Finlay Stonemasonry Pty Ltd v JD & Sons Nominees Pty Ltd
[2011] NTSC 37
PARTIES:FINLAY STONEMASONRY PTY LTD
v
JD & SONS NOMINEES PTY LTD FOR THE JENKINS FAMILY TRUST No 2
TITLE OF COURT: SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
JURISDICTION: SUPREME COURT OF THE TERRITORY EXERCISING ORIGINAL JURISDICTION
FILE NO:No. 108 of 2010 (21032664)
DELIVERED: 18 May 2011
HEARING DATES: 2, 3 March 2011
JUDGMENT OF: BLOKLAND J
CATCHWORDS:
PLANNING ACT – Plaintiff seeks a declaration that a registered lease is void – Plaintiff claims lease void on grounds of purported sub-division – transaction that purports to sub-divide land in contravention of Part 5 of the Act is void – land may be sub-divided only with consent subject to the relevant provisions of the Planning Scheme – Does the lease effect sub-division – lease falls under s 5(3)(b) exception – lease does not effect sub-division – claim dismissed – application as to costs.
Planning Act (NT) ss 2A(1), 2A(2)(a)-(e), 3, 5(1), 5(3), 5(4), 44(b), 46, 47A, 47A(a), 62(1)(a), 63(2)
Licensed Surveyors Act (NT) s 49(3)
The Conveyancing Act (NSW)
Valuation of Land Act 1916 (NSW)
Local Government Act (NSW)
Interpretation Act (NT) s 17(1)
Auctioneers, Real Estate Agents (etc) Act (Qld)
Property Law Act (NSW) [1900] NSWR 570
Butt, Land Law, 6th Edition, (2010) Law Book Co.
MacDonald, McCrimmon, Wallace, Weir, Real Property Law in Queensland, 3rd Edition, (2010), Law Book Co.Bradbrook, “The relevance of the cujuis est solum doctrine to the surface land owners claims to natural resources located above and beneath the land”, (1988) 11 Adel LR 462.
Butt, “The Conveyancer” (1978) ALJ 161.
Butt, “Conveyancing and Property” conveyancing practice and the law: leases and subdivisions”, (2002) 76 ALJ 346.
Butt, “How Far Down Do You Own? The Final Word?” (2010) 84 ALJ 746.
Hardy v Wardy [2001] NSW SC 180; distinguished
Bernstein of Leigh (Baron) v Skyviews and General Ltd [1977] 3 WLR 136;
Bocardo SA v Star Energy Onshore Ltd [2009] 3 WLR 1010; Bocardo SA v Star Energy Onshore Ltd and another [2010] 3 WLR 654 Supreme Court (UK); Byrnes v Jokona [2002] FCA 41; Commissioner for Railways and Others v Valuer-General [1974] AC 328; Pacific Carriers Ltd v BNP Paribas (2004) 218 CLR 416; Re Lehrer [1961] SR (NSW) 365; Re Trizec Manitoba (1986) 25 DLR (4th) 444; The Centre Pty Ltd v Thomas Magnus Pty Ltd (1969) Qd R 452; Toll (FGCT) P/L v Alpharpharm (2004) 219 CLR 165; referred to
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Plaintiff:A. Wyvill SC
Defendant:M. Maurice QC
Solicitors:
Plaintiff:Hunt and Hunt
Defendant:Cridlands MB
Judgment category classification: B
Judgment ID Number: BLO 1104
Number of pages: 41
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWINFinlay Stonemasonry Pty Ltd v JD Sons Nominees Pty Ltd
[2011] NTSC 37
No. 108 of 2010 (21032664)
BETWEEN:
Finlay Stonemasonry Pty Ltd
Plaintiff
AND:
JD & Sons Nominees Pty Ltd for the
Jenkins Family Trust No. 2
Defendant
CORAM:…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Finlay Stonemasonry Pty Ltd v JD & Sons Nominees Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NTSC 37
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the lease did not effect a sub-division of the land. The lease referred to "land" in terms of the area leased but did not include the soil beneath. The court noted that the lease did not contravene or violate any part of the Planning Act or the relevant parts of the Northern Territory Planning Scheme. The court also found that the lease fell under the exception provided in s 5(3)(b) of the Act, which exempts certain transactions from the requirement for consent for sub-division. Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiff's claim for a declaration that the lease was void. The court also dismissed the plaintiff's application as to costs.
In conclusion, the court found that the lease in question did not effect a sub-division of land in contravention of the Planning Act. The court also found that the lease fell under the exception provided in s 5(3)(b) of the Act, which exempts certain transactions from the requirement for consent for sub-division. The court dismissed the plaintiff's claim for a declaration that the lease was void and also dismissed the plaintiff's application as to costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The lease in question, specifically Exhibit 1, referred to "that part of the land as hatched on the attached plan" as the Interest Being Leased. The plan annexed to the lease depicted a grey shaded area, which was understood to represent the area leased. The lease also referred to "Land" in its terms. The Plaintiff’s Senior Counsel provided a detailed construction of the relevant parts of the Planning Act (NT), arguing that the lease should be void because it contravened the Act's requirement for sub-division consent. However, the Court noted that it could not conclude from the evidence whether the leased premises were the type of interest targeted by the Planning Act (NT).
The Plaintiff provided further evidence through Mr Thomas David Finlay's affidavit, which detailed the construction of a rectangular shed on a portion of the land in October/November 2005. The shed, a one-level structure, was divided into two sections by a dividing wall and had a veranda around the perimeter. Although this evidence provided context on the nature and description of the demised premises, it did not conclusively determine the ultimate issue of whether the lease constituted an unauthorised sub-division. The Defendant argued that the lease fell under the exception in s 5(3)(b) of the Planning Act (NT), suggesting that the lease did not effect sub-division. This contention was central to the legal dispute before the Court.
Finlay Stonemasonry Pty Ltd v JD & Sons Nominees Pty Ltd came before the court as an appeal from a decision made by the Northern Territory Magistrates Court. The Plaintiff sought a declaration that a registered lease was void, arguing that the lease purportedly sub-divided the land in contravention of Part 5 of the Planning Act (NT). The case was initially heard in the Magistrates Court where the Plaintiff’s claim was dismissed. Dissatisfied with this outcome, the Plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory. The procedural journey leading to the final hearing involved several key steps, including the filing of appeals, submission of affidavits and plans, and a review of the lease terms and the land’s structural relationship with the adjoining property. The court examined the lease document, including a hand-written correction and the attached plan, to interpret the area leased and its implications under the Planning Act (NT). The Plaintiff also presented an affidavit from Mr. Thomas David Finlay, which provided insights into the nature and description of the demised premises. The court’s task was to determine whether the lease constituted a sub-division contrary to the Act, focusing on the interpretation of the lease terms and the area depicted on the attached plan.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the lease effect a sub-division of the land within the meaning of the Planning Act (NT)?
2. Does the lease fall under the exception in s 5(3)(b) of the Planning Act (NT)?
3. Does the lease contravene or otherwise violate any part of the Planning Act (NT) or the relevant parts of the Northern Territory Planning Scheme?
4. Can the court draw ultimate conclusions from the evidence presented regarding the nature and use of the demised premises?
5. What is the extent of the area leased, and does the lease include the soil beneath the premises?
Held
1. The court concluded that the lease does not effect a sub-division of the land within the meaning of the Planning Act (NT), and thus the lease does not contravene this aspect of the Act.
2. The court held that the lease falls under the exception in s 5(3)(b) of the Planning Act (NT), as it is a registered lease and therefore exempt from the sub-division provisions.
3. The court found that the lease does not contravene or otherwise violate any part of the Planning Act (NT) or the relevant parts of the Northern Territory Planning Scheme.
4. The court concluded that it cannot draw ultimate conclusions from the evidence presented regarding the nature and use of the demised premises.
5. The court determined the extent of the area leased by construing the terms of the lease, finding that the grey shaded portion on the plan annexed to the lease represents the area leased. However, the court found it necessary to interpret whether the soil beneath the premises is included in the lease.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Finlay Stonemasonry Pty Ltd v JD & Sons Nominees Pty Ltd, the court addressed whether the lease in question effected a sub-division of land within the meaning of the Planning Act (NT). The court agreed with the plaintiff's construction of the relevant parts of the Planning Act (NT), but disagreed with the plaintiff's narrow interpretation of the exception in s 5(3)(b) of the Act. The court noted that nothing in the lease or the structure of the premises appeared to contravene or violate any part of the Planning Act (NT) or the Northern Territory Planning Scheme, except for the reference to "land" in the lease.
The court also considered whether the lease fell under the exception in s 5(3)(b) of the Planning Act (NT). The court found that the lease did fall under this exception, which exempts certain transactions from the definition of sub-division. The court held that the lease did not effect a sub-division of the land, and therefore the claim for a declaration of invalidity was dismissed.
In addition, the court considered whether the lease contravened or violated any part of the Planning Act (NT) or the Northern Territory Planning Scheme. The court found that there was nothing in the lease or the structure of the premises that appeared to contravene or violate any part of the Act or the Scheme, except for the reference to "land" in the lease.
The court also considered whether it could draw ultimate conclusions from the evidence presented regarding the nature and use of the demised premises. The court found that it could not draw ultimate conclusions from the evidence presented, but noted that the lease must and does speak for itself. The court proceeded on the basis that the grey shaded portion on the plan annexed to the lease represented the area leased, but noted that this did not answer the ultimate question of whether the soil beneath was included.
Finally, the court considered the extent of the area leased and whether the lease included the soil beneath the premises. The court found that the extent of the area leased was to be determined by construing the terms of the lease, and that evidence was led bearing on the nature of the demised premises, its uses, dimensions, and structural relationship with the adjoining part of the building and the land beneath. The court noted that there was still room for a degree of interpretation on some elements of what was actually included in the lease.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a lease that falls under the exception in s 5(3)(b) of the Planning Act (NT) does not effect a sub-division of the land, and therefore does not contravene or violate any part of the Act or the Northern Territory Planning Scheme. The court distinguished the narrow interpretation of the exception suggested by the plaintiff, and held that the lease did not contravene or violate any part of the Act or the Scheme, except for the reference to "land" in the lease. The court also held that it could not draw ultimate conclusions from the evidence presented regarding the nature and use of the demised premises, and that the extent of the area leased and whether the lease included the soil beneath the premises were to be determined by construing the terms of the lease.