Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Mark Forbes

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Mark Forbes [2007] FCA 1598

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to vacate trial dates – recent summary dismissal application revealed that respondents misconstrued applicant’s case – respondents now seek time to put on further evidence and file a second further amended defence – respondents’ previous solicitor now required to appear as a witness – respondents engaged new solicitors one week ago – whether applicants prejudiced by adjournment application.

COSTS – whether applicants are entitled to costs thrown away by virtue of the adjournment.

HELD – Application granted.  Trial dates vacated.  Applicants entitled to costs thrown away by virtue of the adjournment.

Federal Court Rules O 30 r 7.

The State of Queensland v JL Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146 applied
Jarrett v Westpac Banking Corporation [1999] FCA 425 cited
Robinson v Aware Industries Ltd (unreported, Weinberg J, 1 October 1998) cited
Business in Focus (Aust) Pty Ltd v Began Property Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 264 cited
Menzies v CRCI Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 118 cited

FORBES ENGINEERING (ASIA) PTE LIMITED AND FORBES ENGINEERING HOLDINGS (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED v MARK FORBES AND KAREN LEE FORBES
NSD 636 OF 2005

COLLIER J
18 OCTOBER 2007
BRISBANE

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 636 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

FORBES ENGINEERING (ASIA) PTE LIMITED
First Applicant

FORBES ENGINEERING HOLDINGS (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED
Second Applicant

AND:

MARK FORBES
First Respondent

KAREN LEE FORBES
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 OCTOBER 2007

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The date for trial fixed by the Court be vacated in accordance with Order 30 rule 7 of the Federal Court Rules.

2.The Court dispense with the requirements of service of this Notice of Motion as set out in the Order 19 rule 3 in accordance with Order 19 rule 2 of the Federal Court Rules.

3.The respondents in the substantive proceedings pay the costs thrown away by the applicants in the substantive proceedings as a result of the order in paragraph 1, to be taxed if not otherwise agreed.

4.The costs of and incidental to this Notice of Motion incurred by the applicants in the substantive proceedings be paid by the respondents in the substantive proceedings, to be taxed if not otherwise agreed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 636 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

FORBES ENGINEERING (ASIA) PTE LIMITED
First Applicant

FORBES ENGINEERING HOLDINGS (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED
Second Applicant

AND:

MARK FORBES
First Respondent

KAREN LEE FORBES
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE:

18 OCTOBER 2007

PLACE:

BRISBANE (VIA VIDEO LINK TO SYDNEY)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. I have before me a notice of motion filed yesterday by bci duells lawyers, the solicitors for the first and second respondents in the substantive proceedings (to whom I shall continue to refer as “the respondents”), seeking the following orders :

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Mark Forbes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1598
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Mark Forbes, the applicants sought to recover alleged shortfalls in respect of profit guarantees, which were part of a Share Sale Agreement executed on 17 December 1997. The dispute centered on two claims: one for $127,284 related to the 1998 calendar year and the other for $1,691,284 for the 1999 calendar year. The respondents had sought source financial documentation and working papers to counter the applicants' reliance on reports from Ernst & Young and Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu. However, the respondents were unable to obtain necessary documents and expert reports, leading to their inability to properly examine the applicants' claims.

The legal issues before the court included whether the trial dates should be vacated and whether the applicants should bear the costs of the motion. The court considered the recent change of solicitors for the respondents, the need for a second further amended defence, and the potential prejudice to the respondents if the trial proceeded as scheduled. It was also noted that the respondents had not demonstrated significant prejudice beyond the expected prolongation of the litigation. Additionally, the court examined the respondents' misunderstanding of the applicants' case, which led to a conflict of interest for their solicitor and necessitated new legal representation.

The court ultimately decided to vacate the trial dates in the interests of justice, considering the recent developments and the necessity for the respondents to amend their defence and gather additional evidence. The court found that the respondents' misunderstanding of the applicants' case was not due to any fault of the applicants but rather a failure to clarify the relevance of the requested documents. The court also ordered that the respondents pay the costs incurred by the applicants due to the vacation of the trial dates and that the applicants pay the costs of the motion.

The final orders included the vacation of the trial dates, the waiver of notice service requirements, and the allocation of costs between the parties. The respondents were ordered to pay the costs thrown away by the applicants due to the vacated trial dates, and the applicants were ordered to pay the costs of the motion. The costs were to be taxed if not otherwise agreed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The date for trial fixed by the Court be vacated in accordance with Order 30 rule 7 of the Federal Court Rules.

2. The Court dispense with the requirements of service of this Notice of Motion as set out in the Order 19 rule 3 in accordance with Order 19 rule 2 of the Federal Court Rules.

3. The respondents in the substantive proceedings pay the costs thrown away by the applicants in the substantive proceedings as a result of the order in paragraph 1, to be taxed if not otherwise agreed.

4. The costs of and incidental to this Notice of Motion incurred by the applicants in the substantive proceedings be paid by the respondents in the substantive proceedings, to be taxed if not otherwise agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

I have before me a notice of motion filed yesterday by bci duells lawyers, the solicitors for the first and second respondents in the substantive proceedings (to whom I shall continue to refer as “the respondents”), seeking the following orders :1.The date for trial fixed by the Court be vacated in accordance with Order 30 rule 7 of the Federal Court Rules. 2.The Court dispense with the requirements of service of this Notice as set out in Order 19 rule 3 in accordance with Order 19 rule 2 of the Federal Court Rules.3.Costs of this application and the adjourned trial be reserved to the trial judge.4.Any further order or other order as to this Honourable Court seems appropriate.Background The hearing of the substantive proceedings in this matter is listed for five days commencing Monday 22 October 2007. Accordingly, there is some urgency attendant on a decision as to whether those hearing dates be vacated. In summary, the applicants in the substantive proceedings seek to recover alleged shortfalls in respect of profit guarantees which were the subject of a covenant in a Share Sale Agreement executed on 17 December 1997. The covenant relates to profit guarantees for the second applicant for the 1997, 1998 and 1999 calendar years. In summary, two claims have been made by the applicants :1. a claim for $127,284 which is alleged to be the agreed profit shortfall in respect of the 1998 calendar year.2. a claim for $1,691,284 which is alleged to be the profit shortfall in respect of the 1999 calendar year. In relation to this claim, the applicants have placed reliance on two reports prepared by Ernst & Young and a report produced by Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu. In relation to these claims the respondents have previously sought source financial documentation of the second applicant, and any working papers that might exist in relation to the report of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu, so as to obtain expert evidence to meet and answer the reports relied upon by the applicants. Similarly, the affidavits of the respondents previously filed have been directed towards the substantive correctness of the second applicant’s profit result for each of the 1998 and 1999 calendar years. Ultimately however the respondents were unable to obtain any expert report to meet the reports relied upon by the applicants because:1. the financial source documents relating to the second applicant’s affairs in the 1998 and 1999 calendar years had not been retained by the second applicant and2. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu had not retained its working papers in relation to the report of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu. On 12 September 2007 the respondents filed a notice of motion for a stay of the substantive proceedings pursuant to Order 20 rule 2 Federal Court Rules. The respondents claimed that they were prejudiced because they could not undertake any useful or proper examination of :· all sales of the second applicant that occurred in 1998 or· the trading performance of the second applicant in the 1999 calendar year.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J
In my view the appropriate order is that, in the interests of justice, the hearing dates of the trial should be vacated. I form this view in light of :· the recent change of solicitors of the respondents· the view taken by the new solicitor for the respondents that, in light of developments following the hearing of 26 September 2007, a second further amended defence needs to be filed and served, and additional evidence produced (for which leave will clearly be required)· the fact that the applicants have not demonstrated prejudice other than what would be expected from the prolongation of the litigation beyond next week· the fact that, if the trial were to proceed next week, the respondents would be significantly prejudiced.Decision as to Costs It appears that as a result of the hearing before Tracey J, the respondents now understand that the applicants’ case will be conducted on a different basis than that which they had previously understood. Indeed Counsel before me this morning agreed that the likely length of the trial had reduced from five days to three days. The respondents claim that this misunderstanding, which prompted the notice of motion heard by his Honour, was due to the conduct of the applicants. Indeed, it appears that there has been considerable correspondence between solicitors for both parties involving requests by the respondents for source financial documentation and working papers as discussed earlier in this judgment. The respondents also on 5 February 2007 sought and obtained an order for third party discovery of all documents in the possession of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu relating to the financial affairs of the second applicant concerning the 1997, 1998 and 1999 calendar years. The respondents now complain that it is clear (following the hearing of 26 September 2007) that such documentation is of minimal (if any) relevance to the substantive proceedings, that as a result of the clarification of issues following the hearing before Tracey J their solicitor now must withdraw because of a conflict of interest, and their new solicitors require time to amend their defence and put on further evidence. However, it does not appear to be in dispute that the amended statement of claim as filed 31 March 2006 actually represents the case the applicants are prosecuting and have been prosecuting since last year, and that it represents the case the respondents are required to meet, notwithstanding the apparent narrowing of issues in light of the hearing before Tracey J. While it is true that the respondents appear to have been under a serious misapprehension as to the case of the applicants, which has now lead to the solicitor for the respondents withdrawing due to conflict of interest, it is difficult to identify any fault of the applicants which has lead to this state of affairs other than a failure of the applicants to inform the respondents that the documents the respondents sought were of minimal (or possibly, no) relevance to the case. As Mr Jones said in Court this morning, if the respondents needed clarification of the applicants’ case, they could have sought an order for further and better particulars.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J

Full text does not contain this section.