JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: FLEET BROADBAND HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR -v- PARADOX DIGITAL PTY LTD (SUBJECT TO A DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT) & ORS [2005] WASC 261
CORAM: MASTER NEWNES
HEARD: 5 APRIL, 15 JUNE 2005
DELIVERED : 2 DECEMBER 2005
FILE NO/S: COR 196 of 2004
MATTER :IN THE MATTER OF PARADOX DIGITAL PTY LTD (SUBJECT TO A DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT) (ACN 008 875 714)
BETWEEN: FLEET BROADBAND HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 096 576 377)
First Plaintiff
FLEET GLOBAL PTY LTD (ACN 100 351 320)
Second PlaintiffAND
PARADOX DIGITAL PTY LTD (SUBJECT TO A DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT) (ACN 008 875 714)
First DefendantCHARLES PHILIPPE LOUIS NILANT
OREN ZOHAR
Second DefendantsDATAFAST TELECOMMUNICATIONS LIMITED (ACN 073 238 178)
Third DefendantEFTEL PTY LTD (ACN 092 667 126)
Fourth DefendantSIMON EHRENFELD
Fifth DefendantJURGEN STEINERT
Sixth Defendant
Catchwords:
Corporations - Application to terminate deed of company arrangement - Section 445D - Relevant principles - Whether unfairly prejudicial or discriminating to exclude related party creditor from participation in distribution under DOCA - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Corporate Law Reform Bill 1992 (Cth)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 232, s 286, s 435A, s 436C, s 439A, s 445D, s 445D(1), s 445D(1)(e), s 445D(1)(f), s 445D(1)(f)(i), s 445D(1)(g), s 556(1A), s 556(1B), s 564, s 600A
Result:
Application dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
First Plaintiff : Mr S Penglis
Second Plaintiff : Mr S Penglis
First Defendant : Mr J C Vaughan
Second Defendants : MR J C Vaughan
Third Defendant : Mr M N Solomon
Fourth Defendant : Mr M N Solomon
Fifth Defendant : Mr M N Solomon
Sixth Defendant : Mr M N Solomon
Solicitors:
First Plaintiff : Freehills
Second Plaintiff : Freehills
First Defendant : Christensen Vaughan
Second Defendants : Christensen Vaughan
Third Defendant : Gadens Lawyers
Fourth Defendant : Gadens Lawyers
Fifth Defendant : Gadens Lawyers
Sixth Defendant : Gadens Lawyers
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Bathurst City Council v Event Management Specialist Pty Ltd [2001] NSWSC 34
BGC Contracting Pty Ltd v Kimberly Gold Pty Ltd (2000) 18 ACLC 894
Cresvale Far East v Cresvale Securities (2001) 37 ACSR 394
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Portinex Pty Ltd (2000) 156 FLR 453
Emanuele v Australian Securities Commission (1995) 63 FCR 54
Hagenvale Pty Ltd v Depela Pty Ltd & Serrada Holdings Pty Ltd (1995) 17 ACSR 139
Hamilton v National Australia Bank Limited (1996) 66 FCR 12
JA Pty Ltd v Jonco Holdings Pty Ltd (2000) 33 ACSR 691
Jenkins v Enterprise Goldmines NL (1992) 6 ACSR 539
Kalon Pty Ltd v Sydney Land Corporation Pty Ltd (No 2) (1998) 16 ACLC 540
Khoury v Zambena (1997) 15 ACLC 620
Lam Soon Australia Pty Ltd v Molit (No 55) Pty Ltd (1996) 70 FCR 34
Re Bartlett Researched Securities Pty Ltd (1994) 12 ACSR 707
Sydney Land Corporation Pty Ltd v Kalon Pty Ltd (1997) 16 ACLC 95
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fleet Broadband Holdings Pty Ltd v Paradox Digital Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] WASC 261
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court evaluated the application of section 445D(1)(f)(i) by examining the overall effect of the DOCA and assessing any unfairness to Fleet, considering the scheme of Part 5.3A, the interests of other creditors, the company, and the public. It was necessary to consider the whole of the circumstances to determine if there was overall unfairness, with the criteria guiding the Court being fairness and practicality of the scheme as a whole. The Court was tasked with deciding whether, in balancing the interests of creditors as a whole against minority creditor interests, the DOCA unfairly prejudiced the interests of the minority. This decision was made according to ordinary standards of reasonableness and fair dealing, with the conduct being judged on standards which reasonable commercial persons acting bona fide would think to be fair. The Court also considered the application of section 445D(1)(g), which may be relevant where the proposal for the DOCA has a fraudulent or wrongful purpose, or the DOCA offers an unconscionable premium contrary to public policy.
The Court concluded that the DOCA did not unfairly prejudice Fleet, as it was not oppressive or unfairly discriminatory in terms of section 445D(1)(f). The Court found that a DOCA may provide differential dividends among creditors, and Part 5.3A does not require a pari passu distribution. Instead, the aim is to provide a better return to creditors than an immediate winding up, which was achieved in this case. Furthermore, the Court found no evidence of fraudulent or wrongful purposes in the DOCA or any unconscionable premium offered to creditors.
The Court dismissed the application by Fleet Broadband Holdings Pty Ltd to terminate the DOCA.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Where s 445D(1)(f)(i) is relied upon, the Court looks at the whole of the effect of the DOCA and assesses its unfairness, if any, to the plaintiff creditor bearing in mind the scheme of Pt 5.3A, the interests of the other creditors, the company and the public generally: Sydney Land Corporation Pty Ltd v Kalon Pty Ltd(supra) at 98. In order to consider questions of fairness it is necessary to look at the whole of the circumstances and see if there is overall unfairness: Hagenvale Pty Ltd v Depela Pty Ltd & Serrada Holdings Pty Ltd (1995) 17 ACSR 139 at 151; Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Portinex Pty Ltd (2000) 156 FLR 453. The criteria that guide the Court are fairness and practicality of the scheme as a whole: Re Bartlett Researched Securities Pty Ltd (1994) 12 ACSR 707 at 710. It is for the Court to decide whether, in balancing the interests of the creditors as a whole against minority creditor interests, the DOCA acts so as to unfairly prejudice the interests of the minority. The Court decides this "according to ordinary standards of reasonableness and fair dealing". Whether the conduct is unfairly discriminatory will be judged on standards which reasonable commercial persons acting bona fide would think to be fair: Jenkins v Enterprise Goldmines NL (1992) 6 ACSR 539 at 550. That case was concerned with an application of oppression of members but the expression "oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to, or unfairly discriminatory against" in s 445D(1)(f) is in the same terms as s 232 and, so long as it is borne in mind that in the former the oppression may be of creditors by other creditors rather than of members by directors or other members, the case law dealing with oppression under s 232 is of assistance: Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Portinex Pty Ltd (supra) at [100]. The fact that the deed discriminates between creditors will not of itself establish that it is unfairly discriminatory or prejudicial: Khoury v Zambena Pty Ltd (supra) at 627; Lam Soon Australia Pty Ltd v Molit (No 55) Pty Ltd (supra). The test under s 445D(1)(f)(i) is not merely discrimination or prejudice, but unfair discrimination or unfair prejudice: Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Portinex Pty Ltd (supra) at [102]. Some degree of discrimination is not necessarily unfair. Thus it is clear that a DOCA may provide the differential dividends among creditors: Hamilton v National Australia Bank Limited (1996) 66 FCR 12 at 38. Part 5.3A does not require a pari passu distribution. What is required is a better return to creditors than an immediate winding up: Lam Soon Australia Pty Ltd v Molit (No 55) Pty Ltd (supra). That object is met if some creditors are better off than in a winding up and none are worse off under the DOCA than they would be under a winding up. There is little assistance to be gained on the application of s 445D(1)(g) from the Explanatory Memorandum to the Corporate Law Reform Bill 1992 (Cth). It was there observed that "having regard to the width of the previous paragraphs in proposed subsection (1), it is anticipated that the Court's power under proposed paragraph (1)(g) would be exercised at most very rarely". The provision may be available where the proposal for the DOCA has a fraudulent or wrongful purpose: Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Portinex Pty Ltd (supra) at [99] or the DOCA offers an unconscionable premium, contrary to public policy, as a bribe to creditors to support an arrangement under which the conduct of the directors will not be investigated: Young v Sherman (2002) 170 FLR 86 at [67]. But the possibility or even the probability that abuse may occur is not itself sufficient to deny creditors the opportunity to approve arrangements including a premium distribution in a case where the facts do not point to any such impropriety: Young v Sherman (supra).