Footscray Quarries Pty Ltd v Nicholls

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
14 CLR 321

FOOTSCRAY QUARRIES PROPRIETARY

APPELLANTS; LIMITED

DEFENDANTS, NICHOLLS

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Negligence-Employer and employé-Evidence - -Employers and Employés Act 1890

(Vict.), (No. 1087), sec. 38.

14 CLR 322

Sec. 38 of the Employers and Employés Act 1890 provides that where per- sonal injury is caused to a workman (inter alia) (2) by reason of the negli- gence of any person in the service of the employer who has any superintendence entrusted to him whilst in the exercise of such superintendence or (3) by reason QUARRIES

of the negligence of any person in the service of the employer to whose orders or directions the workman at the time of the injury was bound to conform and did conform, where such injury resulted from his having so conformed; or (4) by reason of the act or omission of any person in the service of the employer done or made

in obedience to particular instructions given by any person delegated with the authority of the employer in that behalf -the workman or his representative "shall have the same right of compensa- tion and remedies against the employer as if the workman had not been a workman of nor in the service of the employer nor engaged in his work."

In an action under that section by the representative of a man who was killed by the explosion of a charge during blasting operations at a quarry,

Held, on the evidence, by Griffith C.J. and Barton J. (Isaacs J. dissenting), that the plaintiff was properly nonsuited.

Decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria reversed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Victoria.

Amy Auburn Nicholls, the widow and administratrix of Charles Ernest Nicholls, deceased, brought an action in the County Court against the Footscray Quarries Proprietary Limited claiming damages in respect of the death of her husband which she alleged was caused (inter alia) :(b) by reason of the negligence of a person in the defendants' service who had superintendence entrusted to him whilst in the exercise of such superintendence (c) by reason of the negligence of a person in the defendants' service to whose orders or directions C. E. Nicholls at the time he sustained injury and was killed was bound to conform and did conform and such injury and death resulted from his having

SO conformed; (d) by reason of the Act or omission of a person in the defendants' service done or made in obedience to the defendants' rules or by-laws or in obedience to particular instruc- tions given by a person delegated with the defendants' authority in that behalf.

At the conclusion of the plaintiff's case the Judge of the County Court nonsuited the plaintiff, and he subsequently refused an application by the plaintiff for a new trial. On appeal, the Full Court of the Supreme Court by a majority (Hood and

14 CLR 323

Cussen JJ., Madden C.J. dissenting) allowed the appeal and H. C. OF ordered a new trial.

From that decision the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Footscray Quarries Pty Ltd v Nicholls and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1912] HCA 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Supreme Court of Victoria concerning a claim for damages arising from the death of Charles Ernest Nicholls, who was killed in a blasting accident at the Footscray Quarries. The action was brought by Amy Auburn Nicholls, the widow and administratrix of the deceased, against Footscray Quarries Proprietary Limited, relying on provisions of the Employers and Employés Act 1890. The County Court had initially nonsuited the plaintiff, but the Supreme Court of Victoria, by a majority, ordered a new trial.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the plaintiff had established a case under section 38 of the Employers and Employés Act 1890, which modifies the common law defence of common employment in specific circumstances. Specifically, the court had to determine if the death was caused by the negligence of a person entrusted with superintendence, or by the negligence of a person to whose orders the deceased was bound to conform and did conform, or by an act or omission done in obedience to particular instructions.

Griffith C.J. and Barton J. held that the plaintiff had been properly nonsuited. They reasoned that the evidence did not establish negligence on the part of the foreman, Whitton, in failing to cover the unfired blast hole, nor was any such negligence the cause of the accident. They also found that the powder monkey, McDonough, was not a person with superintendence entrusted to him. Furthermore, they concluded that McDonough's actions, including a wave of his hand which was intended as a warning to the deceased's colleague, McKay, could not reasonably be interpreted as an instruction to ignite the main charge. Consequently, they found no negligence under the relevant subsections of the Act. Isaacs J., dissenting, believed that the case should have gone to a jury, arguing that McDonough's conduct, particularly his signal and subsequent order for men to return to work, could have been reasonably interpreted as negligent given the circumstances and the hazardous nature of the work.

The High Court, by a majority of two to one, allowed the appeal, setting aside the Supreme Court's order for a new trial and dismissing the plaintiff's appeal from the County Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.