Finn v Department of Correctional Services

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

FINN v DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES

[2012] SASC 88

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

1 June 2012

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - NON-CUSTODIAL ORDERS - COMMUNITY SERVICE ORDERS

MAGISTRATES - JURISDICTION AND PROCEDURE GENERALLY - PROCEDURE - THE HEARING - PLEA AND STATEMENT OF DEFENCE - PLEA OF GUILTY - WHERE DEFENDANT NOT REPRESENTED

MAGISTRATES - JURISDICTION AND PROCEDURE GENERALLY - PROCEDURE - THE HEARING - GENERAL MATTERS - MATTERS OF PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS AND PROPRIETY

The appellant was ordered by a Magistrate to be imprisoned for 40 days for failure to comply with an order requiring him to perform 320 hours of community service.  The appellant served 21 days imprisonment before being granted bail pending his appeal against the Magistrate’s orders.

Whether the Magistrate ought to have granted the appellant’s application for an adjournment to seek legal advice and representation – whether the Magistrate ought to have informed the appellant of his right to object, cross-examine and adduce evidence and make submissions – whether the Magistrate ought to have informed the appellant of the power to excuse a failure to comply – whether the Magistrate properly considered exercise of the power to excuse the failure to comply – whether the appellant ought to be excused for his failure to comply.

Held, allowing the appeal:

(1) the Magistrate failed to inform the appellant of his rights in relation to evidence and submissions on the substantive hearing and of the court’s power of excusal.

(2) the Magistrate erred in her consideration of the power of excusal.

(3) proper grounds existed for the failure to be excused.

Orders of the Magistrate set aside. Order made refraining from issuing a warrant of commitment, extending the term of the order made on 20 May 2011 and reducing the number of hours of community service to be performed to 152 hours, in accordance with time served by way of imprisonment.

Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) s 11, 64-71; Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA) s 15, 16, 17, referred to.
Caston v Police (2002) 132 A Crim R 11; Cooling v Steel (1971) 2 SASR 249; Stanford v Police [2006] SASC 143, applied.
R v Buckman (1987) 47 SASR 303, discussed.
Hodgins v Police [2008] SASC 176; R v Harvey [1996] SASC S5519; Stanitszki v Higgins (1994) 63 SASR 309, considered.

FINN v DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES
[2012] SASC 88

Magistrates Appeal

  1. BLUE J:   The appellant Mr Finn was ordered by a Magistrate to be imprisoned for 40 days on the basis that the Magistrate was satisfied that he had failed to comply with an order requiring him to perform 320 hours of community service.[1]

    [1]    Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) s 71(5).

  2. Mr Finn appeals against that order. The appeal raises the issues:

    1.whether the Magistrate ought to have granted Mr Finn’s application for an adjournment to seek legal advice and representation;

    2.how the Magistrate ought to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Finn v Department of Correctional Services and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 88
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Finn v Department of Correctional Services was an appeal heard by the District Court of South Australia. The case involved Mr Finn, who was subject to a community service order that he failed to comply with on six occasions. The Department of Correctional Services applied to the Magistrates Court for an order of imprisonment due to Mr Finn's non-compliance. The Magistrate subsequently ordered that Mr Finn be imprisoned for 40 days. Mr Finn appealed the Magistrate's decision, arguing that he should not have been imprisoned and that his failure to comply with the community service order should have been excused. The appeal raised several legal issues, including whether the Magistrate should have granted Mr Finn's application for an adjournment to seek legal advice and representation, and whether the Magistrate properly considered the exercise of the power to excuse the failure to comply.

The court found that the hearing miscarried due to procedural issues and the Magistrate's flawed reasoning on excusal. The court held that the Magistrate ought to have granted Mr Finn's application for an adjournment to seek legal advice and representation. The court also found that the Magistrate did not properly consider the exercise of the power to excuse the failure to comply. The court determined that there were proper grounds for excusal, as Mr Finn's employment prevented him from attending for community service on three occasions and he had other legitimate reasons for missing the remaining sessions. The court concluded that the appeal must be allowed and the Magistrate's order set aside.

The court proceeded to hear and determine the section 71 application itself, finding that Mr Finn's failure to comply with the community service order should be excused. The court ordered that the community service order be extended to allow Mr Finn to complete the required hours of community service instead of serving the term of imprisonment imposed by the Magistrate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Finn appeals against that order. The appeal raises the issues:1.whether the Magistrate ought to have granted Mr Finn’s application for an adjournment to seek legal advice and representation;2.how the Magistrate ought to have proceeded upon hearing and determining the section 71 application given that Mr Finn was not represented;3.whether the Magistrate ought to have informed Mr Finn of the power to excuse a failure to comply;4.whether the Magistrate properly considered exercise of the power to excuse the failure to comply; and5.whether Mr Finn ought to have been excused for his failure to comply.Background facts Between October 2007 and September 2010, Mr Finn was fined a total of $7,004.98 as a result of the issue of expiation notices for vehicle offences and convictions of three offences involving the provision of false information. On 20 May 2011, the Magistrates Court made an order pursuant to section 70I of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) (“the Act”) revoking Mr Finn’s liability to pay the fines and ordering instead that he perform 320 hours of community service within 18 months. On 16 June 2011, Mr Finn was required by his community correction officer to attend for community service at the local work base each Thursday commencing on 30 June 2011. On 21 September 2011, the community correction officer lodged at the Elizabeth Magistrates Court a Report of Apparent Non-compliance. The alleged non-compliance comprised the failure by Mr Finn to attend for community service on six occasions, namely 30 June, 7 July, 14 July, 21 July, 4 August and 11 August 2011. On 12 January 2012, the Elizabeth Magistrates Court issued a warrant for Mr Finn’s arrest[2] and he appeared before the Court on 17 January 2012. The matter was adjourned to 28 February 2012 for him to obtain legal advice. [2] Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) s 71(3)(b). On 28 February 2012, Mr Finn sought a further adjournment to obtain legal advice. The Magistrate made an order pursuant to section 71(5) that he be imprisoned for 40 days by reason of his failure to comply with the 20 May 2011 order. On 16 March 2012, Mr Finn appealed. On 20 March 2012, having served 21 days imprisonment, he was granted bail pending the hearing and determination of the appeal.The hearing before the Magistrate There is no transcript of the hearing. I received without opposition two affidavits of Mr Finn and one affidavit of the correctional services courts unit officer who appeared on behalf of the Department. Neither deponent was cross‑examined. Based upon the affidavits, the following occurred during the hearing:1.Mr Finn informed the Magistrate that he was seeking an adjournment to apply for legal aid. He said that his application for legal aid had not been processed because he had not provided sufficient information about his finances.2.The Magistrate asked Mr Finn about the community service. Mr Finn said that he had not undertaken it because he had obtained full-time employment not long after the order had been made.3.The Magistrate asked the prosecuting officer to confirm that the full hours were outstanding and she did so.4.The Magistrate asked the prosecuting officer about the reason why Mr Finn had not attended to perform community service. She confirmed that it was because of employment. She added that Mr Finn had not provided evidence of his employment to his community correction officer despite being asked for it. 5.The Magistrate asked the prosecuting officer to confirm that the community service order had been imposed in relation to fines and she did so.6.Mr Finn told the Magistrate that, at the time of the breach, he could not do the community service because he was working six days a week. He said that he had since lost his job, that he had no income and could not pay the fines, but that he could now do the community service.7.The Magistrate proceeded to deliver an ex tempore judgment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that, however her reasons are construed, the Magistrate erred in concluding that Mr Finn should not be excused pursuant to subsection 71(7). Conclusion Because the hearing miscarried, and in any event the Magistrate’s reasoning on excusal was flawed, the appeal must be allowed and the Magistrate’s order set aside.Rehearing Both parties on appeal accepted that, if the order of the Magistrate is set aside, I have power to determine myself the section 71 application rather than remitting it to the Magistrates Court for rehearing. In circumstances in which Mr Finn has now served 21 of the 40 days imprisonment imposed by the Magistrate’s order, and given the further delay which would be occasioned by a rehearing in the Magistrates Court and any subsequent appeal, it is preferable that I proceed to hear and determine the section 71 application myself. For the purpose of that hearing, Mr Finn gave oral evidence before me and tendered a number of documents. He was cross‑examined by the Department, which also tendered documents. The evidence establishes the following facts.1.Mr Finn commenced employment with a transport operator on 21 July 2011 and continued in that employment until 1 November 2011.2.It was a term of Mr Finn’s employment that he report for work on Monday to Saturday and that he proceed to work on those days unless not required. 3. Over the course of his employment, Mr Finn usually did work six days a week. On six or seven weekdays and two or three Saturdays, he reported to work and was told that he could go home due to inclement weather or other reasons.4.Mr Finn’s employment prevented his attending for community service on the last three of the occasions charged, namely 21 July, 4 August and 11 August 2011.5.The reason why Mr Finn did not attend for community service on 14 July 2011 was that he was sick. His wife telephoned the Department on that day to inform it that he was sick. This is corroborated by the Department’s records, although they record “GF”, being presumably Mr Finn, rather than his wife making the phone call.6.The reason why Mr Finn did not attend for community service on the first or second occasion (probably 7 July) was that he was being interviewed by his prospective employer for the employment which he subsequently obtained.7.Mr Finn does not recall the reason why he did not attend for community service on the remaining occasion charged (probably 30 June). Mr Finn contends that there are proper grounds on which his failure to comply with the community service order should be excused. He found his imprisonment for 21 days a sobering experience. He wishes to undertake and complete community service instead of completing the term of imprisonment imposed by the Magistrate.Proper grounds for excusal The first question is whether, on the evidence before me, there are “proper grounds on which the failure should be excused” within the meaning of subsection 71(7) of the Act. The relevant provisions of section 71 are as follows:71—Community service orders may be enforced by imprisonment(1)Subject to this section, an order of a court or authorised officer requiring performance of community service is enforceable by imprisonment in default of compliance.(2)The term of imprisonment to be served in default of compliance will be—(a)a term calculated on the basis of one day for each eight hours of community service remaining to be performed under the order; or(b)six months,whichever is lesser.…(5)If the court is satisfied that the person has failed to comply with the order requiring performance of community service—(a) the court may issue a warrant of commitment for the appropriate term of imprisonment fixed in accordance with subs (2); ……(7)Despite subsection (5), if the court is satisfied that the failure of a person to comply with an order requiring performance of community service was trivial or that there are proper grounds on which the failure should be excused, the court—(a) may refrain from issuing a warrant of commitment; and(b) may—(i)extend the term of the order by such period, not exceeding six months, as the court thinks necessary for the purpose of enabling the person to perform the remaining hours of community service (if any);(ii)if the order has expired, impose a further order, for a term not exceeding six months, requiring the person to perform the number of hours of community service unperformed under the previous order;(iii)cancel the whole or a number of the unperformed hours of community service under the order.(8)However, if the court is satisfied that the person's failure to comply with the order is excusable on the ground of the person's obligations to remunerated employment gained since the making of the order, and that the person has the means to pay a fine without the person or his or her dependants suffering hardship, the court may—(a) revoke the community service order; and(b) impose a fine not exceeding the maximum fine that may be imposed for the offence in respect of which the community service order was made (or, if the order was made in respect of more than one offence—the total of the maximum fines that may be imposed for the offences).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.