|
New South Wales |
Case Name: | FHO v Commissioner of Victims Rights |
Medium Neutral Citation: | [2022] NSWCATAD 268 |
Hearing Date(s): | 29 July 2022 |
Date of Orders: | 16 August 2022 |
Decision Date: | 16 August 2022 |
Jurisdiction: | Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division |
Before: | M Riordan, Senior Member |
Decision: | (1) I extend the time for filing the application for administrative review to the date it was filed. |
Catchwords: | ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – merits review - Victims Rights and Support - Whether act of violence established on the balance of probabilities – time limits for applying for victims support |
Legislation Cited: | Administrative Decisions Review Act 1997 (NSW) |
Cases Cited: | DSK v Commissioner of Victims Rights [2019] NSWCATAD 170 |
Texts Cited: | None |
Category: | Principal judgment |
Parties: | FHO (Applicant) |
Representation: | Solicitors: |
File Number(s): | 2022/00047237 |
Publication Restriction: | Section 64 (1) Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 – Restriction on publication of information that will identify any victims or evidence given and received in this Tribunal hearing or in relation to the proceedings which is likely to identify those persons. |
REASONS FOR DECISION
Background
These proceedings relate to a claim for victims support and a recognition payment lodged by the applicant known by the pseudonym FHO initially before the Commissioner for Victims Rights (the Respondent).
The application was lodged under the provisions of the Victims Rights and Support Act 2013 (NSW) (the Act) on 23 March 2015, and alleged that FHO was the primary victim of assault, sexual assault, Robbery and Home Invasion and that he suffered both physical and psychological injuries as a result. However, he did not indicate the date of the alleged act(s) of violence.
FHO stated that he reported the acts of violence to Police.
Decision at first instance
On 4 December 2019, an Assessor (Client Claims) issued a Notice of Decision, which determined that an act of violence was not established on the balance of probabilities and dismissed the application. The Assessor stated, relevantly:
4. According to the application form, (FHO) was the victim of assault committed by an alleged offender. The violence occurred between 1 January 2008 and 16 November 2009, at Matraville in New South Wales.
5. (FHO) describes the act of violence as follows:
Being intimidated, assaulted by a number of males.
6. (FHO) has indicated he suffered by physical and psychological injuries as a result.
7. the matter…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fho v Commissioner of Victims Rights and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NSWCATAD 268
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central issue before the court was whether the alleged acts of violence occurred during the period claimed by FHO. The court also had to determine whether FHO was out of time to apply for victims support, and whether the court had the power to extend the time limit for making an application for victims support. The court found that the alleged acts of violence did not occur during the period claimed by FHO, and that FHO was out of time to apply for victims support. The court also found that it did not have the power to extend the time limit for making an application for victims support.
The court found that the alleged acts of violence did not occur during the period claimed by FHO. The court accepted that FHO believed that he was the victim of the sexual violence that he described to the counsellor/psychologist during the period from 31 December 2007 and 30 May 2010. However, the court did not feel a sense of persuasion that the alleged sexual violence occurred. The court found that the counsellor/psychologist’s opinion that the events described by FHO were “delusional” and a “hallucination” was supported by the absence of any contemporaneous corroborating evidence. The court found that FHO was out of time to apply for victims support because his application was lodged on 1 April 2015. The court found that it did not have the power to extend the time limit for making an application for victims support.
The court affirmed the decision of the Commissioner of Victims Rights dated 11 March 2020. The court extended the time for filing the application for administrative review to the date it was filed. The court found that FHO was not eligible for victims support with respect to any physical injuries allegedly suffered during the period from 31 December 2007 to 30 May 2010 because his application was lodged out of time.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) I extend the time for filing the application for administrative review to the date it was filed.
(2) FHO is not eligible for victims support with respect to any physical injuries allegedly suffered during the period from 31 December 2007 to 30 May 2010 because his application was lodged out of time.
(3) The decision dated 11 March 2020 is affirmed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
However, as FHO applied for victims support on 1 April 2015, he was out of time to apply for victims support in respect of any physical act of violence that may have occurred during the period claimed in his application. This is because s 40(1) of the Act provides:40. Time for making, and duration of, applications(1) Except as provided by this section, an application for financial support or a recognition payment must be duly made within 2 years after the relevant act of violence occurred or, if the victim was a child when the act of violence or act of modern slavery occurred, within 2 years after the day on which the child concerned turns 18 years of age. FHO has lodged submissions and evidence that refer to alleged acts of violence that occurred after the period alleged in the application for victims support dated 1 April 2015. However, the decision that is the subject of the current application for administrative review is restricted to the acts of violence alleged during the period from 31 December 2007 and 30 May 2010. In any event, this Tribunal does not have power to extend the time for an applicant to lodge an application for victims support beyond the time limits prescribed in s 40 of the Act. In relation to the alleged sexual violence alleged by FHO during the period from 31 December 2007 to 30 May 2010, I note that the extensive police COPS event records do not indicate any report of sexual violence. There are also no contemporaneous medical records before me that corroborate FHO’s allegations. Further, it appears that the first report of any sexual violence is found in the counselling report dated 12 April 2016. I note that the counsellor/psychologist took a florid history of the events alleged by FHO as occurring approximately 6.5 to 7 years previously, including: (1) four assailants breaking into his place; (2) assaults by groups of people; (3) his escaping and running on the street completely naked; (4) his seeing a number of people in government uniforms attacking him with swords; (5) eventually, children getting into his home and humiliating him by pushing his head into a toilet and stripping his clothes, pinning him to the floor and making him masturbate. FHO also said that he identified “some moderately famous public faces” in “his crowd of assailants” and that the attacks continued through 2008 and 2009. The counsellor/psychologist opined that the events described by FHO were “delusional”, but also stated that he believes his story as “the hallucination is imprinted on his memory as any other event in his life would be.” While I accept that FHO believes that he was the victim of the sexual violence that he described to the counsellor/psychologist to during the period from 31 December 2007 and 30 May 2010, based on the opinion of the counsellor/psychologist dated 12 April 2016, that the events were delusional and a hallucination and in the absence of any contemporaneous corroborating evidence, I do not feel an actual sense of persuasion that the alleged sexual violence occurred.