Forde v Toowoomba Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read


PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Forde v Toowoomba Regional Council [2008] QPEC 114

PARTIES:

GRANT LINDSAY FORDE

(Appellant)

v

TOOWOOMBA REGIONAL COUNCIL

(Respondent)

FILE NO:

BD 4 OF 2007

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

DELIVERED ON:

12 December 2008

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27 and 28 November 2008

JUDGE:

Judge Brabazon QC

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING – PLANNING SCHEMES AND INSTRUMENTS – CONFLICT WITH PLANNING SCHEMES – where proposal is in conflict with planning scheme – lot reconfiguration – establishment of commercial stables in conjunction with houses

LEGISLATION CITED:

Integrated Planning Act 1997 (Qld)

CASES CITED:

Legal & General Life of Australia Ltdv North Sydney Municipal Council (1990) 69 LGRA 201

Sweeney Pastoral Company v Snowy River Shire Council [1993] NSWLEC 189

COUNSEL:

Mr S P Fynes-Clinton for the Appellant

Mr S M Ure for the Respondent

SOLICITORS:

Hede Byrne & Hall Solicitors for the Appellant

Deacons for the Respondent

  1. The Issues

  1. The address, 31 Glenvale Road, Toowoomba, actually covers two adjoining pieces of land.  They are lots 19 and 20.  They are long rectangular pieces of land, of roughly similar area.  The combined area is 2,458 m2.

  1. The front part of lot 19 is vacant land, while the front part of lot 20 contains a house, with a garage behind it.  Towards the back of each lot there are horse stables and associated sheds and equipment.  There are stalls for 12 horses.  The two blocks of land have been used together for around 40 years as horse stables.  The aerial photo at p 5 of Ms Roughan’s report shows the two lots at the present time.

  1. A change is now proposed.  Mr Forde’s wish is that the existing house and garage on lot 20 should become a separate lot of 537 m2.  Behind the garage, the boundary between lots 19 and 20 would be removed, so creating a hatchet or L-shaped block on the one title.  The proposal can be seen at p 2 of Ms Roughan’s report.  The new lot 19 would have an area of 1,924 m2.

  1. The Council has refused to approve that change.  Mr Forde has appealed to this court.  Should the change be allowed, or not?

  1. The appeal means that there has been a fresh hearing before this court.  That is, the court has a duty to consider the merits of the appeal based on the evidence, independently of any view which Council took.  Mr Forde is the appellant, and he has the burden of proving that the appeal should be allowed.

  1. It must be understood that this court is in no sense a planning authority.  That is the duty of the Toowoomba City Council.  The court acts on all the evidence, including, in particular, the town planning provisions adopted by Council.

  1. In this case, some established principles are important.  If the proposal is in conflict with provisions of the planning scheme, that conflict should be identified.  The application might be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forde v Toowoomba Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QPEC 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Forde v Toowoomba Regional Council, the applicant sought to reconfigure two lots of land for the establishment of commercial stables in conjunction with houses. The Toowoomba Regional Council rejected the application, finding that it conflicted with the planning scheme. The applicant appealed the decision to the court, which was required to determine whether the proposal complied with the planning scheme and whether any conflicts could be justified by planning merits. The court found that the applicant's proposal did indeed conflict with the planning scheme, particularly regarding the establishment of commercial stables and their establishment in conjunction with houses. The court held that the applicant failed to demonstrate sufficient planning merit to warrant the adoption of the proposal despite the conflicts. The court concluded that the council's decision was correct and dismissed the appeal. The court's reasoning was based on the importance of adhering to the planning scheme and minimising adverse amenity impacts, particularly in relation to the proximity of stables and houses. The court found that the proposal would likely result in increased conflicts if the house were sold separately, and that the current access arrangement for the stables was both lawful and practical. The court found that the applicant's proposal did not meet the necessary planning standards, and therefore the appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusions Mr Fynes-Clinton, in his comprehensive and helpful submissions, mentioned everything in favour of the application. He urged the adoption of Mr Buller’s conclusion that there is sufficient planning merit in the proposal to warrant its adoption despite any conflict as to the scheme. However, once it is seen that the scheme provisions (particularly because of the issues about “commercial stables” and “established in conjunction with stables”) have been more accurately applied by Ms Roughan, it is clear that her opinion should prevail. The Council’s decision was correct. There are conflicts between the proposal and the scheme provisions. There are no planning grounds sufficient to justify this proposal, despite the conflicts. The appeal must be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Other Considerations The reference to houses is important in this case, because of the house on lot 20. If this appeal were allowed, the reconfiguration of the land would mean that the house could be sold to anybody. That is a result which would be in conflict with the provision of the planning scheme. It can be accepted that a proposed development would continue to give effect to the existing use of the land for stables. However, it would make a different with regard to the house. It is quite possible, or even probable, that the resulting small lot would be sold to someone unrelated to the stables’ operation. It is true, that adjustment of the boundary behind the house is necessary, if it is sold, to allow access to lot 20, over lot 19. There is no effective access at the present time to the rear of lot 20, other than from lot 19. That is, the house is constructed so close to the boundary, that it would not safely allow the passage of a medium rigid vehicle. The space available is below the Australian standard. Secondly, the garage behind the house physically stands in the way of access to the rear. It was pointed out that without undue expense or trouble, the garage could be moved. That is so, but the position of the house would seem to be the real obstacle. However, the existing arrangement has worked for 40 years, and there is no suggestion that there is any reason to split the operation on the two blocks of land – at least in relation to the operation of the stables, behind the house. The existence of the two titles does not itself undermine the viability or security of the stable’s operation. Given that the two lots are in common ownership, and used conjointly, the current access arrangement is both lawful and practical. There is evidence that this is not an uncommon arrangement for stables in the precinct. Some other joined lots are used in the same way. There could be an impact, if the house were sold separately. The town planners agreed that amenity impacts and complaints about them were common in situations where stables and houses were established close to each other. For example, stables often mean very early noise and some odours and health concerns. For example, manure has to be disposed of in a certain way and any breakdown in that system could cause a health concern. Adverse amenity impacts need to be minimised or avoided. One way to do that is to have on-site supervision by a manager or caretaker, so that an eye can be kept on problems which might emerge. If the house was sold to someone with no connection with horse training, then those conflicts are likely to be increased. The Planners Of the planners, Ms Roughan gave more appropriate weight to the planning scheme, and the amenity impacts. Her conclusion, which is reflected in these reasons, should be accepted. As she puts it: Conclusions Mr Fynes-Clinton, in his comprehensive and helpful submissions, mentioned everything in favour of the application. He urged the adoption of Mr Buller’s conclusion that there is sufficient planning merit in the proposal to warrant its adoption despite any conflict as to the scheme.