FLEMING v ADVERTISER-NEWS Weekend Publishing Co Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

FLEMING  v  ADVERTISER-NEWS WEEKEND PUBLISHING CO PTY LTD & ANOR (No 2)

[2012] SASC 127

Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court

24 July 2012

PROCEDURE

Application to amend Statement of Claim - pleading of imputation alleging a criminal offence in a defamation claim - offence not precisely identified - held 6R99(1)(b) requires statute on which offence is based to be pleaded - application dismissed.

FLEMING  v  ADVERTISER-NEWS WEEKEND PUBLISHING CO PTY LTD & ANOR (No 2)
[2012] SASC 127

JUDGE LUNN:

Reasons on plaintiff’s application to file a Fourth Statement of Claim

  1. The Plaintiff, who was an Anglican priest, sues the Defendant for damages in defamation.  The provisions of the Defamation Act 2005 apply.

  2. The Third Statement of Claim pleads nine allegedly defamatory publications by the Defendant.[1]  In respect of all nine publications, the plaintiff has pleaded the same basic imputation in relation to each publication as follows:

    In the natural and ordinary meaning the words in the … publication[s] … meant and were understood to mean:

    (1)     That the Plaintiff as an Anglican priest had committed criminal offences of unlawful sexual intercourse with a minor who might be younger than 13; or alternatively

    (2)     There were reasonable grounds to suspect that the Plaintiff as an Anglican priest had committed criminal offences of unlawful sexual intercourse with a minor who might be younger than 13.[2]

    [1]    Paragraph 12A of the Statement of Claim refers to a further publication identified as the fifth web publication, which is not now pleaded.

    [2]    In some instances additional words have been added into the imputation, but they are not relevant to what I have to decide.

  3. The Statement of Claim pleads the words complained of in each of the nine publications.  In broad terms they are that in the 1970s the plaintiff had a sexual involvement with two girls, one of whom was under age.  The one who was under age was named as “Jane”.  The nature of the sexual involvement was not stated.  There was no express reference to oral sex, masturbation or homosexual activity.

  4. The plaintiff has not pleaded any other imputations alleging criminal offences of indecent assault, indecent interference or gross indecency, or of immoral sexual impropriety or conduct unbecoming to a priest.

  5. On 31 May 2011 I published reasons on an application by the plaintiff to strike out part of the pleaded defence of contextual truth.[3]  In those reasons I concluded that the reference to the criminal offence of unlawful sexual intercourse in the Third Statement of Claim was inappropriate, as an offence with that name did not exist at the time of the acts in question.  My reasons were largely upheld by Peek J on an appeal.[4]

    [3]    FDN35.

    [4] 13 April 2012, [2012] SASC 58, FDN41.

  6. By an application of 30 May 2012 the plaintiff seeks permission to file a Fourth Statement of Claim amending his pleadings of the defamatory imputations.  It is only necessary to refer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FLEMING v ADVERTISER-NEWS Weekend Publishing Co Pty Ltd (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 127
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Fleming v Advertiser-News Weekend Publishing Co Pty Ltd (No 2) involved a defamation claim brought by the Plaintiff, an Anglican priest, against the Defendant, a publishing company. The Plaintiff sought damages for allegedly defamatory publications made by the Defendant, which were said to impute that the Plaintiff had committed criminal offences of unlawful sexual intercourse with a minor. The Supreme Court of South Australia was tasked with determining whether the Plaintiff could amend his pleadings to more accurately reflect the alleged criminal offence.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Plaintiff was required to precisely identify the statutory basis for the alleged criminal offence in his pleadings. The court was also required to determine whether the Plaintiff's proposed amendment to the pleadings would cause substantial prejudice to the Defendants and whether it was appropriate to allow the amendment at this stage in the proceedings.

In dismissing the Plaintiff's application to amend his pleadings, the court held that the Plaintiff was required to identify the statutory basis for the alleged criminal offence in his pleadings. The court noted that Rule 99(1)(b) of the Supreme Court Civil Procedure Rules 2006 (SA) mandates that a statement of claim must state the basis of each cause of action, including any statutory provision on which the Plaintiff relies. The court found that the Plaintiff's proposed amendment was ambiguous and did not clearly identify the criminal offence upon which he relied. The court also found that the Defendants would be substantially prejudiced by not knowing in advance of the trial precisely what offence in law the Plaintiff was relying upon.

The court further held that the Plaintiff's proposed amendment was not a matter of particularity, as particulars under the Supreme Court Civil Procedure Rules 2006 (SA) only relate to the pleading of facts. The identification of the precise criminal offence was a question of law, and the Plaintiff was required to identify the offence relied upon for the imputation to the trial Judge. The court found that there was no good reason why the Plaintiff should not identify the offence relied upon in his pleadings.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the Plaintiff's application to amend his pleadings, finding that the Plaintiff was required to precisely identify the statutory basis for the alleged criminal offence in his pleadings. The court also found that the Defendants would be substantially prejudiced by not knowing in advance of the trial precisely what offence in law the Plaintiff was relying upon. The court directed the parties to return on a specified date to discuss costs and further directions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established