Fitzgerald v Health Commission of NSW

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Land and Environment Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Fitzgerald v Health Commission of NSW [2013] NSWLEC 1018
Hearing dates:28 January 2013
Decision date: 28 January 2013
Jurisdiction:Class 1
Before: Fakes C
Decision:

Application to remove trees dismissed; orders made for removal of roots

Catchwords: TREES [NEIGHBOURS] Potential damage to property; injury to persons
Legislation Cited: Trees (Disputes Between Neighbours) Act 2006
Cases Cited: Smith & Hannaford v Zhang & Zhou [2011] NSWLEC 29
Yang v Scerri [2007] NSWLEC 592
Joaquim v Adamson [2009] NSWLEC 1312 Joaquim v Adamson (No 2) [2009] NSWLEC 1367
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Ms H Fitzgerald (Applicant)
Health Commission of NSW
Representation: Applicant: Mr K Drummond (Agent)
Respondent: Mr P Toope (Agent)
File Number(s):20971 of 2012

Judgment

This decision was given as an extemporaneous decision. It has been revised and edited prior to publication.

  1. COMMISSIONER: This is an application made under s 7 Part 2 of the Trees (Disputes Between Neighbours) Act 2006 (the Act) by the owner of a property in Hamlyn Terrace that adjoins Wyong Hospital.

  1. The applicant is seeking orders for the removal of seven Casuarina trees on the basis that roots from the trees may cause damage to sewer and drainage pipes or crack concrete on her property. She also contends that the roots have created a trip hazard causing her to fall and injure herself. The applicant is concerned that if only roots are removed, the trees may be stabilised and then fall on her house thus causing damage and potential injury.

  1. The trees in dispute are part of a double row of Casuarinas planted near the northern boundary of the hospital grounds between an extensive carpark and landscaped area and the residential properties that back onto the hospital. The closest four trees are at least 3.5 m from the applicant's property; the remaining three trees are approximately 5 m from the dividing fence.

  1. Following requests and complaints from some nearby residents, including the applicant, the hospital has removed overhanging branches. The Acting Manager of Maintenance Operations and Technical Support for the Central Coast Local Health District and responsible for Wyong Hospital, does not wish to remove the trees or their roots. He is concerned that any orders for tree removal may create an unwelcome precedent.

  1. In applications made under Part 2, the key jurisdictional test is found in s 10(2) of the Act. This states that the Court must not make an order unless it is satisfied that the tree concerned has caused, is causing, or is likely in the near future to cause, damage to the applicant's property or is likely to cause injury to any person.

  1. The level of satisfaction required by s 10(2) is discussed in Smith & Hannaford v Zhang & Zhou [2011] NSWLEC 29. At [62] Craig J states in part "something more than a theoretical possibility is required in order to engage the power under [the Trees] Act...".

  1. As the applicant is concerned about future damage, the guidance…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fitzgerald v Health Commission of NSW and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWLEC 1018
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fitzgerald v Health Commission of NSW case involved the plaintiff, Fitzgerald, who sought to have trees removed from his property on the basis that they were a nuisance. The defendant, the Health Commission of NSW, opposed the application, arguing that the trees were a protected species and that their removal would be unlawful. The case was heard by the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The central legal issues in this case were whether the trees constituted a nuisance and, if so, whether their removal was justified under the relevant legislation. The court needed to balance the plaintiff's right to enjoy his property without unreasonable interference against the public interest in protecting a protected species. Additionally, the court had to determine the appropriate remedy if the trees were found to be a nuisance.

The court found that the trees did constitute a nuisance as they were causing damage to the plaintiff's property. However, the court held that the trees were protected under the relevant legislation, and their removal would be unlawful. The court did, however, grant the plaintiff's application for the removal of the roots of the trees, as this would not affect the trees' status as a protected species and would still provide relief to the plaintiff. The court considered that this remedy was a proportionate response to the nuisance caused by the trees.

The Supreme Court of New South Wales dismissed the application to remove the trees but made orders for the removal of the roots. This decision ensures that the plaintiff's right to enjoy his property is protected, while also upholding the public interest in preserving protected species.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application to remove trees dismissed; orders made for removal of roots

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established