Flinders Diamonds Ltd v Tiger International Resources Incorporated

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

FLINDERS DIAMONDS LTD v TIGER INTERNATIONAL RESOURCES INCORPORATED & OTHERS

[2006] SASC 139

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Layton

11 May 2006

EQUITY - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - EQUITABLE DOCTRINES AND PRESUMPTIONS - CONTRIBUTION

PROCEDURE - COSTS - AGREEMENTS AS TO COSTS

PROCEDURE - COSTS - GENERAL RULE - COSTS FOLLOW THE EVENT - CO-DEFENDANTS

Application for contribution by first and second defendants (applicants) from third, fourth and fifth defendants (respondents) - costs order made joint and severally against all five defendants in favour of the plaintiff following a trial and confirmed on appeal by the Full Court- respondents entered into a deed of settlement with plaintiff and paid $11,000.00 to plaintiff - applicants did not know terms of the settlement - all five defendants consented to a costs allocatur of $200,000.00 plus interest - applicants paid the full amount of the consent costs - whether payment discharged joint liability of all defendants- whether applicants can claim equitable contribution from respondents – whether respondents were released from contribution by agreement or common intent or by entering into a deed of settlement - whether respondents liable to contribute only with reference to their share percentage in the plaintiff company – whether contribution based on differing fault or benefit - whether respondents to be treated as one entity for purposes of determining contributions - consideration of legal and equitable principles of contribution - Held: application granted - equal contribution between all defendants to the consent costs including interest- respondents to pay three fifths of the consent costs plus interest, to the applicant.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 606; s 671B; s 672B; Supreme Court Act 1935 s 40(1); Supreme Court Rules 1987 R 101, referred to.
Salim v Ingham Enterprises Pty Ltd (1998) 55 NSWLR 7, distinguished.
Albion Insurance Co Ltd v GIO (NSW) (1969) 121 CLR 342; Burke v LFOT Pty Ltd (2002) 209 CLR 282; Mike Gaffikin Marine Pty Ltd v Princes Street Marina Pty Ltd  (Unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Equity Division, Young J, 15 July 1996, Judgment No 2092/1992); Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 193 CLR 72, discussed.
Accident Compensation Commission v Baltica General Insurance Co Ltd [1993] 1 VR 467; Coulls v Bagot's Executor & Trustee Co Ltd (1967) 119 CLR 460; Flinders Diamonds Ltd v Tiger International Resources Inc (2003) 86 SASR 353; Flinders Diamonds Ltd v Tiger International Resources Inc (2004) 88 SASR 281; In Re Cartwright [1975] 1 WLR 573; Mike Gaffikin Marine Pty Ltd v Princes Street Marina Pty Ltd (1995) 122 FLR 294; Morgan Equipment Co v Rodgers [No 2] (1993) 32 NSWLR 467; Muschinski v Dodds (1985) 160 CLR 583; Robinson v Campbell (No 2) (1992) 30 NSWLR 503; Salomon v A Salomon and Co Ltd [1987] AC 22; Stec v Orfanos [1999] FCA 457; Thiess Watkins White Constructions Ltd (In Liq) v Witan Nominees (1985) Pty Ltd

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Flinders Diamonds Ltd v Tiger International Resources Incorp... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SASC 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Flinders Diamonds Ltd v Tiger International Resources Incorporated, the applicants sought contribution from the respondents in relation to costs previously awarded to the plaintiff. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia, with Justice Blue presiding. The primary legal issues before the court were whether the payment by the respondents to the plaintiff discharged the joint liability of all defendants, and if not, whether the applicants could claim equitable contribution from the respondents. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the respondents were released from contribution by agreement or common intent, and whether the contribution was to be based on differing fault or benefit.

The court considered the legal and equitable principles of contribution, including the principles of joint and several liability and equitable doctrines. The court found that the payment by the respondents did not discharge the joint liability of all defendants, and that the applicants could claim equitable contribution from the respondents. The court held that the respondents were not released from contribution by agreement or common intent, and that the contribution was not based on differing fault or benefit. The court determined that the respondents were to be treated as one entity for the purposes of determining contributions. The court concluded that the applicants were entitled to contribution from the respondents, and ordered that the respondents pay three fifths of the consent costs plus interest to the applicants.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 17 June 2005 the respondents filed an application for security for costs. The applicants also filed an application for security for costs on 1 July 2005. In his reasons for decision on those applications Judge Withers described the situation between the parties in this way:…it became reasonably clear…that there was a dispute of fact as to what had been agreed between the Barry interests and the Campbell interests or put on their behalf prior to the recording of the order by Judge Kelly of 10 August 2004. The Campbell entities in particular alleged that before August 2004 they had already resolved any liability they had for costs towards the plaintiff and that in August 2004 they had not knowingly agreed to enter into any arrangement which exposed them to contributing further costs to the plaintiff. The dispute was such that after considering the affidavits it appeared clear that the matter would not be resolved other than by way of an oral hearing. On 13 April 2005…I directed that the first and second defendants file points of claim against the third, fourth and fifth defendants. I directed the third, fourth and fifth defendants to file points of defence.It is as a result of those orders that this matter was listed for hearing before me.Agreed facts The parties were able to agree a number of facts at trial, including the amounts paid by the applicants and the respondents to the plaintiff in satisfaction of the costs claim, the percentages of shareholdings each party held in the plaintiff company, and a number of other matters set out below. It was agreed between the parties that the applicants paid the amount of $203,366.08 to the plaintiff, and that pursuant to the Deed of Settlement (which is referred to in more detail later in these reasons) the respondents paid to the plaintiff the amount of $11,000. It was also agreed between the parties that the parties held the following shares in the plaintiff company:[4]·The first defendant held 17,269,292 shares, representing 29.77 per cent of the total shares of the plaintiff, and 76.35 per cent of those shares held by the defendants.·The second defendant held 4,000,000 shares, 6.9 per cent of the total shares and 17.68 per cent of those held by the defendants. ·The third defendant held 1,000,000 shares, 1.72 per cent of the total shares and 4.42 per cent of those held by the defendants.·The fourth defendant held 250,000 shares, 0.43 per cent of the total shares and 1.11 per cent of those held by the defendants.·The fifth defendant held 100,000 shares, 0.17 per cent of the total shares and 0.44 of those held by the defendants.·The respondents collectively held 2.32 per cent of the total shares of the plaintiff, and 5.97 per cent of those held by the defendants.[4] Exhibit 1, “Agreed Share Percentages”. The further facts agreed between the parties in Exhibit 2 are set out in full below:1. The quantum of the plaintiff’s costs was set down for taxation on 10 August 2004.2.During an adjournment of the taxation, the parties agreed to consent to an order setting the quantum of the plaintiff’s costs at $200,000. 3.The only issue not resolved during the adjournment was the pre-existing dispute among the defendants as to the issue of contributions among them to this sum.4.The first and second defendants undertook to pay the $200,000 to the plaintiff in satisfaction of the costs order of 12 June 2003 as an initial matter and to adjourn the contribution claims that had been foreshadowed by the first and second defendants against the third, fourth and fifth defendants to a separate hearing.5.The court was informed of the parties’ agreement on quantum and the dispute among the defendants as to the contribution claims that had been foreshadowed by the first and second defendants.6.The orders and undertakings of 10 August 2004 did not constitute a waiver by the first and second defendants of any right or claim to contribution against the third, fourth and fifth defendants and did not operate to release the third, fourth and fifth defendants from any existing liability they might have with regard to the costs order of 12 June 2003.7.The consent of the third, fourth and fifth defendants to an order setting the quantum of plaintiff’s costs at $200,000 did not constitute an agreement on the part of the third, fourth and fifth defendants to be liable to the plaintiff for any additional costs.8.The dispute concerning the contribution claims was adjourned until 8 September 2004 at which time the first and second defendants made a formal oral application for contribution from the third, fourth and fifth defendants.9.The form of the consent allocatur submitted by the plaintiff to the Registry on 12 August 2004 should not have been altered by inserting the words “first and second”.Evidence

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The further facts agreed between the parties in Exhibit 2 are set out in full below:1. The quantum of the plaintiff’s costs was set down for taxation on 10 August 2004.2.During an adjournment of the taxation, the parties agreed to consent to an order setting the quantum of the plaintiff’s costs at $200,000. 3.The only issue not resolved during the adjournment was the pre-existing dispute among the defendants as to the issue of contributions among them to this sum.4.The first and second defendants undertook to pay the $200,000 to the plaintiff in satisfaction of the costs order of 12 June 2003 as an initial matter and to adjourn the contribution claims that had been foreshadowed by the first and second defendants against the third, fourth and fifth defendants to a separate hearing.5.The court was informed of the parties’ agreement on quantum and the dispute among the defendants as to the contribution claims that had been foreshadowed by the first and second defendants.6.The orders and undertakings of 10 August 2004 did not constitute a waiver by the first and second defendants of any right or claim to contribution against the third, fourth and fifth defendants and did not operate to release the third, fourth and fifth defendants from any existing liability they might have with regard to the costs order of 12 June 2003.7.The consent of the third, fourth and fifth defendants to an order setting the quantum of plaintiff’s costs at $200,000 did not constitute an agreement on the part of the third, fourth and fifth defendants to be liable to the plaintiff for any additional costs.8.The dispute concerning the contribution claims was adjourned until 8 September 2004 at which time the first and second defendants made a formal oral application for contribution from the third, fourth and fifth defendants.9.The form of the consent allocatur submitted by the plaintiff to the Registry on 12 August 2004 should not have been altered by inserting the words “first and second”.Evidence In addition to the agreed facts referred to above, the parties provided an agreed book of documents, which contained relevant court orders, correspondence between the parties, the plaintiff’s Short Form Bill of Costs, and the Deed of Settlement. There were also several other exhibits tendered in Court, namely the share percentages held by all parties,[5] details of costs payments to the plaintiff detailed in a letter dated 17 January 2006 from Corsers Solicitors,[6] two lists of documents filed by the applicants,[7] a letter dated 3 September 2005 from Talbot Olivier to Mr Campbell,[8] an affidavit of Mr Campbell dated 15 March 2005,[9] and a letter from Mr Ken Robson to Mr Campbell dated 6 January 2006.[10][5] Exhibit 1.[6] Exhibit 4.[7] Exhibit D1-D2 5; Exhibit D1-D2 6.[8] Exhibit D1-D2 7 “Letter of 3 September 2005 from Talbot Olivier”.[9] Exhibit D1-D2 8 .[10] Exhibit D3-5 9. The second defendant Mr Barry and the third defendant Mr Campbell also gave evidence. The evidence of both witnesses primarily focussed on the discussions and the legal advice which they each received about the legal proceedings, including the Full Court decision; defending an application by the plaintiff for special leave to the High Court with potential for a cross-appeal; as well as evidence about discussions and correspondence between them regarding possible settlement with the plaintiff. The applicants’ submissions

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.