Fleming and Fleming (Review of Costs)

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FLEMING & FLEMING (Review of Costs) [2009] FamCA 552
FAMILY LAW – COSTS – Assessment of Costs – Review of Registrars Decision – Unavailability of Registrar’s Reasons – Counsel’s preparation for trial – Care and consideration – General care and conduct
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Family Law Rules 2004

Auspine Ltd  v Australian Newsprint Mills Ltd (1996) FCA 673
Australian Coal and Shale Employees’ Federation v The Commonwealth (1953) 94 CLR 621 at 628-629
Brott v Abeles (2007) FLC 93-310
Locke and Locke (1993) FLC 92-352
Saaethoff v Saaethoff (1987) FLC 91-817
Schweppes Limited v Archer (1934) 34 SR (NSW) 178

APPLICANT: Mr Fleming
RESPONDENT: Ms Fleming
FILE NUMBER: BRF 83 of 2005
DATE DELIVERED: 26 June 2009
PLACE DELIVERED: Brisbane
PLACE HEARD: Brisbane
JUDGMENT OF: Murphy J
HEARING DATE: 29 May 2009

REPRESENTATION

APPLICANT: Appeared on his own behalf
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: James Noble Family Law

Orders

  1. The parties shall each do all such things, sign all such documents and engage in all such correspondence as is necessary to perform the calculation/s required to ascertain the amount used by the Registrar as the taxed-off amount in respect of Item 476 of the Amended Itemised Bill of Costs in arriving at her assessment dated 17 November, 2008.

  2. The assessment of costs made by Registrar Stevens on 17 November, 2008 be varied by:

    (a)reducing the amount payable by the husband to the wife by:

    (i)the amount of  $13,358.04 plus

    (ii)the amount of $1106.25 if, but only if, the amount of $1195 was used by the Registrar in lieu of $2301.25 as the figure to be taxed off in respect of Item 476 of the Amended Itemised Bill of Costs in arriving at  her assessment.

    (b)       deleting the notation thereto; and

    (c)adding in lieu the following notation:  “The effect of this order is that the wife is to refund to the husband the sum of $30,322.10 plus, if the requirements of paragraph 2(a)(ii) of this order are met, the additional sum of $1106.

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment under the pseudonym Fleming and Fleming (Review of Costs) is approved pursuant to s 121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT BRISBANE

FILE NUMBER: BRF 83 of 2005

MR FLEMING

Applicant Husband

And

MS FLEMING

Respondent Wife

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 12 June 2007 O’Reilly J ordered, relevantly, that “the husband pay to the wife her costs of and incidental to the s 79 property proceedings between the parties on the standard basis to be assessed if not agreed”.

  2. Subsequently, an itemised costs account was prepared on behalf of the wife by a costs consultant.  Subsequent to that, an amended itemised costs account was provided by the same costs consultant.  That costs account sought by way of party and party costs the sum of $72,463.94.

  3. O’Reilly J had also ordered that “the wife’s costs as so assessed or agreed be paid from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fleming and Fleming (Review of Costs) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FamCA 552
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a review of costs assessed by Registrar Stevens on 17 November 2008, brought before Murphy J. The dispute centred on the assessment of costs, specifically concerning Item 476 of an amended itemised bill of costs, and the amount that was "taxed off" by the Registrar.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Registrar had erred in her assessment of costs, particularly in relation to the allowance of a reading fee for counsel. This involved determining the appropriate interpretation of the relevant court rules and case law concerning the circumstances under which such fees are permissible in a party and party taxation.

Murphy J's reasoning was guided by the principles established in *Saaethoff v Saaethoff* and the relevant court rules, specifically clauses 6.35(1) and 6.51(4). The court emphasised that reading fees are generally not allowed in party and party taxations unless the case is unusually complex or the amount of material is particularly large. The court noted that in an "affidavit court," reading is inherent in every case, and therefore, reading fees should be the exception rather than the norm. The court distinguished between costs allowable on a solicitor and own client basis and those on a party and party basis.

The court ordered that the assessment of costs be varied. The husband was to be refunded a specific amount, with a further potential refund contingent on the Registrar having used a lower figure than $2301.25 as the amount to be taxed off in respect of Item 476. The notation on the assessment was to be amended to reflect the total refund amount payable to the husband.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The parties shall each do all such things, sign all such documents and engage in all such correspondence as is necessary to perform the calculation/s required to ascertain the amount used by the Registrar as the taxed-off amount in respect of Item 476 of the Amended Itemised Bill of Costs in arriving at her assessment dated 17 November, 2008.

2.

The assessment of costs made by Registrar Stevens on 17 November, 2008 be varied by:

(a) reducing the amount payable by the husband to the wife by:

(i) the amount of $13,358.04 plus

(ii) the amount of $1106.25 if, but only if, the amount of $1195 was used by the Registrar in lieu of $2301.25 as the figure to be taxed off in respect of Item 476 of the Amended Itemised Bill of Costs in arriving at her assessment.

(b) deleting the notation thereto; and

(c) adding in lieu the following notation: “The effect of this order is that the wife is to refund to the husband the sum of $30,322.10 plus, if the requirements of paragraph 2(a)(ii) of this order are met, the additional sum of $1106.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Saaethoff v Saaethoff (1987) FLC 91-817, an item in a bill of costs entitled “Brief to Appear on Appeal - $2,500.00” was, the Full Court observed, “…actually constituted by a conference and two days reading charged at $750.00 per day and $1,000.00 on the appearance”. The Full Court held at 76,158:-“It does not appear to us that this was an appropriate case for counsel to charge a reading fee additional to the fee on brief to appear. As we had previously indicated the appeal was a straight forward and uncomplicated property appeal occupying half a day and did not in our view require any significant preparation beyond what is involved in the preparation of a brief to appear in the ordinary way. The trial including judgment occupied approximately two full days and the transcript is of approximately 150 pages. The other written material was relatively brief. Counsel for the wife appeared for her at the trial. In ordinary circumstances a brief fee represents an allowance for the time expected to be occupied in court, up to one day, and for the preliminary work in mastering the facts, the law and preparing for the hearing. Where the case is of great complexity or the material is voluminous, a reading fee or a preparation fee may be appropriate, either as a separate fee or as an additional component of the brief to appear: see Magna Alloys and Research Pty Ltd v Kevin Lindsay Coffee and Ors (No.2) (1982) VR 97 especially at pp 109-111 and the cases therein referred to. [emphasis added] In this context, it is important to note the distinction between matters which might be allowed on a solicitor and own client taxation and those which might be allowed on a party and party taxation. (See eg, Locke and Locke (1993) FLC 92-352 at 79,720 per Baker J). In my opinion, the Schedule, and Item 204 specifically, are each intended to reflect the position referred to by the Full Court in Saaethoff. Clause 6.35(1) provides that:-A Registrar must not allow costs that, in the opinion of the Registrar:(a) are not reasonably necessary for the attainment of justice;(b) are not proportionate to the issues in the case. Clause 6.51(4) provides, relevantly, that the Registrar must not allow:-(a)a fee paid to counsel as retainer;(b)a reading fee, unless:-(i) the case is unusually complex;(ii) the amount of material involved is particularly large;…(d)if a daily fee for counsel’s attendance is payable in accordance with Part 2 of Schedule 3 – an additional amount for work done for the case but counsel on any day for which the daily fee applies. This court is “an affidavit court”. Evidence is given by affidavit (unless leave is otherwise given). Axiomatically, then, reading will be involved in every case irrespective of its length or complexity or whether the issues result in particularly voluminous material. Similarly, almost by definition, preparation for trial will involve significant reading. The thrust of the case law, and the Rules themselves, are each to the effect that reading fees are the exception.