Forbes and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

Forbes and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 2408 (7 August 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/1771

Re:Emma Forbes

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member J Collins

Date:7  August 2023

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

..................................[SGD]......................................

Senior Member J Collins

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access criteria- NDIS Act s24(1)(c) – s24(1)(e) – s25 - end stage kidney disease - whether applicant meets disability requirements - whether impairments substantially reduce functional capacity- whether applicant meets early intervention requirements - whether likely to require support under National Disability Insurance Scheme for applicant’s lifetime - whether supports more appropriately funded through another service system

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975(Cth) section 43
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) sections 3, 4, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 27, 100, 103, 209

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016 (Cth) rules 2.5, 5.4, 5.5, 5.6, 5.7, 5.8, 6.1

Cases

G v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 79
G v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1229
National Disability Insurance Agency v Foster [2023] FCAFC 11
Mulligan v NDIA [2015] FCA 544; (2015) 233 FCR 201

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] 24ALR 577

Secondary Materials

NDIS - Applying to the NDIS guidelines, as of 1 July 2022.

NDIS - Assistive technology operational guidelines, as of 16 February 2023

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member J Collins

  1. Ms Emma Forbes is a 45-year-old woman, who has a diagnosis of End Stage Kidney Disease (‘ESKD’). In January 20221 Ms Forbes applied to the National Disability Insurance Agency (‘the Agency’) for access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (‘the scheme’) so that she could receive supports. The supports sought included assistance with meals and maintaining her home.[1] That application was refused by the Agency at first instance and again upon internal review. Ms Forbes has now applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) for review of that decision (‘the decision under review’).[2]

    [1] T3.

    [2] T1; section 103 NDIS Act.

  2. For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

    BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION TO THE AGENCY

  3. On 24 February 2021 the Agency affirmed its original decision to refuse Ms Forbes access to the scheme. The Agency maintained that Ms Forbes did not meet the ‘disability requirements’ in section 24 of the National Disability Insurance Act 2013 (‘the NDIS Act’) or the ‘early intervention requirements’ in section 25 of the NDIS Act.[3] The Agency relied on the following:

    ·Subsection 24(1)(c) - that Ms Forbes’ disability did not result in a substantial reduction in her functional capacity;

    ·Subsection 24(1)(e) - that Ms Forbes was likely to require lifetime support from the scheme;

    ·Subsection 25(1)(b) - that early intervention supports will reduce Ms Forbes’ future needs for supports; and

    ·Subsection 25(1)(c) - that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forbes and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2408
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Ms Forbes against the National Disability Insurance Agency's decision to refuse her access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme. The Agency had affirmed its original decision, maintaining that Ms Forbes did not meet the disability requirements under section 24 of the *National Disability Insurance Act 2013* (Cth) or the early intervention requirements under section 25 of the Act. Specifically, the Agency contended that Ms Forbes' impairments did not result in a substantial reduction in her functional capacity, that she was not likely to require lifetime support from the scheme, and that early intervention supports would reduce her future needs and mitigate the impact of her impairments.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Ms Forbes met the disability requirements under section 24 of the NDIS Act, particularly subsections 24(1)(c) and 24(1)(e), and whether she met the early intervention requirements under section 25 of the Act. This involved determining if her end-stage kidney disease and its treatment, including a kidney transplant and immunosuppressant medication, resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity, specifically in social interaction, and whether she was likely to require lifetime support. The Tribunal also considered whether early intervention supports would benefit her by reducing future needs or alleviating the impact of her impairments.

The Tribunal affirmed the Agency's decision, finding that Ms Forbes did not meet the disability requirements under section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act. While acknowledging Ms Forbes' significant health challenges and her admirable efforts to maintain independence and employment, the Tribunal concluded that her functional capacity for social interaction was not substantially reduced to the extent required by the Act. The Tribunal noted that Ms Forbes prioritised her health management and employment, which necessarily limited her energy for social activities. However, it found that the evidence did not establish that her impairments prevented her from participating in social interaction to a "substantially reduced" degree, considering the cumulative effect of her impairments and her ability to engage in some social activities, albeit limited. The Tribunal did not make specific findings on the early intervention requirements as it had already determined Ms Forbes did not meet the disability requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION TO THE AGENCY On 24 February 2021 the Agency affirmed its original decision to refuse Ms Forbes access to the scheme. The Agency maintained that Ms Forbes did not meet the ‘disability requirements’ in section 24 of the National Disability Insurance Act 2013 (‘the NDIS Act’) or the ‘early intervention requirements’ in section 25 of the NDIS Act.[3] The Agency relied on the following:·Subsection 24(1)(c) - that Ms Forbes’ disability did not result in a substantial reduction in her functional capacity;·Subsection 24(1)(e) - that Ms Forbes was likely to require lifetime support from the scheme;·Subsection 25(1)(b) - that early intervention supports will reduce Ms Forbes’ future needs for supports; and·Subsection 25(1)(c) - that early intervention supports will mitigate or alleviate the impact of Ms Forbes impairment upon her functional capacity.[4] [3] T2.[4] T1A; T2.THE NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE ACT 2013 (Cth) The disability requirements are contained in section 24 of the NDIS Act and provide as follows:1.A person meets the disability requirements if:(a)the person has a disability that is attributable to one or more intellectual, cognitive, neurological, sensory or physical impairments or the person has one or more impairments to which a psychosocial disability is attributable; and(b)the impairment or impairments are, or are likely to be, permanent; and(c)the impairment or impairments result in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more of the following activities:(i)communication;(ii)social interaction;(iii)learning;(iv)mobility;(v)self-care;(vi)self-management; and(d)the impairment or impairments affect the person’s capacity for social or economic participation; and(e)the person is likely to require support under the National Disability Insurance Scheme for the person’s lifetime.2. For the purposes of subsection (1), an impairment or impairments that vary in intensity may be permanent, and the person is likely to require support under the National Disability Insurance Scheme for the person's lifetime, despite the variation.3.For the purposes of subsection (1), an impairment or impairments that are episodic or fluctuating may be taken to be permanent, and the person may be taken to be likely to require support under the National Disability Insurance Scheme for the person's lifetime, despite the episodic or fluctuating nature of the impairments.4.Subsection (3) does not limit subsection (2). The requirements of section 24 of the NDIS Act are cumulative and all criteria must be met. The early intervention requirements are contained in section 25 of the NDIS Act provide as follows:1. A person meets the early intervention requirementsif:(a)the person:(i)has one or more identified intellectual, cognitive, neurological, sensory or physical impairments that are, or are likely to be, permanent; or(ii) has one or more identified impairments to which a psychosocial disability is attributable and that are, or are likely to be, permanent; (iii)is a child who has developmentaldelay; and(b)the CEO is satisfied that provision of early intervention supports for the person is likely to benefit the person by reducing the person's future needs for supports in relation to disability; and(c)the CEO is satisfied that provision of early intervention supports for the person is likely to benefit the person by:(i)mitigating or alleviating the impact of the person's impairment upon the functional capacity of the person to undertake communication, social interaction, learning, mobility, self-care or self-management; or;(ii)preventing the deterioration of such functional capacity; or(iii)improving such functional capacity; or(iv)strengthening the sustainability of informal supports available to the person, including through building the capacity of the person's carer.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In November 2021, Ms Forbes was fortunate to receive a second kidney transplant. Therefore, at the time of the Tribunal hearing Ms Forbes was at a stage of 12 months, post- operatively, from her second kidney transplant.Evidence about Ms Forbes. Ms Forbes lives alone in a privately rented apartment in Toorak, Victoria and has done so for the past 7 years. Her apartment is accessible via three flights of stairs from the street level.[18][18] A2. Ms Forbes works full-time as a personal assistant for a corporate entity.[19] She described her job as mainly a ‘desk job’ and computer-based. She completes her work mostly in a seated position,[20] however at times she is required to undertake errands out of the office. Working in a full-time capacity is a financial necessity for Ms Forbes[21] and she has a ‘...will to identify as a contributing and independent person, despite her disability and her responsibility to her financial obligations’.[22] She enjoys her work and her ability to maintain her financial independence, which includes her rental expenses. Ms Forbes described herself as ‘…an independent individual who is solely financially responsible for all of my living expenses’.[23][19] A3.[20] A6.[21] Transcript page 20 lines 31-32.[22] A6.[23] A3. Ms Forbes described ESKD as an ‘unseen physical permanent impairment’.[24] She has been on medication, including ‘immunosuppressants’ since she was 14 years of age. She referred to her daily medication as a ‘life-long commitment’.[25] Immunosuppressants are an ‘anti-rejection medication’ which must be taken by Ms Forbes to reduce the ability of her body to reject her transplanted kidney.[24] Transcript page 13 lines 17-18.[25] A3. Ms Forbes prioritises ‘staying well’ so that she can continue working for as long as possible, thereby maintaining her lifestyle and independence.[26] She has a driver’s license and is able to drive herself to work when feeling well enough. When she is feeling too unwell to drive, she will use taxis. [26] A3. Ms Forbes contends that PD and a kidney transplant each have ‘different’ and significant ‘challenges’.[27] Having received both types of KRT, Ms Forbes gave evidence in relation to these challenges and also the impact upon her functional capacity in the context of both PD and a kidney transplant. Kidney transplant[27] Transcript page 20 line 19. A kidney transplant involves the transplant of a donated kidney into Ms Forbes’ body. As the transplanted kidney is effectively a ‘foreign body’ Ms Forbes must take immunosuppressant medication to suppress her own immune system from ‘attacking’ the transplanted kidney. Simply put, the effect of the immunosuppressant medication is to make Ms Forbes’ body more compatible with her transplanted kidney. Unfortunately, taking immunosuppressants has ‘enormous’ side-effects on Ms Forbes including lethargy, nausea and being more prone to infection.[28][28] Transcript page 14 lines 13-22.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Forbes’ position is that the effort and energy required to manage the treatment of her ESKD (whether by kidney transplant or CAPD), together with the effort of working full-time leaves her little energy for other activities. One such activity is her ability for social interaction. She thus contends she has a substantially reduced functional capacity for social interaction.Considerations The question of what is meant by ‘effectively and completely’ as appearing in Rule 5.8(a) of the Access Rules was addressed in Foster. Justice Derrington provided the following observation:[83] In the overall legislative scheme, the adverb “completely” appears to be redundant, and in any event, unachievable. If “completely” is to be given its ordinary meaning, what is being asked of the rule is an assessment of whether a person’s impairment results in substantially reduced functional capacity to participate “wholly” or “perfectly” in the activities of communication, social interaction, learning, mobility, self-care and self-management – an impossible bar for almost everyone....[88] Within this statutory context, and having regard to the purpose of s 24 as described in the revised Explanatory Memorandum, a person will not necessarily be deemed to have substantially reduced functional capacity simply because one task is unable to be completed without assistive technology. The task remains to assess the degree to which the person can participate in the activity. The Tribunal is therefore required to make an assessment ‘as a whole’ of the degree to which Ms Forbes can participate in the activity of social interaction.[128][128] [2023] FCAFC 11 at [85]. The Access Guidelines, whilst not prescriptive, provide guidance in relation to the question of whether the criterion under subsection 24(1)(c)(ii) of the NDIS Act has been met by Ms Forbes in relation to the activity social interaction. The Access Guidelines provide as follows: Does your impairment substantially reduce your functional capacity?Your permanent impairment needs to substantially reduce your functional capacity or ability to undertake activities in one of the following areas:…………………………………………………………………….Socialising – how you make and keep friends, or interact with the community, or how a young child plays with other children. We also look at your behaviour, and how you cope with feelings and emotions in social situations.……………………………….We consider how you’re involved in different areas of life like home, school, work and the community, and how you carry out tasks and actions. We also consider any other factors that may impact your day-to-day life.Your needs might go up and down each day or each month. Progressive Multiple Sclerosis (MS) can be a good example of this. We consider your ability over time, taking into account your ups and downs. Having considered the evidence of Ms Forbes and SF and the medical and clinical evidence, I am satisfied that Ms Forbes has a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake social interaction. My considerations are as follows:·Ms Forbes’ ESKD causes her to experience uremic symptoms which are debilitating and result in extreme fatigue, lethargy and nausea and anorexia. ·Dr Cai’s evidence is that whilst uremic symptoms can be expected to subside with a kidney transplant, they can continue. This is particularly so when a transplanted kidney starts to fail. Ms Forbes’ kidney transplant could fail at any time and is not expected to last her lifespan. I also note that Dr Cai has not been involved in Ms Forbes’ care or treatment since her second kidney transplant and is not in a position to comment on any symptoms experienced by Ms Forbes since her second transplant. ·Ms Forbes concedes that her level of fatigue has reduced somewhat with her second kidney transplant. I accept however, that her symptoms persist, and that she continues with a significant level of fatigue and reduction in her energy levels despite a second kidney transplant. In this regard I am satisfied that Ms Forbes’ evidence was honest, truthful and without exaggeration.·I am therefore satisfied that Ms Forbes continues with uremic symptoms despite having had a second kidney transplant. I am also satisfied that Ms Forbes’ uremic symptoms of fatigue, lethargy, nausea and dizziness result in her having extremely limited energy, which she must carefully allocate each day. ·Ms Forbes is an intelligent woman. She makes every effort, on a daily basis to manage carefully her ESKD within the confines of significant fatigue, lethargy and limited energy. This involves the utilisation of compensatory strategies. It also involves, by necessity, the making of choices in respect of what activities that she can and cannot do.·Understandably Ms Forbes prioritises the management of her ESKD. If she does not, she will die. Management of Ms Forbes’ ESKD through both forms of KRT is time consuming and both physically and emotionally demanding. ·Whilst a kidney transplant is less time-consuming than CAPD, there are other demands in relation to this form of KRT. These include regular medical reviews and monitoring of blood, urine and blood pressure, scans and biopsies to check the function of the transplanted kidney.[129] [129] Transcript page 39 line 43-47. ·Ms Forbes chooses also, as a priority, working on a full-time basis. Working is a financial necessity for Ms Forbes, and also extremely important to her independence, dignity and self-worth. This is an admirable attitude and having regard to the principles of subsection 4(2) of the NDIS Act ought to be respected and encouraged.·Managing her ESKD and associated treatment, combined with full-time work leaves Ms Forbes with a small and finite amount of residual energy.·Ms Forbes chooses to use her remaining energy towards her self-care, in particular her diet and nutrition. This is an obvious choice. Ms Forbes diet and nutrition are fundamental to her well-being and will hopefully extend her life. Her failure to prioritise her diet and nutrition will lead to serious consequences.·The same consequences to her physical health do not arise with the compromise and forfeiture of social interaction. ·I am satisfied that Ms Forbes compromises her level of social interaction to accommodate and anticipate her severe fatigue so that she is able to have sufficient energy to manage her treatment needs and regime and also maintain her employment and financial independence.[130] [130] Applicant’s Closing Submissions at [20]. ·Having been satisfied that social interaction as an activity receives an extremely low priority for Ms Forbes, the issue still remains as to whether Ms Forbes’ functional capacity to undertake social interaction is in fact ‘substantially reduced’.·Ms Forbes maintains that her social interaction is substantially reduced and she refers to the following:oHer limited walking endurance. When accessing the community for exercise Ms Forbes must rest after 30 minutes. This impacts on the activities she can undertake and she must ensure she is always in a position to rest within 30 minutes.oOn weekdays, after completing a day at work and her self-cares including a meal, Ms Forbes has no energy for any social interaction whatsoever.oFollowing her second kidney transplant, and only on the weekends, Ms Forbes is able to visit a friend for a coffee or lunch. This activity however is limited to two to three hours.[131]oDue to the unpredictable and variable nature of her symptoms, Ms Forbes has a reluctance to make social plans for fear of having to cancel plans because she is unwell.[132]oMs Forbes states ‘…the difficulty that I face informing new relationships has mostly to do with my amount of available energy’.[133]oMs Forbes has had to make extreme changes in respect of time spent with friends in order to manage her treatment and be in a position to continue working and thereby maintain her financial independence.[134]oMs Forbes must carefully consider her access to the community. She is vulnerable to communicable diseases and quite properly does not wish to risk infection. She does not access places such as a gym, a shopping mall or events with crowds.[135]oWhilst Ms Forbes’ mother stays with her on the weekends to assist with tasks including laundry cleaning and meals, Ms Forbes states ‘but we’re not going out shopping and seeing a picture or going to a theatre’.[136]oMs Forbes concedes her mother’s visits provide a type of social interaction, but for the purposes of her application and her submission in relation to subsection 24(1)(c)(ii) she states ‘on the basis of my application, my reference to social interaction, I guess, had more with the community and my friends, which I don’t – I find very difficult’.[137]oAside from her mother Ms Forbes has two other people in her ‘friendship circle’. M who speaks to generally once a week and S who she speaks to generally twice a year.[138] These friends are aware of her illness. Ms Forbes finds spending time with friends as incredibly difficulty because a lot of the time she does not have the energy to do so.[139][131] Report of Dr Green 7 November 2023.[132] Transcript page 84 lines 4-47[133] Transcript page 52 line 16-17.[134] Transcript page 20 lines 40-45. [135] A6.[136] Transcript page 19 line 23-26.[137] Transcript page 19 lines 39-41.[138] Transcript page 51 lines 10-22. [139] Transcript page 19 lines 45-47.