FONT & BANTON

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FONT & BANTON [2010] FamCA 9

FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – Final parenting orders – Where the Father suffers from a psychiatric illness – Where the experts recommend supervised time – Where the child wishes for time to be supervised – Supervised time ordered – Provision for the child to initiate time if he wishes

FAMILY LAW – COSTS – Child representative – Submissions to be made in relation to ICL’s costs

APPLICANT: Ms Font
RESPONDENT: Mr Banton
FILE NUMBER: PAF 4439 of 1997
DATE DELIVERED: 11 January 2010
PLACE DELIVERED: Brisbane
PLACE HEARD: Sydney
JUDGMENT OF: Barry J
HEARING DATE: 15 and 16 July 2009

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Mr Henness of Counsel appeared for the Applicant Mother
SOLICITORS FOR THE APPLICANT: Bowring Macaulay & Barrett
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT:

Mr Friend, Solicitor of Friend & Co Lawyers appeared for the Respondent Father

COUNSEL FOR THE INDEPENDENT

CHILDREN’S LAWYER

Mr Maurice of Counsel appeared for the Independent Children’s Lawyer

SOLICITORS FOR THE INDEPENDENT

CHILDREN’S LAWYER

Abrams Turner Whelan Family Lawyers

Orders

  1. The child, T born … June 1995 to live with the Mother.

  2. The Mother to have sole parental responsibility for the child.

  3. The child is to spend time with the Father:

    (a)       at all times and subject to such conditions as may be agreed between the         Mother and Father;

    (b)       at any time the child indicates he wishes to see the Father whether       supervised or unsupervised, at the child’s election.

  4. In the event the child is not otherwise seeing the Father pursuant to the terms of paragraph (3) hereof, the child is to spend time with the Father for a period of two (2) hours every seven (7) weeks, such time to be supervised at the N Contact Centre.

  5. Should the child at any time express a wish to speak to the Father by telephone, the Mother shall encourage and facilitate such communication between the child and the Father.

  6. Should the child at any time wish to email, text or send a letter to the Father, the Mother shall ensure that the child is able to engage in such communication.

  7. The Father is at liberty to write to the child and send gifts to him at all reasonable times.

  8. The Mother and Father are at liberty to agree in writing for another venue at which the child may spend supervised time with the Father.

  9. That to the extent necessary the Mother authorise the child’s treating health professionals to speak to the Father about the child’s treatment and progress.

  10. The Mother’s amended application in form 1 filed 12 April 2007 and the Father’s amended response filed 25 May 2007 be otherwise dismissed.

  11. Within fourteen (14) days of the date hereof the Independent Children’s Lawyer is to file and serve written submissions as to why the parties should pay costs of the Independent Children’s Lawyer. Within fourteen (14) days thereafter the parties are to file and serve a response to such submissions.

  12. Pursuant to s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FONT & BANTON and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FamCA 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Font & Banton*, Ms Font, the applicant mother, and the respondent father sought final parenting orders concerning their child, T. The primary dispute revolved around the father's psychiatric illness and its implications for his time with T, with expert evidence recommending supervised contact and T himself expressing a wish for supervised time. The matter came before Barry J in the Family Court of Australia.

The court was required to determine the nature and extent of the time the child, T, should spend with his father, given the father's diagnosed psychiatric illness, the expert recommendations for supervised contact, and the child's stated wishes. The court also needed to consider the terms of communication and contact between the father and child, and address the costs of the Independent Children's Lawyer.

Barry J considered the unchallenged reports of two forensic psychiatrists, which indicated the father suffered from a significant psychiatric disorder, likely intermittent psychotic episodes on a background of schizoaffective and/or personality disorder. These reports noted the father's unusual beliefs, lack of insight, and diminished judgment, leading to a recommendation for continued supervised access. The court accepted this expert opinion, noting the father's co-operative presentation and affection for his son. Crucially, the court also took into account the child's expressed wish for supervised time.

The court ordered that T live with the mother and that the mother have sole parental responsibility. T was to spend time with the father subject to conditions agreed between the parents, or at T's election if he wished to see his father, supervised or unsupervised. In the absence of T initiating contact, T was to spend two hours every seven weeks with the father, supervised at a contact centre. The orders also facilitated communication between T and his father via telephone, email, text, and letters, and allowed the father to send gifts. The court also directed the Independent Children's Lawyer to make submissions regarding costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The child, T born … June 1995 to live with the Mother.

2.

The Mother to have sole parental responsibility for the child.

3.

The child is to spend time with the Father:

(a) at all times and subject to such conditions as may be agreed between the Mother and Father;

(b) at any time the child indicates he wishes to see the Father whether supervised or unsupervised, at the child’s election.

4.

In the event the child is not otherwise seeing the Father pursuant to the terms of paragraph (3) hereof, the child is to spend time with the Father for a period of two (2) hours every seven (7) weeks, such time to be supervised at the N Contact Centre.

5.

Should the child at any time express a wish to speak to the Father by telephone, the Mother shall encourage and facilitate such communication between the child and the Father.

6.

Should the child at any time wish to email, text or send a letter to the Father, the Mother shall ensure that the child is able to engage in such communication.

7.

The Father is at liberty to write to the child and send gifts to him at all reasonable times.

8.

The Mother and Father are at liberty to agree in writing for another venue at which the child may spend supervised time with the Father.

9.

That to the extent necessary the Mother authorise the child’s treating health professionals to speak to the Father about the child’s treatment and progress.

10.

The Mother’s amended application in form 1 filed 12 April 2007 and the Father’s amended response filed 25 May 2007 be otherwise dismissed.

11.

Within fourteen (14) days of the date hereof the Independent Children’s Lawyer is to file and serve written submissions as to why the parties should pay costs of the Independent Children’s Lawyer. Within fourteen (14) days thereafter the parties are to file and serve a response to such submissions.

12.

Pursuant to s 62B and s 65DA(2), the particulars of the obligations these Orders create and the particulars of the consequences that may follow if a person contravenes these Orders, and details of who can assist parties to adjust to and comply with an order, are set out in the document entitled “Parenting orders – obligations, consequences and who can help”, a copy of which is annexed to these Orders.

NOTATION:

The Family Consultant Ms F is requested to meet with the child and explain to him the orders made and the reasons for same with particular emphasis on the fact that at his age the child is at liberty to communicate with his father and see him in such circumstances and subject to such conditions as he may wish.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In a report dated 23 August 2007 Dr K a forensic psychiatrist noted under the heading “Opinion” (page 8 of the report):“[The father] from the information provided to me and from the history and mental state examination obtained at interview clearly has a history of significant psychiatric disorder. Nevertheless his presentation is complex.It is important, firstly, to note that he has a clear history of psychosis, judging from the documents reviewed by Dr [A] with respect to his admissions to […] and […] Hospitals in 1996. The nature of prior psychiatric admissions to other hospitals is uncertain as I have not reviewed any relevant documentation and [the father] was unable to clarify the nature of his admissions.On presentation, it was apparent that [the father] held odd, unusual and bizarre beliefs, as noted in the body of my report. These were either delusion-like (over-valued ideas) or frankly delusional. He displayed features of a form of thought disorder. This was no clear disturbance of mood or affect.There was no evidence of overt cognitive impairment and he appeared to be of average intelligence. There was no clear evidence of the negative (residual) features of a chronic schizophrenic illness such as personality deterioration, affect of blunting/flatness or cognitive impairment. Most likely diagnosis are that [the father] suffers from intermittent psychotic episodes, which could be diagnosed as brief psychotic episodes or schizophreniform episodes. These are probably on the background of a schizoaffective disorder and/or a personality disorder, probably schizotypal in nature. I might emphasise that [the father] was very co-operative throughout the interview and in no way irritable or aggressive. He was at times pleasant and clearly concerned about his current lack of access to his son, about whom he expressed affection.Given the longstanding nature of his psychiatric problems, the current lack of monitoring and treatment by mental professionals and his lack of insight, his prognosis is uncertain. It is, however, obviously a chronic stress for him not being able to spend time with his son. On the basis of one interview it is difficult to comprehensively assess [the father’s] capacity to spend time with and care for his son on an unsupervised basis but given his unusual beliefs, lack of insight and diminished judgment and without in anyway wanting to pre-empt the decision of the Court, continuing supervised access would be wise.” (Underlining not in original text). The psychiatrists were not required for cross examination on the contents of their reports and accordingly their reports are before me on an unchallenged basis. Nothing in the evidence would persuade me to question the professional opinions of the two psychiatrists. On the 5 November 2007 orders issued by consent providing for the child to live with the Mother and for the Father to spend time and communicate with the child for a period of two hours supervised every eight weeks at the C Contact Service. There were various other orders providing for the Father to be at liberty to write and send gifts to the child at his home address and for the child to be able to have telephone communication with his father.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.