" under the Act.
3. Whether the consumption of goods (parts) during the servicing function qualified the business as a "retail shop".
4. Whether 57% of the profit derived from the sale of such parts could be analogous to an hotel and still qualify the premises as a "retail shop".
5. Whether the premises were used "wholly or predominantly" for the purposes of a "retail shop".

Held
1. The court concluded that the premises in question did not constitute a "retail shop" as defined by the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Act 1985 (WA), and thus the application was dismissed.
2. The court held that an automotive service workshop could not be considered a "retail shop" under the Act.
3. The court found that the consumption of goods (parts) during the servicing function did not qualify the business as a "retail shop".
4. The court determined that 57% of the profit derived from the sale of such parts could not be analogous to an hotel and still qualify the premises as a "retail shop".
5. The court held that the premises were not used "wholly or predominantly" for the purposes of a "retail shop".

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Formstar Holdings Pty Ltd and Top Notch Roofing Pty Ltd, the primary issue before the tribunal was whether the premises in question constituted a "retail shop" as defined by the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Act 1985 (WA). The court meticulously examined the statutory definition of a "retail shop" to ascertain whether the premises fit within this category. The Act defines a retail shop as a place where goods are sold or offered for sale, and where the primary function of the business is the sale of goods rather than the provision of services. The court noted that a retail shop may include premises used for the sale of goods, even if those goods are consumed during the provision of a service. This interpretation was crucial in understanding whether an automotive service workshop could be considered a retail shop under the Act.

The court then turned its attention to whether an automotive service workshop could be classified as a retail shop. This inquiry required a detailed examination of the nature of the business operations within the premises. The court considered whether the primary purpose of the business was the sale of goods or the provision of services. It was established that the primary function of an automotive service workshop is the provision of automotive repair and maintenance services, rather than the sale of goods. However, the court recognised that the consumption of goods, such as parts, during the servicing function could potentially bring such a business within the ambit of a retail shop. This consideration was pivotal in determining whether the consumption of goods during the servicing function qualified the business as a retail shop.

In exploring whether the consumption of goods during the servicing function qualified the business as a retail shop, the court applied the statutory definition and interpreted the term "consumed" to mean that the goods were used up in the course of providing the service. The court examined whether the parts used in the servicing process could be considered as being sold or offered for sale. It found that while the parts were integral to the service provided, they were not sold independently of the service. The court also considered the percentage of profit derived from the sale of such parts, which was 57%, and whether this could be analogous to an hotel, which could be considered a retail shop. This analogy was significant in understanding whether the premises could still qualify as a retail shop despite the high percentage of profit from parts sales.

The court then addressed the question of whether the 57% of profit derived from the sale of parts could be analogous to an hotel, which could be considered a retail shop. The court examined the nature of the profit derived from the sale of parts and compared it to the profit derived from the sale of goods in an hotel. It noted that while the profit percentage was significant, the primary function of the business remained the provision of automotive repair and maintenance services. The court concluded that the analogy to an hotel was not apt, as the primary function of the business was not the sale of goods but the provision of services. This finding was critical in determining whether the premises were used "wholly or predominantly" for the purposes of a retail shop.

Finally, the court examined whether the premises were used "wholly or predominantly" for the purposes of a retail shop. The court considered the overall business operations and the proportion of the business dedicated to the sale of goods versus the provision of services. It found that while a significant portion of the profit was derived from the sale of parts, the primary function of the business was the provision of automotive repair and maintenance services. The court concluded that the premises were not used "wholly or predominantly" for the purposes of a retail shop, as the primary function was not the sale of goods but the provision of services. The ratio decidendi of this case is that an automotive service workshop, despite the consumption of goods during the servicing function and a significant percentage of profit derived from the sale of such parts, does not constitute a retail shop under the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Act 1985 (WA) if the primary function of the business is the provision of services rather than the sale of goods. The court distinguished its decision from prior authority by emphasising the importance of the primary function of the business in determining whether the premises qualify as a retail shop.