Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Forgall Pty Ltd v Greater Taree City Council [2015] NSWCA 340 Hearing dates: 27 October 2015 Decision date: 27 October 2015 Before: Basten JA; Simpson JA Decision: (1) Application for leave to appeal dismissed.
(2) Applicant to pay the respondent’s costs in this Court.Catchwords: APPEAL – civil – application for leave – decision of judge of Land and Environment Court on appeal from decision of Commissioner in Class 1 jurisdiction – whether arguable error – whether issue of principle – whether procedural unfairness – whether detailed landscape plan required – whether “concession” by Council that plan could form part of conditions of consent
PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT – development prohibited unless consistent with objectives of zone – onus on applicant to satisfy Court that condition complied with – preparation of draft conditions if consent forthcomingLegislation Cited: Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW), ss 56A, 57 Cases Cited: Warkworth Mining Ltd v Bulga Milbrodale Progress Association Inc (2014) 86 NSWLR 527; [2014] NSWCA 105 Category: Principal judgment Parties: Forgall Pty Ltd (Applicant)
Greater Taree City Council (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Mr A Crossland/Mr D Sweeney (Applicant)
Mr A Gallasso SC (Respondent)
LS Law (Applicant)
Marsdens Law Group (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2015/151782 Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- Land and Environment Court
- Jurisdiction:
- Class 1
- Citation:
- [2015] NSWLEC 61
- Date of Decision:
- 23 April 2015
- Before:
- Preston CJ
- File Number(s):
- LEC 10682 of 2014
Judgment
-
JUDGMENT of THE COURT delivered by BASTEN JA: On 2 May 2008 the applicant, Forgall Pty Ltd, lodged a development application, later amended, with the respondent Council seeking to build what was described as a “post-operative and complementary health clinic for cancer patients and other seriously ill people” on land at Saltwater Road, Wallabi Point. The development was prohibited unless it satisfied objectives stated with respect to the relevant zone in the applicable Greater Taree Local Environmental Plan. The Council rejected the application. The applicant brought an appeal in the Class 1 jurisdiction of the Land and Environment Court. The appeal was dismissed on 30 June 2014 by Commissioner Dixon. An appeal lay from the Commissioner’s decision to a judge of the Land and Environment Court pursuant to s 56A of the Land and Environment Court Act1979 (NSW). The appeal was limited to a question of law.
-
The applicant lodged an appeal from the decision of the Commissioner. Relevantly for present purposes, the appeal raised an issue of procedural unfairness in the manner the Commissioner had disposed of the application before her. The appeal was dismissed by Preston CJ (LEC) on 23 April 2015. [1]
1. Forgall Pty Ltd v Greater Taree City Council [2015] NSWLEC 61 (“Forgall”).
-
The applicant seeks leave to appeal from the judgment of Preston CJ pursuant to s 57 of the Land and Environment Court Act. Leave is required pursuant to s 57(4).
-
The sole issue sought to be raised concerns the complaint of procedural…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Forgall Pty Ltd v Greater Taree City Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NSWCA 340
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether there was an arguable error of law or fact in the primary judge's decision, whether the matter raised an issue of principle, and whether the applicant had suffered procedural unfairness. Specifically, the Court considered whether the development, which was prohibited unless consistent with the objectives of the zone, had satisfied the onus on the applicant to demonstrate compliance, and whether the preparation of draft conditions, including a landscape plan, was a prerequisite for consent.
Basten and Simpson JJA dismissed the application for leave to appeal. The Court found that no arguable error or issue of principle had been demonstrated. The primary judge had correctly applied the relevant planning legislation, which placed the onus on the applicant to satisfy the Court that the proposed development was consistent with the objectives of the zone. The Court also found no evidence of procedural unfairness, noting that the Council's actions did not constitute a binding concession regarding the landscape plan.
Consequently, the Court ordered that the application for leave to appeal be dismissed, and that the applicant pay the respondent's costs in the Court of Appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Application for leave to appeal dismissed.
(2) Applicant to pay the respondent’s costs in this Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
Upon reviewing Forgall's application, the Council found that the proposed development did not align with the objectives of the residential zone and thus rejected the application. Dissatisfied with the decision, Forgall appealed to the Land and Environment Court, arguing that the Council's decision was incorrect and that the proposed development was consistent with the zoning objectives. The Land and Environment Court subsequently dismissed Forgall's appeal, upholding the Council's decision. Forgall then sought leave to appeal the Land and Environment Court's decision to the Court of Appeal, claiming there were arguable errors and procedural unfairness in the lower court's decision.
The Court of Appeal needed to determine whether the Land and Environment Court made an arguable error in law, whether the case involved an issue of principle, and if there was procedural unfairness in the proceedings. Additionally, the Court examined whether a detailed landscape plan was necessary for the approval of the development and whether the Council's indication that such a plan could form part of the conditions of consent constituted a concession. These factual considerations were central to the legal dispute between Forgall and the Greater Taree City Council.
Forgall Pty Ltd v Greater Taree City Council concerns an appeal from a decision made by a judge of the Land and Environment Court, which itself was an appeal from a decision rendered by a Commissioner in a Class 1 jurisdiction. The applicant, Forgall Pty Ltd, sought leave to appeal against the judge's decision, which had dismissed its appeal against the Commissioner’s ruling. Forgall’s primary contention was that the judge made an arguable error of law, raising issues of principle, and that the proceedings were unfair due to procedural missteps. The case also revolved around whether a detailed landscape plan was necessary and whether a concession by the Council, that such a plan could form part of the conditions of consent, was binding.
The matter originated when Forgall applied for development consent to the Greater Taree City Council, which was ultimately refused. Dissatisfied with the decision, Forgall appealed to the Commissioner. The Commissioner’s decision was subsequently appealed by Forgall to the Land and Environment Court. The Land and Environment Court judge dismissed Forgall’s appeal, leading to Forgall’s application for leave to appeal to a higher court. This application involved an assessment of whether the judge's decision contained an arguable error of law, constituted a matter of principle, or involved procedural unfairness. Additionally, the application considered whether a detailed landscape plan was mandatory and whether the Council’s concession regarding the plan could be enforced as a condition of consent.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court of Appeal should grant leave to appeal the decision of the judge of the Land and Environment Court.
2. Whether there was an arguable error in the decision of the judge of the Land and Environment Court.
3. Whether the issue raised in the appeal is of principle or exceptional public importance.
4. Whether there was procedural unfairness in the decision of the judge of the Land and Environment Court.
5. Whether a detailed landscape plan is required as part of the planning approval process.
6. Whether the Greater Taree City Council made a concession that the landscape plan could form part of the conditions of consent.
Held
1. Whether the Court of Appeal should grant leave to appeal the decision of the judge of the Land and Environment Court. The Court of Appeal concluded that leave to appeal should not be granted, resulting in the dismissal of the application for leave.
2. Whether there was an arguable error in the decision of the judge of the Land and Environment Court. The Court found that there was no arguable error in the decision of the judge.
3. Whether the issue raised in the appeal is of principle or exceptional public importance. The Court determined that the issue was not of principle or exceptional public importance.
4. Whether there was procedural unfairness in the decision of the judge of the Land and Environment Court. The Court held that there was no procedural unfairness in the decision of the judge.
5. Whether a detailed landscape plan is required as part of the planning approval process. The Court concluded that a detailed landscape plan is required as part of the planning approval process.
6. Whether the Greater Taree City Council made a concession that the landscape plan could form part of the conditions of consent. The Court found that there was no such concession by the Council.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal in Forgall Pty Ltd v Greater Taree City Council was tasked with determining whether leave to appeal the decision of the judge of the Land and Environment Court should be granted. In addressing this issue, the Court considered the existence of an arguable error in the original decision. The Court found that the judge of the Land and Environment Court had correctly applied the legal principles and had not erred in their decision. The Court further examined whether the issue raised in the appeal was of principle or exceptional public importance, concluding that it was not. This was significant as the Court of Appeal typically grants leave to appeal in cases where the matter involves significant legal questions or substantial public interest.
In assessing the potential error in the decision of the judge of the Land and Environment Court, the Court applied the principle that the onus is on the applicant to demonstrate that the proposed condition for development approval complies with the objectives of the zoning. The Court held that the judge had correctly determined that the applicant had not satisfied this onus. The Court referenced the statutory framework under which the judge operated, emphasizing that the preparation of a draft condition for approval is contingent on the applicant meeting the required compliance standards. The authorities cited underscored the importance of aligning development proposals with zoning objectives, and the Court found that the judge had appropriately applied these legal principles to the facts of the case.
The Court also considered whether there was procedural unfairness in the decision of the judge of the Land and Environment Court. It found that there was no procedural unfairness, as the applicant had been given ample opportunity to present its case and respond to the issues raised. The Court highlighted that procedural fairness requires a fair hearing process, which was adhered to by the judge. The authorities on procedural fairness were applied to ensure that the applicant’s rights were protected throughout the proceedings. The Court concluded that the procedural integrity of the decision was intact, and no unfairness had occurred.
One of the key issues in the case was whether a detailed landscape plan was required as part of the planning approval process. The Court of Appeal determined that the requirement for a detailed landscape plan was a matter of statutory obligation. It found that the judge had correctly interpreted the statutory provisions and that the applicant had not demonstrated a valid basis for its claim that such a plan was unnecessary. The Court emphasized that statutory compliance is crucial in planning and environmental law, and the judge’s interpretation was consistent with legislative intent. The authorities supporting this interpretation were aligned with legislative objectives and the need for comprehensive planning.
The Court also addressed whether the Greater Taree City Council had made a concession that the landscape plan could form part of the conditions of consent. The Court found that the Council had not made such a concession and that the judge’s decision on this point was correct. The Court applied the principle that any concession made by a party must be clear and unequivocal, and in this case, no such concession had been made. The authorities on the interpretation of concessions in planning matters were applied to support the Court’s finding. The Court held that the judge’s determination on this issue was well-founded and did not constitute an error.
In summary, the Court of Appeal dismissed the application for leave to appeal, finding no arguable error in the decision of the judge of the Land and Environment Court. The Court upheld the requirement for a detailed landscape plan and found no procedural unfairness. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the onus is on the applicant to demonstrate compliance with statutory planning requirements, and any concession by a council must be clear and unequivocal. The Court’s decision was consistent with prior authority and underscored the importance of statutory compliance and procedural fairness in planning and environmental law.