| BE'L'!:EEt: | : | ........ ........ ........ | MALCOLTI JOHN FII\'GZI' | .-.?. | .... |
| ........ ........ ........ ....... | Inf | orrnant |
........ ........ ........ .....
| n | P! ZI | ........ ........ ........ ........ . | MALUA MOTORS PTY LTD |
I
| ........ ........ ........ ........ | Defendant |
........ ........ ........ ......
ST.JOHN J.
6 March, 1978
Sydney
. '
TfIP: cGIJT3' oi?3!??'s TIYhT:
3 . The deferclant company is convlcted.
| 2. |
| ||
| |||
| 3' | TF.e defenGant company is to pay the informant's costs. |
TRADE PRACTICES ACT 1974 SECTTOI\F 79 and 5 3 ( :
MALCOLM JOHN FIFGER
( I n f o r m a t )
I
and
!
!
MALUA IiIOTORS PTY. LITIITED
(Defendant)
| REASONS FOR JUDG:.ENT : | ST. JOHN J . |
| DELIVERED: | 6 March 1978. | |||
|
| has p l eaded gu i l t y t o | two | charges under section | 53(a) | o f | t h e |
| *Trade Practices Act 1974. | Both | these | chzrges | re la te | to | a |
| misleading statement | made | I n r e s p e c t | o f | an odometer reading | on | a |
. *
| Mazda | motor vehicle. |
| The | f irst | cha rge r e l e t e s t o s imp ly d i sp l aymg |
| the odometer x i t h an incor rec t | read lng; | and | the | second | charge |
| r e l a t e s t o | a | r ep resen ta t lon i n wr i t l ng | made | by | t h e manager | o€ | t h e |
| defendant | company | t o an o f f i ce r | o f | the Trade Tractices | Com;nlsslon. |
| On | 3 | August '1976 the off icer vis i ted the |
| showroom premlses | o f J o k Palmer Motors | s i t u a t e d a t | 84-86 |
| Parramatta Road, Summer H i l l . | Hc there | inspec ted | a PIazda motor |
| ca r | on | d isp lay f o r sa le bear ing | a | New | South Wales | r e g i s t r a t i o n |
| p l a t e HI10 | G33 and having | a cer ta in engine | number. |
| /' | 2. |
9 /'
| I | He | looked a t t h e odometer reading of. | t he moto r |
| 1'' | vehicle and notlced | it | was | 32,000 | kilometres approxlmately. |
.
| He then had | a | conversat ion with | t h e manager o'f | t he bus iness , |
a M r . Mervyn J. Pau l l , who assured him t h a t i L; was a
| guaranteed 32,000 ki lometres . | The manager subsequently |
| produced | a | business card | on which he wrote, | Wazda | 808 Deluxe, |
| 32,000 kilometres , $3490." | He gave this card t o t h e 1nIormzmt |
| o f f i c e r . |
| Subsequent | inquir |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Finger, Malcolm John v Malua Motors Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1978] FCA 9
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether Malua Motors Pty Ltd had committed the offences as charged and, if so, what penalty should be imposed. The court considered whether the misleading representation was deliberate and whether the lack of harm to the public should mitigate the penalty. The court found that the offences were deliberate and not due to any mistake or inadvertence. It also held that the fact that the misleading statement was made by the manager of the business, rather than a lower-level employee, warranted a higher penalty.
The court ordered Malua Motors Pty Ltd to pay a penalty of $8,000 for each offence and to cover the informant's costs. The court considered the deliberate nature of the offences and the previous instances of odometer alterations that had been before the court. The court also took into account that it was the manager of the business who made the misleading statement, rather than a lower-level employee. The court found that the appropriate penalty in the circumstances was $8,000 on each offence.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi