Forman & York v The Owners - Units Plan 312

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



FORMAN & YORK v THE OWNERS - UNITS PLAN 312 & ANOR
(Unit Titles) [2015] ACAT 88

UT 15/30

Catchwords:              UNIT TITLES – encroachments – whether survey overrides registered plan – access to common property – restraint of adjoining owner from alleged encroachment – removal of alleged encroachment – circumstances where such orders are appropriate – validity of resolutions – order amending resolution

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 48

Common Boundaries Act 1981 s 10

Land Titles Act1925 s 58

Land Titles (Unit Titles) Act 1970

Legislation Act 2001 s 88

Unit Titles Act 2001 ss 26, 32, 33

Unit Titles Act 1970 (repealed) s 26

Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 ss 19, 20, 129,161 and 164

Cases cited:    Briginshaw v Briginshaw  (1938) 60 CLR 336

CIC Australia Ltd v ACT Planning and Land Authority,      Mainore Pty Ltd and ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal   [2013] ACTSC 96; (2013) 277 FLR 26

Forman and York v ACT Planning and Land Authority and Evans and Evans [2013] ACTSC 167

James v Registrar General (1967) 68 SR (NSW) 361

Redland Bricks Ltd v Morris [1970] AC 652

Tribunal:                   Mr B. Meagher SC, Senior Member

Date of Orders:  17 December 2015
Date of Reasons for Decision:         17 December 2015

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL  UT 30 of 2015

BETWEEN:

DAVID FORMAN AND SARA YORK
Applicants

AND:

THE OWNERS – UNIT PLAN 312
First Respondent

JO - ANN HARDIE
Second Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Mr B. Meagher SC – Senior Member

DATE:  17 December 2015

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

  1. Pursuant to section 129(f) of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 the special resolution of the general meeting of the second respondent held on 26 June 2014 be amended to read:

    “Article 4(e) of the Articles of Unit Plan 312 be deleted and replaced with the following words:

    (e) except in accordance with the express permission of a simple majority of voters at a general meeting of the Corporation and in accordance with the provisions of any law in force in the Territory applicable in the circumstances, erect or alter any structure in or on his, her or its unit.”

  2. The application be otherwise dismissed.

  3. There be no order as to costs.

    ………………………………..

Mr B. Meagher SC

Senior Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Proceedings and Parties

  1. This is an application by David Forman and Sara York, the owners of unit 4 of Units Plan 312 seeking orders set out in their amended application dated 17 June 2015. At the hearing the applicants who appeared for themselves helpfully provided a separate typed list of the orders sought and it is set out in paragraph 48. The second respondent is the owner of unit 3 which has a common boundary with unit 4 on its south-western side. She was also unrepresented. The first respondent, the Body Corporate was represented by the other owners Ms Nicole Gaha, Mr Peter Hogan and Ms Jessica Hogan. Peter Hogan spoke on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forman & York v The Owners - Units Plan 312 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ACAT 88
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Forman & York v The Owners - Units Plan 312 was before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, where the applicants sought to amend the special resolution concerning the erection or alteration of structures in or on their units. The dispute arose out of the applicants' contention that the current wording of Article 4(e) of the Articles of Unit Plan 312 was overly restrictive and inconsistent with the requirements of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011. The applicants argued that the resolution should be amended to require express permission from a simple majority of voters at a general meeting, in addition to complying with relevant laws.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the current wording of Article 4(e) was valid and whether the applicants had provided sufficient grounds for its amendment. In particular, the Tribunal needed to examine the extent to which the existing provisions complied with the statutory requirements and assess the implications of the proposed changes on the rights of other unit owners. The Tribunal also needed to consider whether the applicants had demonstrated that the proposed amendment was necessary to achieve a fair and reasonable outcome for all parties involved.

The Tribunal found that the existing wording of Article 4(e) was inconsistent with the statutory provisions and that the applicants had provided adequate grounds for its amendment. The Tribunal determined that the proposed changes would strike an appropriate balance between the rights of individual unit owners and the need to maintain a harmonious and orderly environment within the unit plan. The Tribunal also found that the applicants had demonstrated that the amendment was necessary to achieve a fair and reasonable outcome for all parties involved. Consequently, the Tribunal ordered that the special resolution be amended to reflect the applicants' proposal and dismissed the application in all other respects. There was no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Orders that:

1.

Pursuant to section 129(f) of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 the special resolution of the general meeting of the second respondent held on 26 June 2014 be amended to read:

“Article 4(e) of the Articles of Unit Plan 312 be deleted and replaced with the following words:

(e) except in accordance with the express permission of a simple majority of voters at a general meeting of the Corporation and in accordance with the provisions of any law in force in the Territory applicable in the circumstances, erect or alter any structure in or on his, her or its unit.”

2.

The application be otherwise dismissed.

3.

There be no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between the appellants, Forman & York, and the Owners – Units Plan 312, concerning the interpretation and amendment of Article 4(e) of the Articles of Unit Plan 312. The appellants, owners of units in the Unit Plan, sought to alter their units by erecting a carport and a verandah. The Owners – Units Plan 312 opposed this alteration, asserting that it was not permitted under the existing Articles. A general meeting of the Corporation was held on 26 June 2014, where a special resolution was passed that permitted the erection or alteration of structures with express permission from a simple majority of voters, subject to compliance with applicable laws. Dissatisfied with this resolution, the appellants applied to the Tribunal for an amendment to the Articles.

The matter was heard by the Tribunal after an application was filed by the appellants seeking an amendment to the Articles of Unit Plan 312. The Tribunal reviewed the application and heard submissions from both parties. The appellants argued that the resolution passed at the general meeting did not sufficiently protect their rights and interests as unit owners, while the Owners – Units Plan 312 contended that the resolution was in accordance with the Act and adequately balanced the rights of all unit owners. The Tribunal assessed the application and the relevant legal provisions before making its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the special resolution of the general meeting of the Corporation held on 26 June 2014 should be amended to alter the provisions of Article 4(e) of the Articles of Unit Plan 312.
2. Whether the proposed amendment to Article 4(e) complies with the requirements of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 and applicable laws.

Held
1. The special resolution of the general meeting of the Corporation held on 26 June 2014 should be amended to alter the provisions of Article 4(e) of the Articles of Unit Plan 312. The Tribunal ordered the amendment of the resolution to reflect the replacement wording.
2. The proposed amendment to Article 4(e) complies with the requirements of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 and applicable laws. The amendment was found to be in compliance, leading to its implementation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal examined the provisions of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 and the context in which the special resolution was passed. The court determined that the amendment to Article 4(e) was necessary to ensure that the erection or alteration of any structure within the unit plan adhered to the legislative requirements and any applicable laws in the Territory. The amendment aimed to provide clarity and compliance with legal standards by specifying the need for express permission from a simple majority of voters at a general meeting. The Tribunal found that the proposed amendment was in line with statutory provisions and did not conflict with any other legal obligations, thus upholding the amendment. The decision underscored the importance of adhering to legislative mandates in the management of unit plans and the need for clear and compliant resolutions in governing bodies.