FLETCHER v POLICE
[1999] SASC 110
Magistrates Appeal
PRIOR J: Appeal against a sentence imposed in the Magistrates Court at Murray Bridge on 18 January 1999.
The appellant then pleaded guilty to driving under the influence of liquor and driving whilst disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver's licence.[1]
[1] Road Traffic Act, 1961 s47, Motor Vehicles Act, 1959 s91
The evidence before the magistrate was that, on the occasion the subject of the charge, the appellant was then driving with a considerable concentration of alcohol in his blood. A level of .186 grams in 100 millilitres of blood was recorded when the appellant submitted to a breath analysis test at the Murray Bridge Police Station soon after he was detained early in the hours of the morning of 1 August 1998. The police had been summonsed to a particular location within Murray Bridge upon reports of a small vehicle driving erratically in the area. When the appellant was spoken to by police he was obviously affected by liquor. Inquiries made subsequently disclosed that the appellant had been disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver's licence from 6 July 1998 until further order. Thus the court had to deal with someone who had relatively recently been the subject of a disqualification order. The appellant admitted to police that he knew he was disqualified and that he had received a letter telling him so before the incident then before the court had occurred.
The magistrate was informed of the fact that the appellant had a number of relevant previous convictions. One was for speeding. Another conviction within two months of that matter was also in the Murray Bridge Magistrates Court, that was for driving whilst disqualified. For that offence he was required to perform community service. Of course it was a matter of some significance to the magistrate in this case that he was therefore dealing with a person for a second offence of driving whilst disqualified. Two other matters dealt with in 1996 related to failure to show “P” plates and driving a defective vehicle. The magistrate fined the appellant $800 and disqualified him from obtaining a driver's licence for 13 months on the admitted charge of driving under the influence. As for driving whilst disqualified the appellant was sentenced to 28 days imprisonment.
In this appeal it is said that the magistrate erred in two respects. By the notice of appeal it was said his Honour erred by failing to find good reason for suspending the sentence of 28 days’ imprisonment. On hearing of the appeal a further and separate ground was advanced. That was that the magistrate erred in finding the offending contumacious.
In submissions put to the magistrate the appellant's counsel emphasised that the appellant was then but 21 years of age and that as a younger man, although he had been in serious trouble for a number of dishonesty offences, he had since the middle of 1996 led a law abiding life. There was reference to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read FLETCHER v POLICE No. SCGRG-99-133 Judgment No. S110 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] SASC 110
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the court had to decide were whether the magistrate erred by not finding good reason to suspend the 28-day imprisonment sentence and whether the magistrate erred in finding the offending to be contumacious. The appellant's counsel argued that the sentence should be suspended due to Fletcher's age, his previous law-abiding conduct, and the absence of a custodial sentence for his prior dishonesty offences. They also argued that the offending was not contumacious as Fletcher had been persuaded to drive by a friend under the influence of alcohol and without considering his disqualification.
The court examined the magistrate's decision and found no basis for interference. The court agreed with the submissions of the respondent's counsel that the facts of this case were distinct from those in Long v Police. The court found that the magistrate properly concluded that the offending was contumacious, considering Fletcher's awareness of his disqualification and the deliberate nature of his actions. The court held that the offending was not trivial and lacked any feature of emergency or unavoidability. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed, affirming the magistrate's decision.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi