Fitness First Australia Pty Ltd v McNicol (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Fitness First Australia Pty Ltd v McNicol (No 2) [2013] QSC 329

PARTIES:

FITNESS FIRST AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED

(applicant)
v
DEAN McNICOL
(respondent)

FILE NO:

BS4895 of 2012

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application for punishment for contempt  

DELIVERED ON:

25 November 2013 (ex tempore)

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

25 November 2013

JUDGE:

Mullins J

ORDER:

1. In respect of each charge, the respondent is sentenced to three months imprisonment.

2. The date the respondent is released on parole is fixed at 25 November 2013.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CONTEMPT, ATTACHMENT AND SEQUESTRATION – POWER OF COURT TO PUNISH FOR CONTEMPT – SUPREME COURT – GENERALLY – where after a hearing the respondent was found to have committed contempt by breaching the order of Philip McMurdo J made on 2 October 2012 – where five of the 17 contempt charges were proved – where the conduct that was the subject of the latter four of the proved charges was committed after the contempt application had begun – where the respondent expressed some remorse, but that was diluted by allegations made in his affidavit and oral submissions for the penalty hearing – where the respondent has no prior criminal history – where the fact that the respondent had been held in custody  on remand for over four months in relation to a stalking charge after the contempt application had commenced was not irrelevant to the penalty to be imposed for the five proved contempt charges – what punishment is appropriate for the contempt and the circumstances of the contemnor

Australian Meat Industry Employees Union v Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 98, considered
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Michalik (2004) 52 ACSR 115, considered
Commissioner for Fair Trading v TLC Consulting Services Pty Ltd[2011] QSC 374, considered
Fitness First Australia Pty Ltd v McNicol [2013] QSC 212, related
Fitness First Australia v McNicol[2012] QSC 296, related
Formal Wear Express Franchising Pty Ltd v Roach

[2004] QCA 339, considered

COUNSEL:

D de Jersey for the applicant

The respondent appeared for himself

SOLICITORS:

Minter Ellison – Gold Coast for the applicant

HER HONOUR: After a hearing, I found that the respondent, Mr McNicol, committed contempt by failing to comply with the order of his Honour Justice McMurdo made on 2 October 2012 in this proceeding, as particularised in charges 5, 8, 9, 10 and 17 of the further amended application filed on 22 July 2013. My reasons are found in Fitness First Australia Pty Ltd v McNicol [2013] QSC 212 (the reasons). This proceeding was complex as there were 17 charges prosecuted by the applicant in respect of which evidence was adduced before me. I did not find 12 of those charges proved. It is important in imposing penalty for the five charges that were proved that I am not influenced by the conduct that was found not to be in breach of Justice McMurdo’s orders.

It…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fitness First Australia Pty Ltd v McNicol (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QSC 329
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Fitness First Australia Pty Ltd v McNicol, the dispute involved the respondent, McNicol, who was found to have committed contempt by breaching an order made by Philip McMurdo J on 2 October 2012. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Australia, where the court was required to determine the appropriate punishment for McNicol's contemptuous conduct. The case hinged on five of the seventeen charges of contempt that were proven against McNicol. Notably, four of these charges related to conduct that occurred after the contempt application had commenced. McNicol expressed some remorse for his actions, though this was somewhat undermined by allegations in his affidavit and oral submissions during the penalty hearing. At the time of the contempt, McNicol had no prior criminal history, but he had been in custody on remand for over four months in relation to a stalking charge.

The court was tasked with determining the appropriate punishment for the contempt committed by McNicol, taking into account the circumstances of the case. The court considered several factors in its deliberation, including the nature of the contempt, the timing of the contemptuous conduct, and the respondent's expression of remorse, albeit diluted by his own allegations. Additionally, the court noted that McNicol had been in custody for a significant period prior to the contempt application, which was relevant to the penalty consideration. After careful deliberation, the court decided on a sentence of three months imprisonment for each of the five proved contempt charges. The court also fixed the date of McNicol's release on parole at 25 November 2013, providing a clear timeline for his potential early release.

The final orders of the court mandated that McNicol serve three months imprisonment for each of the five contempt charges. Furthermore, the court set the release date on parole for McNicol at 25 November 2013, indicating a specific point at which he might be released earlier than the full term, subject to parole board approval. This decision provided a clear framework for the enforcement of the contempt order and the consequences McNicol faced for his actions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In respect of each charge, the respondent is sentenced to three months imprisonment.

2. The date the respondent is released on parole is fixed at 25 November 2013.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Fitness First Australia Pty Ltd v McNicol (No 2) involved a proceeding where the respondent, McNicol, was found to have committed contempt by breaching an order made by Philip McMurdo J on 2 October 2012. The contempt application involved 17 charges against McNicol, of which five were proven. The conduct forming the basis of four of the proved charges was committed after the contempt application had begun. McNicol expressed some remorse for his actions, but this was countered by allegations made in his affidavit and oral submissions during the penalty hearing. McNicol had no prior criminal history, but he had been held in custody on remand for over four months in relation to a stalking charge after the contempt application had commenced. The court needed to determine what punishment was appropriate for the contempt and the circumstances of the contemnor.

This case came before the court as a follow-up to a prior contempt application where McNicol was found to have breached a court order made by Philip McMurdo J. Out of 17 charges, five were proven, with the relevant conduct for four of these charges being committed after the commencement of the contempt application. The case proceeded to a penalty hearing where McNicol expressed some remorse but also made allegations that diluted his remorse. The court considered the fact that McNicol had been in custody on remand for over four months in relation to a stalking charge, which began after the contempt application had started.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What punishment is appropriate for the contempt and the circumstances of the contemnor?
2. How should the fact that the contemnor had been held in custody on remand for over four months in relation to a stalking charge affect the punishment?
3. To what extent should the expressions of remorse and allegations made by the contemnor be considered in determining the appropriate punishment?

Held
1. The court held that for each of the five proved contempt charges, the appropriate punishment is three months imprisonment.
2. The fact that the contemnor had been held in custody on remand for over four months in relation to a stalking charge was relevant to the punishment for the contempt charges, but the court did not specify how this influenced the sentencing.
3. The expressions of remorse and allegations made by the contemnor were considered in determining the appropriate punishment, with the court noting that the remorse was diluted by the allegations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the appropriate punishment for the contempt charges by examining the severity of the breaches and the nature of the contempt. It applied legal principles surrounding contempt of court and the necessity of maintaining the authority of the court. The court also considered the contemnor's lack of prior criminal history, which might have influenced the leniency of the sentence. The court acknowledged the contemnor's expressions of remorse but noted that these were undercut by the allegations made in his affidavit and oral submissions. The fact that the contemnor had been held in custody on remand for over four months for a stalking charge was noted but not explicitly factored into the sentencing. The binding principle established is that while the court must consider all relevant circumstances, the severity of the contempt and the need to uphold the dignity of the court weigh heavily in determining an appropriate punishment.