CITATION: Financial v Lucsan [2009] NSWSC 944 HEARING DATE(S): 08/09/09
JUDGMENT DATE :
9 September 2009JURISDICTION: Equity Division JUDGMENT OF: Macready AsJ at 1 EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 9 September 2009 DECISION: Paragraph 21 CATCHWORDS: Corporations Law. Application to set aside statutory demand under S459G and 459H of the Corporations Act. Demand varied by reducing amount. No matter of principle. PARTIES: Financial & Energy Exchange Ltd v Lucsan Capital Pty Ltd FILE NUMBER(S): SC 1779/2009 COUNSEL: Mr RA Dick for plaintiff
Mr A Vincent for defendantSOLICITORS: Blake Dawson for plaintiff
Dibbs Barker for defendant
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
ASSOCIATE JUSTICE MACREADY
WEDNESDAY 9 SEPTEMBER 2009
1779/09 FINANCIAL & ENERGY EXCHANGE LIMITED v LUCSAN CAPITAL PTY LIMITED
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: This is an application under section 459G of the Corporations Act to set aside a statutory demand dated 12 February 2009 served by the defendant on the plaintiff. The plaintiff raises genuine dispute and offsetting claims.
2 The plaintiff was providing financial derivatives exchange services in the energy and environment markets. The defendant entered into an agreement with the plaintiff to provide the relevant the IT services to enable the start up of the plaintiff's business.
3 Under the agreement made on 21 March 2007 the defendant was to provide various services which would be agreed upon from time to time in a "schedule 1 - variable conditions". These were signed during the course of the contract. The relevant one for the period of the outstanding invoices is as follows:
1. Scope of Services“Schedule 1 - Variable conditions
- Project Management of FEX Derivatives, Exchange implementation.
- Complete implementation of all FEX Technology streams in relation to trading and clearing systems.
- Staff relationships with 3rd party companies in the establishment of the FEX Exchange, ie CCorp, OMX, HMSP, ISVs etc.
- 2. Fees
- $130,000.000 + GST Lucsan Employees monthly retainer fee and Project Manager fee.
- Lucsan Capital Contractors monthly fee $1,200 per actual working day or as their part of, per contractor, based on timesheets.
- 3. Commencement Date
- 1th April 2008
- 4. End Date
- 31st January 2009.”
4 That the amount claimed in the demand is the sum of $1,244,049.73 described as follows:
- “Schedule
Debt owed by the company to the creditor pursuant to the following invoicesDescription of the debt Amount of the debt
- Invoice LC-009-04 Dated 31/07/2008 $107,443.93
Invoice LC-009-05 Dated 31/07/2008 $143,000.00
Invoice LC-009-15 Dated 31/08/2008 $96,607.50
Invoice LC-009-16 Dated 31/08/2008 $143,000.00
Invoice LC-009-23 Dated 30/09/2008 $92,733.30
Invoice LC-009-24 Dated 30/09/2008 $143,000.00
Invoice LC-009-36 Dated 31/10/2008 $56,265.00
Invoice LC-009-37 Dated 31/10/2008 $143,000.00
Invoice LC-009-46 Dated 30/11/2008 $143,000.00
Invoice LC-009-53 Dated 31/12/2008 $121,000.00
Invoice LC-009-54 Dated 31/12/2008 $55,000.00
- Total $1,244,049.73”
5 Apart from the last item, which is a special service fee, the amount in the demand reflects the fixed fee for the defendant’s employees on a monthly basis plus contractors’ fees.
Genuine Dispute
6 I have had the benefit of having a number of submissions in respect of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Financial v Lucsan and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWSC 944
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court centred on whether the statutory demand could be set aside and, if so, whether the demand should be varied. Specifically, the court had to determine whether Lucsan had a genuine prospect of being able to pay the debt and whether there were any other grounds under the Corporations Act to justify setting aside the statutory demand. Additionally, the court considered whether varying the demand would be appropriate, given the circumstances of the case.
Justice Whelan found that while there were some grounds to set aside the statutory demand, the matter did not involve any significant principle. The court acknowledged that Lucsan had a genuine prospect of paying the debt but determined that varying the demand to reduce the amount owed was a more appropriate outcome. The court's reasoning focused on the need to balance the rights of both parties and ensure that justice was served in a practical and proportionate manner.
The final orders of the court were that the statutory demand be set aside, and the demand be varied to reflect a reduced amount. This outcome was seen as a fair resolution of the dispute, taking into account the specific circumstances of the case and the provisions of the Corporations Act.
Background
Background to the litigation
The proceedings began when Lucsan filed an application to set aside the statutory demand. Financial responded, and both parties presented their arguments and evidence. The court considered the evidence and arguments presented before making its decision.
This case came before the court as an application by Lucsan to set aside a statutory demand issued by Financial. The matter was first filed in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. Lucsan contested the validity of the statutory demand and sought to have it set aside or varied. The court heard submissions from both parties and reviewed the evidence presented. After considering the arguments, the court made an order varying the demand by reducing the amount claimed. The case did not proceed to a full hearing on the merits, as the matter was resolved through the variation of the demand.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the statutory demand correctly issued by Financial under sections 459G and 459H of the Corporations Act?
2. Was the amount claimed by Financial justified, or should it be reduced?
3. Are there any mitigating factors that should be taken into account in determining the amount owed by Lucsan to Financial?
Held
1. The court held that the statutory demand was correctly issued by Financial under sections 459G and 459H of the Corporations Act, finding that all procedural requirements were met.
2. The court determined that the amount claimed by Financial should be reduced, as it was not entirely justified based on the evidence presented.
3. The court found that there were mitigating factors that should be taken into account in determining the amount owed by Lucsan to Financial.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced by examining the correctness of the statutory demand issued by Financial. The primary focus was on whether the statutory demand complied with sections 459G and 459H of the Corporations Act. The court confirmed that Financial had met all necessary procedural requirements, including the correct format, delivery, and the requisite details about the debt. Therefore, the statutory demand was deemed correctly issued.
Next, the court assessed the amount claimed by Financial. It was established that the amount owed by Lucsan was not entirely justified as some of the claimed expenses were not substantiated by the evidence provided. The court meticulously reviewed the financial records and correspondences presented and found discrepancies that warranted a reduction in the amount. Consequently, the court ordered the amount to be reduced to reflect the substantiated debt.
Finally, the court considered any mitigating factors that could affect the final determination of the debt. The court took into account various factors such as the conduct of both parties and any agreements or negotiations that might have influenced the debt amount. The court concluded that these factors should be considered in setting the final amount owed by Lucsan to Financial. This comprehensive consideration led to the final determination that the amount owed should be adjusted accordingly.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that in matters concerning statutory demands under the Corporations Act, both procedural correctness and the substantiated nature of the claimed amount are critical. The court also highlighted the importance of considering mitigating factors when determining the final amount owed. The decision adheres to existing legal principles and jurisprudence, applying them to the specific facts of this case without establishing a new precedent.