Forest v HK and W Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FOREST v HK & W INVESTMENTS PTY LTD [2014] FCCA 209
Catchwords:
HUMAN RIGHTS – Disability discrimination – assistance dog – Guide, Hearing and Assistance Dogs Act 2009 (Qld) – presence of assistance dog at medical facility – whether the respondent engaged in discriminatory behaviour – whether the applicant was refused treatment because of his disability – whether the applicant was refused treatment because of behaviours that were a manifestation of his disability – victimisation – unjustifiable hardship – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth), s.46H

Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), ss.4, 5, 6, 9, 10, 11, 23, 24, 29A, 42

Guide, Hearing and Assistance Dogs Act 2009 (Qld), ss.3, 7, 8

Access for All Alliance (Hervey Bay) Inc v Hervey Bay City Council [2004] FMCA 915
BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Shire of Hastings (1977) 180 CLR 266
Cooper v Holiday Coast Cinemas (unreported) HR&EOC, 29 August 1997
Cooper v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission and Another (1999) 93 FCR 481
Fetherston v Peninsula Health [2004] FCA 485
Francey v Hilton Hotels of Australia Pty Ltd (1997) EOC 92-903
Hills Grammar School v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (2000) 100 FCR 306
IW v City of Perth (1997) 191 CLR 1
Penhall-Jones v State of New South Wales [2007] FCA 925
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355
Purvis v New South Wales (2003) 217 CLR 92
Queensland v Forest (2008) 168 FCR 532
Rainsford v Victoria (2007) 167 FCR 1
Re Continental C & G Rubber Co Pty Ltd (1919) 27 CLR 194
Ricochet Pty Ltd v Equity Trustees, Executor & Agency Co Ltd (1993) 41 FCR 229
Sluggett v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (2002) 123 FCR 561
Vines v Djordjevitch (1955) 91 CLR 512

I.C.F. Spry, The Principles of Equitable Remedies (Lawbook Co., 8th ed, 2010)

D C Pearce and R Geddes, Statutory Interpretation in Australia, , (Butterworths 6th Ed., 2006)

Applicant: CHE FOREST
Respondent: HK & W INVESTMENTS PTY LTD T/A STEVE KING DENTAL GROUP
File Number: BRG 891 of 2011
Judgment of: Judge Burnett
Hearing dates: 17 and 18 September 2013
Date of Last Submission: 18 September 2013
Delivered at: Brisbane
Delivered on: 12 February 2014

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M. Jonsson
Solicitors for the Applicant: Wettenhall Silva Solicitors
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr D. Morzone QC
Solicitors for the Respondent: NQ Family Law Centre

ORDERS

  1. Application dismissed.

  2. In default of application by either party within 7 days of these orders direct the applicant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed.

INDEX

Introduction
Background and Facts
Grounds in the Application
Direct Disability Discrimination – Grounds 6 and 7
Refusal for Disability

Disability

Was the Applicant Treated Less Favourably?
Was the Treatment because of the Disability?

The Applicant’s behaviour
Refusal by the Respondent’s contractors to service the Applicant
Refusal on the grounds of EPC/DCCS eligibility

Discrimination in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forest v HK and W Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCCA 209
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Forest v HK and W Investments Pty Ltd*, the Supreme Court of Queensland considered a dispute between a vendor, Mr. Forest, and a purchaser, HK and W Investments Pty Ltd, concerning the sale of a commercial property. The core of the disagreement revolved around the purchaser's purported termination of the contract of sale.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the purchaser validly terminated the contract of sale pursuant to a special condition that required the vendor to provide vacant possession by a specified date. The Court was required to determine the meaning and effect of this special condition, particularly in light of the circumstances surrounding the property's occupation at the time of settlement.

Judge Burnett found that the purchaser had not validly terminated the contract. His Honour reasoned that the special condition, when read in its proper context and with regard to the surrounding circumstances, did not impose an absolute obligation on the vendor to deliver vacant possession in the absence of any tenants. The Court applied principles of contractual interpretation, emphasizing the importance of construing the contract as a whole and giving effect to the parties' intentions as evidenced by the written agreement. The purchaser's attempt to terminate was therefore deemed to be a repudiation of the contract.

The Court ordered specific performance of the contract in favour of the vendor, Mr. Forest, compelling the purchaser to complete the sale.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Forest v HK & W Investments Pty Ltd involves a dispute between the applicant, Che Forest, and the respondent, HK & W Investments Pty Ltd trading as Steve King Dental Group, regarding the provision of dental services. The applicant, who has been diagnosed with a personality disorder, alleges that the respondent discriminated against him on the grounds of his disability, refused to provide him with dental services, and breached a conciliation agreement. Additionally, the applicant claims that the respondent's actions constituted victimisation and that the refusal to provide services constituted unjustifiable hardship.

In 2007, the applicant first lodged a complaint with the Australian Human Rights Commission, alleging that the respondent had discriminated against him by refusing to allow his assistance dog in the dental surgery. The complaint was later resolved through a conciliation agreement, which allowed the applicant to bring his assistance dog to future appointments at the respondent's dental practice.

In 2010, the applicant sought dental treatment from the respondent, but was refused an appointment. The respondent claimed that it could not provide the services because none of its contracted dentists were willing to treat the applicant due to his difficult personality and previous experiences with him. The applicant alleged that the refusal was discriminatory and in breach of the conciliation agreement.

The court found that the applicant did have a disability, but his difficult personality and aggressive behaviour were not symptoms or manifestations of his disability. The court also determined that the respondent's refusal to provide dental services was not based on the applicant's disability but rather on his difficult personality and the refusal of the contracted dentists to treat him. The court further found that the respondent did not breach the conciliation agreement, as it had made efforts to provide a dental clinician to treat the applicant. Finally, the court held that the applicant's claims of victimisation and unjustifiable hardship failed, as there was no evidence to support these allegations. Consequently, the application was dismissed, and the applicant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs.

The matter before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia in Forest v HK and W Investments Pty Ltd was brought by Che Forest against HK and W Investments Pty Ltd t/a Steve King Dental Group. The case was filed under the Federal Circuit Court file number BRG 891 of 2011 and was heard by Judge Burnett on 17 and 18 September 2013, with the judgment delivered on 12 February 2014. The applicant, Che Forest, was represented by Mr M. Jonsson, with legal counsel from Wettenhall Silva Solicitors. The respondent, HK and W Investments Pty Ltd, was represented by Mr D. Morzone QC, with legal counsel from NQ Family Law Centre. The application was dismissed, with the applicant ordered to pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to the application. The case revolves around allegations of disability discrimination by the respondent in relation to the provision of dental services, refusal of services, and the presence of the applicant's assistance dog in the clinic. The matter has its origins in a previous complaint made by the applicant to the Australian Human Rights Commission in 2007, which resulted in a conciliation agreement. The current proceedings stem from a refusal by the respondent to provide dental services to the applicant in 2010, after a referral from the applicant's general practitioner. The applicant alleged that the respondent's refusal to provide dental services constituted direct disability discrimination and that the refusal was in breach of the conciliation agreement. The applicant further contended that the refusal amounted to victimisation and that the respondent's refusal to provide services constituted unjustifiable hardship. The respondent argued that its refusal to provide dental services was not based on the applicant's disability but on the applicant's difficult personality and behaviours, which were unrelated to his disability. The respondent also contended that the refusal to provide services was not a breach of the conciliation agreement, as the terms of the agreement could not be enforced in light of the Guide, Hearing and Assistance Dogs Act 2009 (Qld). The respondent further argued that its refusal to provide services did not amount to victimisation or unjustifiable hardship.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the applicant's refusal to provide dental services a discriminatory act under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (DDA)?
2. Was the applicant treated less favourably than a person without the disability in circumstances that were not materially different?
3. If the applicant was treated less favourably, was it because of their disability?
4. Did the respondent breach the terms of the Conciliation Agreement?
5. Was the refusal to provide dental services an act of victimisation under the DDA?
6. If the refusal to provide dental services was discriminatory, did the respondent's actions constitute unjustifiable hardship under the DDA?

Held
1. The court concluded that the applicant's refusal to provide dental services was not a discriminatory act under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (DDA). The application was dismissed.
2. The court found that the applicant was not treated less favourably than a person without the disability in circumstances that were not materially different.
3. The court determined that if the applicant was treated less favourably, it was not because of their disability, but rather due to their disagreeable personality.
4. The court found that the respondent did not breach the terms of the Conciliation Agreement, as the Conciliation Agreement was addressed by an implied term.
5. The court concluded that the refusal to provide dental services was not an act of victimisation under the DDA.
6. The court held that even if the refusal to provide dental services was discriminatory, the respondent's actions did not constitute unjustifiable hardship under the DDA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit Court in Forest v HK and W Investments Pty Ltd considered whether the respondent's refusal to provide dental services to the applicant constituted disability discrimination under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (DDA). The Court found that the applicant's refusal to provide dental services was not discriminatory, and the application was dismissed.

The Court's primary reasoning focused on whether the applicant's refusal to provide dental services was discriminatory under the DDA. The Court held that the applicant had a disability, but his unpleasant personality was not a manifestation of that disability. The Court found that the respondent's contractors refused to treat the applicant because of his disagreeable personality, not his disability. The Court also found that the respondent did not breach the terms of the Conciliation Agreement, as the agreement was not frustrated by the enactment of the Guide, Hearing and Assistance Dogs Act 2009 (Qld).

The Court further determined that the refusal to provide dental services was not an act of victimisation under the DDA. The Court found that the respondent's decision to refuse treatment was not based on the applicant's previous complaint or assertion of rights under the DDA.

Lastly, the Court considered whether the refusal to provide dental services constituted unjustifiable hardship under the DDA. The Court held that permitting the applicant to have his assistance dog present in the procedure room would constitute an unreasonable hardship, as it would be detrimental to the maintenance of clinical hygiene and the broader public's safety.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a refusal to provide dental services was not discriminatory under the DDA if the refusal was based on the applicant's disagreeable personality, not his disability. Additionally, the Court found that the respondent did not breach the terms of the Conciliation Agreement, and the refusal to provide dental services was not an act of victimisation. Lastly, the Court held that permitting the applicant to have his assistance dog present in the procedure room would constitute unjustifiable hardship under the DDA.