Fodare Pty Ltd v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fodare Pty Limited v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2000] FCA 1721

APPEAL – application to adduce further evidence after delivery of Full Court judgment – whether case now sought to be raised arose in consequence of the judgment on appeal – whether Order 52 r 36 complied with – whether case now sought to be raised should have been raised at first instance – whether there was adequate explanation for failure to raise the matter at first instance – whether, had the evidence been adduced at the trial, a different result would have ensued – public interest in the finality of litigation

BANKRUPTCY – void settlement under s 120(1) Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) – entitlement to interest – entitlement in trustee to a charge upon property to secure the payment of the judgment debt

COSTS – where applicant only partially successful on appeal – whether individual respondents were necessary parties

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 120(1), 139ZQ, 139 ZR
Federal Court Rules (Cth) O 35 r 8, O 52 r 36,

Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Alvaro (1996) 66 FCR 372

FODARE PTY LIMITED AND DORIS EMILY ELIZABETH MILLER AND KATHLEEN ANNE HIRTZELL AND KEVIN TUBB v OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY AND OFFICIAL RECEIVER

N 400 OF 2000

LEHANE, HELY & CONTI JJ
29 NOVEMBER 2000
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 400 OF 2000

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

FODARE PTY LIMITED
(ACN 003 722 147)
FIRST APPELLANT

DORIS EMILY ELIZABETH MILLER
SECOND APPELLANT

KATHLEEN ANNE HIRTZELL
THIRD APPELLANT

KEVIN TUBB
FOURTH APPELLANT

AND:

OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY
FIRST RESPONDENT

OFFICIAL RECEIVER
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

LEHANE, HELY & CONTI

DATE OF ORDER:

29 NOVEMBER 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be upheld and the declarations made by the primary judge be set aside.

2.The payment of $87,500 on 13 April 1989 from Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller to Fodare Pty Limited be declared void as against the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy.

3.There be entry of judgment for the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy against Fodare Pty Limited in the sum of $87,500, plus interest in the sum of $32,557.18.

4.The property situated at 23 Racecourse Avenue, Menangle Park, being folio identifier 23/10718, be charged with the payment to the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy of the amount of the judgment, namely $120,057.18.

5.The order for costs made at first instance be discharged insofar as it required Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller, Kathleen Anne Hirtzell or Kevin Tubb to pay the costs of the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy.  The orders for costs are otherwise affirmed.

6.There be no order as to the costs of the appeal.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 400 OF 2000

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

FODARE PTY…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fodare Pty Ltd v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1721
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Fodare Pty Ltd v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy, the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether Fodare Pty Ltd, a company, was required to repay a sum of money to the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy. The dispute involved an alleged void disposition of property by Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller, who had granted a mortgage to Fodare Pty Ltd to acquire the Menangle Park property. The court had to decide whether the funds raised by Fodare Pty Ltd post-April 13, 1989, on the security of the Menangle Park property, were sufficient to repay the sum claimed by the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy.

The legal issues before the court included whether Fodare Pty Ltd had repaid the void disposition to Mrs Miller after the date of her bankruptcy, and if the new evidence presented by Fodare Pty Ltd could be admitted under the rules of court. The court found that Fodare Pty Ltd's application to adduce further evidence did not comply with the procedural requirements set out in Order 52 rule 36 of the Federal Court Rules. The court noted that the grounds for the application were not stated in an affidavit, and no evidence was provided to explain why the new evidence was not presented at the trial. Furthermore, the court highlighted a superficial inconsistency between the new case presented by Fodare Pty Ltd and Mrs Miller's initial position that none of the money used to acquire the Menangle Park property was hers.

The court upheld the appeal and set aside the declarations made by the primary judge. It declared the payment of $87,500 on April 13, 1989, from Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller to Fodare Pty Limited as void against the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy. The court ordered Fodare Pty Limited to pay the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy $87,500, plus interest of $32,557.18, and charged the property at 23 Racecourse Avenue, Menangle Park, with the payment of the judgment amount of $120,057.18. The court also discharged the orders for costs made at first instance that required Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller, Kathleen Anne Hirtzell or Kevin Tubb to pay the costs of the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy, while affirming the other orders for costs. There was no order as to the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be upheld and the declarations made by the primary judge be set aside.

2. The payment of $87,500 on 13 April 1989 from Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller to Fodare Pty Limited be declared void as against the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy.

3. There be entry of judgment for the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy against Fodare Pty Limited in the sum of $87,500, plus interest in the sum of $32,557.18.

4. The property situated at 23 Racecourse Avenue, Menangle Park, being folio identifier 23/10718, be charged with the payment to the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy of the amount of the judgment, namely $120,057.18.

5. The order for costs made at first instance be discharged insofar as it required Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller, Kathleen Anne Hirtzell or Kevin Tubb to pay the costs of the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy. The orders for costs are otherwise affirmed.

6. There be no order as to the costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Fodare Pty Ltd, a company, raised funds from Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller to acquire Menangle Park property. Miller subsequently declared bankruptcy, and the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy claimed that $87,500 paid by Miller to Fodare on 13 April 1989 was a void disposition. Fodare argued that it had repaid Miller the same amount after her bankruptcy, using the security of the Menangle Park property. This contention was raised for the first time during the appeal, with Fodare seeking to adduce an affidavit of Miller in support of this claim. The affidavit was in response to another affidavit by Sally Susan Nash, which Fodare did not read but still sought to rely upon.

The case initially involved a claim by the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy against Fodare Pty Ltd, seeking a declaration that a payment made by Miller to Fodare was a void disposition under section 120(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). The primary judge's declarations were appealed by Fodare. During the appeal, Fodare sought to adduce further evidence in the form of an affidavit from Miller, which was not part of the initial proceedings or the appeal submissions. The Court of Appeal considered the application to adduce further evidence and whether it complied with the relevant procedural rules.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Certain matters were reserved for further consideration in the decision which we gave on 5 October 2000. We did not then envisage that the resolution of those matters would involve the taking of further evidence. However, when the matter came on for further consideration, counsel for Fodare sought to adduce further evidence in the form of an affidavit of Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller sworn 21 November 2000. That affidavit purports to be “in response” to an affidavit of Sally Susan Nash sworn 13 November 2000, which was not read by counsel for the Trustee. Nonetheless, counsel for Fodare sought to rely upon the affidavit.The application to adduce further evidence Counsel for Fodare, Mr Cameron, stated that the further evidence was intended to establish that, after 13 April 1989, Fodare raised on the security of the Menangle Park property, and gave to Mrs Miller, sums of money equal to or exceeding the $87,500 which we held to be a void disposition of Mrs Miller’s property. In substance the case which Fodare now seeks to make is that, prior to Mrs Miller’s bankruptcy, it repaid to Mrs Miller (from money raised under a mortgage of the Menangle Park property) the sum now claimed by the Official Trustee. Mr Cameron accepted that the case now sought to be raised by Fodare was not raised at first instance, nor was it sought to be raised on the hearing of the appeal. In his submission, the occasion for raising the case first arose when the Official Trustee prepared short minutes of order indicating that the relief which it sought as a result of the judgment given on 5 October 2000, was judgment against Fodare in the sum of $87,500 and interest and a charge on the Menangle Park property to secure payment of the amount of the judgment. Mr Cameron accepted that, if leave to adduce further evidence were granted, the matter would need to be remitted to the primary judge for further consideration, as disputed questions of fact requiring cross-examination are involved. We do not accept that the occasion for raising the case now sought to be made arose only in consequence of the judgment which we gave on 5 October 2000. The amended cross claim, filed in the proceedings on 3 September 1998, included a claim for a declaration that the provision of $195,000 to Fodare by Mrs Miller to acquire the Menangle Park property was a void disposition pursuant to s 120(1) of the Bankruptcy Act1966 (Cth) (“the Act”), as well as an order for payment of that sum together with interest at the rate of 10.5% pa. If the claim now sought to be made has any substance, it would have been at least a partial answer to that element of the Trustee’s claim, if not to all elements of that claim. The provisions of Order 52 rule 36 have not been complied with, inasmuch as the grounds of the application to have further evidence received have not been stated in an affidavit. No evidence has been put before the Court to explain why the evidence now sought to be adduced was not led at the trial, or why the case now sought to be made was not raised at the trial. There is at least a superficial inconsistency between that case and Mrs Miller's basic position at first instance that none of the money used to acquire the Menangle Park property was money to which she was beneficially entitled.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether leave should be granted to Fodare Pty Ltd to adduce further evidence in the form of an affidavit of Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller.
2. Whether the case now sought to be made by Fodare was raised at first instance or on the hearing of the appeal.
3. Whether the provisions of Order 52 rule 36 have been complied with in the application to adduce further evidence.

Held
1. The court decided that leave should not be granted to Fodare Pty Ltd to adduce further evidence in the form of an affidavit of Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller.
2. The court determined that the case now sought to be made by Fodare was not raised at first instance or on the hearing of the appeal.
3. The court found that the provisions of Order 52 rule 36 have not been complied with in the application to adduce further evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Counsel for Fodare sought to adduce an affidavit of Doris Emily Elizabeth Miller, sworn on 21 November 2000, in an attempt to establish that sums of money were repaid to Mrs Miller after 13 April 1989, equivalent to the amount claimed by the Official Trustee. This case was not raised at first instance or during the hearing of the appeal. The court rejected the notion that the opportunity to raise this case arose only after the judgment on 5 October 2000. The amended cross-claim filed on 3 September 1998 included a claim for a declaration regarding the disposition of $195,000 to Fodare by Mrs Miller, which if valid, would have been a partial answer to the Trustee's claim. The court noted that the grounds for the application to receive further evidence were not stated in an affidavit, and no evidence was presented to justify why this evidence was not led at the trial or why the case was not raised at the trial. Additionally, there was a superficial inconsistency between the case sought to be made and Mrs Miller's basic position at first instance. The court concluded that the provisions of Order 52 rule 36 were not complied with. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the opportunity to raise a new case by adduced evidence must be justified, and procedural rules for the submission of such evidence must be strictly adhered to, especially where there is an inconsistency with prior positions taken by a party.