Fishwives Pty Ltd v FAI General Insurance Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      FISHWIVES PTY LTD v FAI GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD & ORS [2001]  NSWCA 193

FILE NUMBER(S):
40286/99

HEARING DATE(S):   17 May 2001

JUDGMENT DATE:    27/06/2001

PARTIES:
FISHWIVES PTY LTD v FAI GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD & ORS

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Meagher JA Handley JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:    District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):           DC 9474/97

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:       Delaney DCJ

COUNSEL:
Appellant: P M Biscoe QC/ CA Vindin
1st & 2nd Respondent: D L Davies SC
3rd  Respondent: P T Taylor

SOLICITORS:
Appellant: Pryor Tzannes & Wallis
1st & 2nd Respondent: Blake Dawson Waldron
3rd Respondent: Phillips Fox

CATCHWORDS:
Insurance - claims made and notified policy - failure to disclose "circumstances which may give rise to a claim" - scope of s6(4) of Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (ND)

LEGISLATION CITED:

DECISION:
Appeal dismissed with costs. Cross appeal by FAI General Insurance Co Ltd dismissed with costs.

JUDGMENT:

THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40286/99

DC  9474/97

MASON P
MEAGHER JA
HANDLEY JA

Wednesday 27 June 2001

FISHWIVES PTY LIMITED v  FAI GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD & 2 ORS

JUDGMENT

  1. MASON P:                 The appellant is a hapless plaintiff that sued its architect to judgment for professional negligence only to find the defendant insolvent.  The defendant was insured against liability for professional negligence under a claims made and notified policy.  Consequently, the appellant sought leave to commence proceedings against three insurers each of whom covered one third of the risk.  Leave was refused.  This appeal, itself by leave, challenges that order and the two grounds upon which it stands.

  2. Judge Delaney refused leave on two bases, each of which must be overcome if the appellant is to be successful in this appeal:

    (i)s6 of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (the Act) did not apply to a claims made and notified policy;

    (ii)the insurers were entitled to disclaim liability because of the insured’s failure to disclose certain matters in the relevant proposal form.

    The facts

  3. In June 1988 the appellant appointed Firth Lee & Partners Pty Ltd (the insured) as its architect to design, document and perform contract administration for a four level office building at Chatswood.  The insured prepared the contract documents and supervised the construction work, which was  done by Prime Constructions Pty Ltd (Prime) in 1988-1989. 

  4. The defects liability period expired in December 1989.  In March 1990 several granite tiles fell from the exterior of the building to the footpath.  In consequence, the premises were inspected on 22 March 1990 by Mr Stefanatos, one of the principals of the insured.  There were also inspections by representatives of Prime, Metro Marble Pty Ltd (the tiling subcontractor) and the distributor of Laticrete (the adhesive specified by the insured and used in affixing the granite tiles).

  5. On 19 March 1990 Mr Geoffrey Lee, another of the principals of the insured, sent a memorandum to Mr Stefanatos as follows:

    Last week several granite tiles fell from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fishwives Pty Ltd v FAI General Insurance Co Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWCA 193
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fishwives Pty Ltd (the appellant) appealed a decision concerning an insurance claim against FAI General Insurance Co Ltd and two other insurers (the respondents). The dispute arose from FAI's denial of indemnity under an architects' indemnity insurance policy. The appellant had notified a claim against the insured during the policy period, but the insurers contended that the insured had failed to disclose material circumstances that may have given rise to a claim in its proposal for insurance. The appeal was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the insured had failed to make a material disclosure in its insurance proposal, and consequently, whether the insurers were entitled to disclaim liability. Specifically, the court considered whether the insured's principals were aware of circumstances that might give rise to a claim at the time of the proposal, and if so, whether this constituted a breach of the policy's disclosure obligations. A related, though ultimately unaddressed, issue was the applicability of section 6(4) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (NSW) to a "claims made and notified" policy.

The court reasoned that the insured's proposal form contained a question asking if the principals were aware of any circumstances which might give rise to claims, whether they considered themselves liable or not. Evidence, including a memorandum from March 1990 and subsequent reports, indicated that the insured's principals were aware of issues concerning dislodged granite tiles from the building's external wall as early as 1990 and again in 1992. The court found that this awareness constituted circumstances that could give rise to a claim, and the failure to disclose these circumstances in the proposal was a material non-disclosure. This non-disclosure, coupled with an exclusion clause in the policy relating to claims and circumstances noted on proposal forms, provided a basis for the insurers to disclaim liability.

The appeal was dismissed with costs. The cross-appeal by FAI General Insurance Co Ltd concerning costs was also dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs. Cross appeal by FAI General Insurance Co Ltd dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Senior counsel for the sole contending respondent, GIO, formulated the legal basis for disclaimer of liability based upon the insured’s answers to question 7 in the Proposal Form. It was submitted that the principals of the insured (Mr Lee, in particular) were aware on 29 September 1992 of “circumstances which may give rise to claims against the firm …whether you consider yourselves liable or not”. Failure to disclose that awareness was material non-disclosure, especially in light of Exclusion (e) of the policy which stipulated that there was no indemnity against claims upon the insured:… arising out of claims and circumstances noted on the proposal form for the current period of cover or on any previous proposal form.The judgment under appeal The respondents successfully opposed the granting of leave to proceed on each of the grounds referred to in par 2 above. As to the first ground, Judge Delaney held that s6 of the Act did not extend to a claims made and notified policy. It is common ground in the appeal that this legal issue is one of significance and difficulty. Each side cites numerous decisions in its favour (see generally, Sutton, Insurance Law in Australia 2nd ed, 1999 §2.119). It is unnecessary for this Court to address this issue if we are of the view that leave was properly refused having regard to the non-disclosures inherent in the answers to questions 7(a) and (b) of the Proposal Form. That in fact is my view, for the reasons which follow. Before the primary judge the insurers relied upon the following as establishing that the insured failed to make proper disclosure in its proposal of 29 September 1992:(a)Mr Lee’s memorandum of 19 March 1990;(b)the facts summarised in Mr Stefanatos’ memorandum of 27 October 1993;(c)the evidence of Mr Lee (CB 114-122); and(d)the report and evidence of a consultant architect, Mr J G Poiner who addressed the inferences which an architect acting reasonably would have drawn from the events of March 1990 and “May” 1992 when granite tiles fell from the external wall of the building (CB 104, 122-127). Judge Delaney summarised the evidence. He concluded that he was satisfied that:… the first problems arose in relation to the failure of the granite, at least in 1990, and were raised and considered during that time as well as in March and May of 1992. Accordingly, these were issues which were raised between the parties before the policy was taken out in September of 1992. Later in his judgment his Honour concluded that he had:… come to the view, on the balance of probabilities, that the failure by Mr Lee to disclose the various matters which appear in [the Stefanatos memorandum] provided in terms of the proviso of s6(4) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act a basis upon which, on the balance of probabilities, I can be satisfied that the insurer was entitled, pursuant to the terms of the contract of insurance, to disclaim liability. The appellant challenges these conclusions and submits that his Honour erred in using them as the basis for refusing leave in the event (contrary to his Honour’s view) that s6 applied to the policy in question.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The recent appointment of a provisional liquidator to members of the HIH Insurance group including the first and second respondents meant that the appellant was forced to make a belated application for leave to proceed in the appeal against those respondents (see Corporations Law, s471B). That leave was granted at the commencement of the hearing of the appeal whereupon senior counsel for those two respondents withdrew because he had no further instructions in the appeal. It follows that, as matters presently stand, the hapless appellant has encountered two further opponents whose lack of opposition reflects their lack of money. The appeal proceeded against the three respondents, but with counsel for the third respondent (GIO) manning the only labouring oar. A cross-appeal involving costs had been filed by FAI pursuant to leave. It has not been prosecuted and accordingly it will be dismissed with costs in the final orders.The insurance policy and the issues arising under it The insured was covered under the Australian Architects’ Indemnity plan from at least as early as 1990. It would appear that the sole insurer may originally have been FAI General Insurance Co Ltd. But during the period 26 October 1992 - 26 October 1993 the three respondents were the insurers, each covering one-third of the risk. It was during that period that the appellant clearly indicated its intention to sue the insured, first by solicitor’s letter and then by the issue of the statement of claim in the District Court which was filed and served in early October 1993. On 11 November 1993 the insured gave formal notification of the claim to the insurers. One of the printed questions on the Form asked:On what date did the Insured first become aware of the matter complained of or the circumstances which may give rise to a claim?The question was answered:On or about 12 March 1990 first piece of granite dislodged. Various rectification works and investigations carried out between this date and date of claim. On 16 September 1994 FAI declined indemnity on the basis that the circumstances giving rise to the claim were known by the insured at least as early as 19 March 1990, yet they were not notified under the policy in force as at that date nor was the existence of those circumstances disclosed in connection with subsequent policies in the proposals for those policies or otherwise. The application for leave to commence proceedings against the three respondents based itself upon the assertion that they were the insurers on risk during the period when the appellant’s claim was made against the insured and notified by the insured to its respective insurers. I am unaware of evidence indicating that the other two insurers on risk in 1992-1993 have disclaimed liability or formally spelt out their reasons for doing so. Nevertheless, the case proceeded in the District Court on the basis that the three insurers made common cause in opposition. The relevant Proposal is dated 29 September 1992 and signed by Mr Geoffrey Lee. Part 7 of that Proposal reads:7.(a) Have any claims ever been made against the firm, its predecessors in business, or any present or past Principal? YES/NOIf “YES”, please give full particulars, including parties involved, date of occurrence, date of discovery and amount involved.(b)Are any of the Principals after enquiry, aware of any circumstances which may give rise to claims against the firm or their predecessors in business or any of the present or former Principals whether you consider yourselves liable or not? YES/NOIf “YES”, please give full particulars, including parties involved, date of occurrence, date of discovery and amount involved.