Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd. v Perfect Day, Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd. v Perfect Day, Inc. [2022] APO 59

Patent Application:                2015305271

Title:Compositions comprising a casein and methods of producing the same

Patent Applicant:                   Perfect Day, Inc.

Opponent:  Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd.

Delegate:  Leslie F. McCaffery

Decision Date:  23 August 2022

Hearing Date:  19 May 2022 by video conference

Catchwords:  PATENTS – opposition to the grant of a patent under section 59 – consideration of information filed pursuant to Regulation 5.23 – inventive step – clear enough and complete enough disclosure ­ – support – utility  – opposition successful  – claims lack support – specification is not clear enough and complete enough to be performed by the person skilled in the art – applicant given 2 months from date of decision to propose amendments – costs awarded.

Representation:  Patent attorney for the applicant:  Linda Govenlock of Allens Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys

Counsel for the opponent:  Claire Cunliffe

Patent attorney for the opponent:  Tim Jackson of AJ Park

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2015305271

Title:Compositions comprising a casein and methods of producing the same

Patent Applicant:                   Perfect Day, Inc.

Date of Decision:                   23 August 2022

DECISION

The opposition is successful.

The claims lack support under section 40(3).

The complete specification does not disclose the invention in a manner which is clear enough and complete enough for the invention to be performed by a person skilled in the relevant art (section 40(2)(a)).

Applicant given two (2) months from the date of this decision to file amendments to attempt to overcome the deficiencies. 

Costs according to Schedule 8 are awarded against the applicant, Perfect Day, Inc.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. Patent application 2015305271 (the application) in the name of Perfect Day, Inc. (the applicant) was filed on 21 August 2015 under the provisions of the Patent Cooperation Treaty.  The application claims an earliest priority date of 21 August 2014. 

  2. Following examination, the application was advertised as accepted on 26 September 2019.  A notice of opposition was file by Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd (the opponent) on 23 December 2019.  The statement of grounds and particulars (SGP) was filed on 23 March 2020, and set out the grounds of lack of novelty, inventive step, utility, clear enough and complete enough disclosure (“sufficiency”), and support.  A first request to amend the SGP was filed on 24 December 2020 to include the ground of lack of best method.  The amendment was allowed on 20 January 2021. 

  3. A second request to amend the SGP was filed on 5 May 2022 to remove the grounds of novelty and best method, as well as to amend some particulars.  Because of the relatively short time available before the hearing, the usual practice of seeking comments from the applicant could not be followed, and the matter was held over for consideration at the hearing. 

  4. Evidence in support (EIS) was completed on 23 June 2020.  Evidence in answer was completed on 23 October 2020, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd. v Perfect Day, Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] APO 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd. opposed the grant of a patent to Perfect Day, Inc. The opposition was heard by Leslie F. McCaffery, a delegate of the Commissioner of Patents. The decision was issued on 23 August 2022. The decision was that the opposition was successful. The claims were found to lack support and the specification did not disclose the invention in a manner which was clear enough and complete enough for the invention to be performed by a person skilled in the relevant art. The applicant was given two months from the date of the decision to file amendments to attempt to overcome the deficiencies. Costs were awarded to the opponent.

The opposition was based on the grounds of lack of novelty, inventive step, utility, sufficiency and support. The opponent argued that the claims were obvious, that the specification did not disclose the invention in a manner which was clear enough and complete enough for the invention to be performed by a person skilled in the relevant art, and that the claims were not supported by the specification.

The applicant argued that the claims were novel and inventive, that the specification was sufficient and that the claims were supported by the specification.

The delegate found that the claims were obvious, that the specification was not sufficient and that the claims were not supported by the specification. The delegate found that the claims were obvious in view of the common general knowledge alone, and in view of two prior art documents combined with the common general knowledge. The delegate found that the specification did not disclose the invention in a manner which was clear enough and complete enough for the invention to be performed by a person skilled in the relevant art because the specification did not provide guidance, or even a suggestion, that α-lactalbumin and/or β-lactoglobulin could be used as a replacement for casein and would provide the structure, texture, mouthfeel and aggregation properties traditionally attributed to casein. The delegate found that the claims were not supported by the specification because the specification did not describe a principle of general application that any combination of milk proteins can provide suitable dairy substitute food products, but rather a specific combination of milk proteins, including casein, as well as other dairy milk components, is required.

The applicant was given two months from the date of the decision to file amendments to attempt to overcome the deficiencies. Costs were awarded to the opponent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.