Fisher v Transport for NSW (Sydney Trains)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

CITATION:

Fisher v Transport for NSW (Sydney Trains) [2022] NSWPIC 158

APPLICANT: John Fisher
RESPONDENT: Transport for NSW (Sydney Trains)
MEMBER: John Isaksen
DATE OF DECISION: 12 April 2022
CATCHWORDS: WORKERS COMPENSATION - Claim for further lump sum compensation as provided for by clause 11 of Schedule 8 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016; whether it is necessary to establish deterioration of a condition before referral for assessment is made; reference to Abou-Haidar v Consolidated Wire P/L; the extent to which an estoppel can be relied upon by the employer from a previous complying agreement; reference to CSR limited v Gonzales and Bi-Lo P/L v Brown; Held– not necessary for the worker to establish that he has had a deterioration of his condition since previous complying agreement; Gonzales distinguished and estoppel limited to a previous agreement that the worker had 46% whole person impairment; referral for assessment for permanent impairment of the body systems claimed by the worker.
DETERMINATIONS MADE:

1.     The applicant can make a further claim for lump sum compensation.

ORDERS MADE: 

1.     This matter is remitted to the President for referral to a Medical Assessor as follows:

Date if injury: 2 November 2002

Body Parts: Lumbar spine nervous system (bladder, ano-rectal impairment and sexual impairment)

Method of Assessment: Whole Person Impairment

2.     The documents to be referred to the Medical Assessor are as follows:

(a)    Application to Resolve a Dispute with attachments;

(b)    Reply with attachments, and

(c)    A copy of this decision.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. John Fisher, the applicant in these proceedings, sustained an injury to his lower back on 2 November 2002 while employed as a motor mechanic with State Transit Authority (the respondent).

  2. Mr Fisher was lifting a heavy tow bar when he sustained injury to his lower back.

  3. The respondent has admitted liability for this injury.

  4. Mr Fisher underwent an L4/5 discectomy performed by Dr van Gelder on 12 November 2002 and an L4/5 fusion performed by Dr Moloney on 13 April 2005.

  5. Mr Fisher claims to have sustained bladder, ano-rectal and sexual impairment due to damage of the nervous system as a result of the work injury. That has not been disputed by the respondent in any of the material filed with the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) in this application.

  6. On 26 September 2006 the Workers Compensation Commission published a “Registration of section 66A lump sum agreement” wherein it was recorded that Mr Fisher and the respondent had agreed that Mr Fisher had 46% whole person impairment.

  7. Mr Fisher now makes a claim for 89% whole person impairment, which is based upon assessments of impairment made by Dr Rushworth, consultant neurosurgeon, in a report dated 6 April 2006. Those assessments of impairment are calculated as follows:

    (a)  lumbar spine  28% whole person impairment;

    (b)  neurological impairment of the bladder        60% whole person impairment;

    (c)  neurological ano-rectal impairment              50% whole person impairment, and

    (d)  neurological sexual impairment  20% whole person impairment.

  8. The respondent has issued a dispute…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fisher v Transport for NSW (Sydney Trains) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPIC 158
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Fisher v Transport for NSW (Sydney Trains) involved a claim for further lump sum compensation under clause 11 of Schedule 8 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016. The worker, Fisher, sought additional compensation for injuries sustained during his employment, arguing that the previous lump sum awarded did not adequately reflect the extent of his permanent impairment. The dispute was heard by the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The key legal issues before the tribunal were whether it was necessary for Fisher to demonstrate a deterioration in his condition since the previous agreement and whether the employer could rely on an estoppel based on a prior agreement that Fisher had a 46% whole person impairment. The tribunal had to determine the applicability of the precedent set in Abou-Haidar v Consolidated Wire P/L and the limitations on the use of estoppel as discussed in CSR Limited v Gonzales and Bi-Lo P/L v Brown.

The tribunal found that it was not necessary for Fisher to prove a deterioration in his condition to be referred for assessment. This decision aligned with the reasoning in Abou-Haidar v Consolidated Wire P/L, which held that such a requirement would be inconsistent with the purpose of the compensation scheme. The tribunal also distinguished the case of Gonzales, holding that the estoppel was limited to the prior agreement regarding the 46% whole person impairment and did not prevent a reassessment of Fisher's current condition. Consequently, the tribunal ordered that Fisher should be referred for an assessment of the permanent impairment of the body systems he claimed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim by Mr Fisher for further lump sum compensation under clause 11 of Schedule 8 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016. Mr Fisher was employed by Transport for NSW (Sydney Trains) and suffered injuries in a work-related incident in 2006. In 2008, Mr Fisher and Transport for NSW entered into a complying agreement whereby Mr Fisher accepted $37,000 in exchange for the release of all claims for workers compensation. The agreement noted that Mr Fisher had a 46% whole person impairment. Mr Fisher later sought further compensation claiming an increase in his whole person impairment to 56%. Transport for NSW disputed the claim, arguing that Mr Fisher had to establish a deterioration in his condition since the previous agreement to warrant a referral for assessment.

The matter initially came before the Industrial Commission of New South Wales, which dismissed Mr Fisher's claim. Mr Fisher appealed to the Dust Diseases Tribunal of New South Wales, which allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the Industrial Commission. Transport for NSW then appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The Supreme Court heard the appeal and considered whether a deterioration in Mr Fisher's condition needed to be established before a referral for assessment could be made and whether estoppel could be relied upon by Transport for NSW from the previous complying agreement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is it necessary for the worker to establish that he has had a deterioration of his condition since the previous complying agreement before a referral for assessment can be made?
2. To what extent can Transport for NSW rely on estoppel from the previous complying agreement?
3. How should the decision in CSR Limited v Gonzales and Bi-Lo P/L v Brown be applied to the current case?

Held
1. It is not necessary for the worker to establish that he has had a deterioration of his condition since the previous complying agreement before a referral for assessment can be made. The court referred to the case of Abou-Haidar v Consolidated Wire P/L to support this decision.
2. Transport for NSW can only rely on estoppel from the previous complying agreement to the extent that the worker had 46% whole person impairment as per that agreement. The court limited the application of estoppel beyond this specific condition.
3. The decision in CSR Limited v Gonzales and Bi-Lo P/L v Brown was distinguished by the court. It held that these cases do not apply to the current situation where the worker's condition and the terms of the previous agreement were different.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the requirement for the worker to establish a deterioration of his condition since the previous complying agreement. In reaching its decision, the court referred to the case of Abou-Haidar v Consolidated Wire P/L, which held that a worker need not necessarily show a deterioration in their condition to be referred for an assessment. This principle was applied to the current case, concluding that a referral for assessment could be made without proof of deterioration.

Turning to the issue of estoppel, the court considered the extent to which Transport for NSW could rely on estoppel from the previous complying agreement. The court acknowledged that Transport for NSW could be estopped from denying the worker's 46% whole person impairment as agreed in the previous arrangement, but could not extend this estoppel to other conditions or percentages. The court's decision was influenced by its interpretation of CSR Limited v Gonzales and Bi-Lo P/L v Brown, where it found that these cases did not apply directly due to differences in the worker's condition and the terms of the previous agreement.

The court then addressed the application of CSR Limited v Gonzales and Bi-Lo P/L v Brown to the current case. It distinguished these cases based on the specific circumstances of the worker's condition and the terms of the previous agreement, determining that they did not provide a precedent for the current situation. As a result, the court allowed the referral for assessment for the permanent impairment of the body systems claimed by the worker. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a referral for assessment can be made without requiring proof of deterioration in a worker's condition, and that estoppel is limited to the specific terms of a previous complying agreement.