Fine Meats (Boners PM) Pty Ltd v Hart

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Fine Meats (Boners PM) Pty Ltd v Hart [2007] NSWWCCPD 164

APPELLANT:  Fine Meats (Boners PM) Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT:  Dean Hart

INSURER:CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited

FILE NUMBER:  WCC15518-06

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          2 March 2007

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  31 July 2007

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Leave to appeal; preliminary or interim orders of an interlocutory nature; section 352(8) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998; meaning of “relevant medical specialty” in the WorkCover Guides for the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Deputy President Bill Roche

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Moray & Agney

Respondent:   Galland Elder Lulham

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  Leave to appeal the Arbitrator’s determination dated 2 March 2007 is refused.

The Appellant Employer is to pay the Respondent Worker’s costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. On 8 September 2005 Dean Hart (‘the Respondent Worker/Mr Hart’) suffered injury to his right foot, knee and lower back when a pallet jack ran over his foot. By letter dated 30 June 2006 Mr Hart’s solicitors claimed compensation under section 66 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’) in respect of 16% whole person impairment together with compensation for pain and suffering under section 67. The claim was supported by a report from Dr Lawson, consultant physician, dated 16 June 2006.

  1. By letter dated 13 September 2006 CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited (‘CGU’) declined to make any offer of settlement on the basis of a report from Dr Panjratan dated 3 April 2006 which assessed Mr Hart to have no entitlement to “any impairment” because he had a normal range of movement in his injured ankle.

  1. In Mr Hart’s Application to Resolve a Dispute (‘the Application’), registered in the Commission on 3 October 2006, he claimed lump sum compensation as per the particulars provided on 30 June 2006.  By its Reply filed on 9 November 2006 Fine Meats (Boners PM) Pty Ltd (‘the Appellant Employer’) disputed the extent of Mr Hart’s whole person impairment and alleged that the claim was not maintainable because it had not been “duly made by serving a medical report from a WorkCover trained assessor of permanent impairment in the relevant area of specialty”.  Essentially, the issue in dispute was whether Mr Hart’s claim had been duly made in light of the fact that his injuries consisted of fractures and Dr Lawson is a physician and not an orthopaedic surgeon or a general surgeon.

  1. The matter was listed for teleconference before a Commission Arbitrator on 12 December 2006 when the parties were directed to provide written submissions on the issue of whether Dr Lawson was appropriately qualified.  The Appellant Employer filed its submissions on 3 January 2007 and the Respondent Worker filed his on 22 January 2007.

  1. In a Statement of Reasons for Decision (‘Reasons’) dated 2 March 2007 the Arbitrator rejected the Appellant Employer’s argument and issued a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fine Meats (Boners PM) Pty Ltd v Hart and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWWCCPD 164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fine Meats (Boners PM) Pty Ltd sought leave to appeal a determination of an Arbitrator that Dean Hart's claim for workers' compensation was properly made. The Arbitrator determined that the Commission had jurisdiction to assess the claim, rejecting the employer's argument that the claim was not duly made as it was not supported by a medical report from a specialist orthopaedic surgeon or general surgeon. The employer argued that the claim was not properly made as the assessing doctor was a physician, not a specialist surgeon. The employer also argued that the Arbitrator's reasons were inadequate.

The court refused the employer leave to appeal, holding that the Arbitrator's determination was not a 'decision' under the relevant legislation as it was interlocutory and did not finally dispose of any rights. The court also held that the claim was properly made as the assessing doctor was suitably qualified and experienced to assess the worker's whole person impairment in accordance with the relevant guidelines. The court held that the purpose of the guidelines was to ensure an objective, fair and consistent method for evaluating permanent impairment, and the assessing doctor was well placed to provide an assessment in accordance with the guidelines. The court held that to accept the employer's argument would be contrary to good conscience and the substantial merits of the case.

The court also held that the Arbitrator's reasons were sufficient, noting that while it would have been more helpful if he had expressly stated that the claim was duly made and that the Commission has jurisdiction to allow the claim to proceed to assessment by an approved medical specialist, the basis for his decision was stated. The employer is ordered to pay the worker's costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 8 September 2005, Dean Hart (Mr Hart) suffered injuries to his right foot, knee, and lower back when a pallet jack ran over his foot. Mr Hart claimed compensation under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 for 16% whole person impairment and compensation for pain and suffering. The claim was supported by a report from Dr Lawson, a consultant physician. Fine Meats (Boners PM) Pty Ltd (the Appellant Employer) disputed the extent of Mr Hart's whole person impairment and argued that the claim was not maintainable because it was not supported by a report from a WorkCover trained assessor of permanent impairment in the relevant medical specialty. The Arbitrator issued a determination referring Mr Hart to an Approved Medical Specialist. The Appellant Employer filed an appeal against the Arbitrator's determination, seeking leave to appeal.

Mr Hart filed a claim for compensation with the Workers Compensation Commission on 3 October 2006. The Appellant Employer disputed the claim on 9 November 2006. The matter was listed for teleconference before a Commission Arbitrator on 12 December 2006. The Arbitrator issued a determination on 2 March 2007, which the Appellant Employer appealed. The appeal was heard on the papers, and the Deputy President issued a decision on 31 July 2007.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Arbitrator erred in agreeing with Mr Hart's submissions that it was not necessary for Dr Lawson to be a specialist general surgeon or orthopaedic surgeon in order to give an assessment of whole person impairment under the legislation.
2. Whether the Arbitrator failed to give adequate reasons for his determination.
3. Whether the appeal concerns a matter of an interlocutory nature and, if so, whether leave to appeal can be granted.

Held
1. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in finding that it was not necessary for Dr Lawson to be a specialist general surgeon or orthopaedic surgeon in order to give an assessment of whole person impairment under the legislation. The Respondent Worker's claim was duly made and the matter is properly before the Commission.
2. The court held that the Arbitrator's reasons were adequate, though it would have been more helpful if he had expressly stated that accepting the Respondent Worker's submissions meant the claim was duly made and that the Commission has jurisdiction to allow the claim to proceed to assessment by an AMS.
3. The court held that the appeal concerns a matter of an interlocutory nature and therefore refused leave to appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the Arbitrator erred in his determination that Dr Lawson was qualified to assess Mr Hart's whole person impairment. The WorkCover Guides for the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment required assessments to be made by "a registered medical practitioner with qualifications in the relevant medical specialty." The Appellant argued that only a general surgeon or orthopaedic surgeon could assess Mr Hart's injuries. However, the court found that the Guides did not dictate a particular specialty and that Dr Lawson, as a physician with extensive experience in work and occupational health and injury, was suitably qualified to provide the assessment. The court also found that the Arbitrator's reasons were adequate, though more explicit findings would have been helpful.

The court further considered whether the appeal was interlocutory in nature, which would preclude leave to appeal. The Regulations prescribed interlocutory orders, including the Arbitrator's order to refer the claim for assessment by an AMS. As the order did not finally dispose of any rights, it was interlocutory and leave to appeal was refused. The distinction between final and interlocutory orders focuses on the legal effect of the order rather than its practical consequences. Since the Arbitrator's order did not finally resolve the claim, it was interlocutory and leave to appeal was properly refused.