FFVQ and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 1968 (2 July 2018)
Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION
File Number(s): 2016/3237 and 2017/6358
Re:FFVQ
APPLICANT
AndNational Disability Insurance Agency
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Deputy President Gary Humphries
Date:2 July 2018
Place:Canberra
The Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to stay the Agency’s plan dated 27 January 2016 in respect of the Applicant.
........................................................................
Deputy President Gary Humphries
Catchwords
National Disability Insurance Scheme – Jurisdiction – Statement of supports is not to be conflated with a plan – Plan is not a decision to which the relevant proceeding relates – Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to stay the operation of the National Disability Support Agency’s plan.
Legislation
Administrative Appeals TribunalAct 1975 s 26, 41
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 ss 33, 37, 48, 49, 99, 100, 103
Cases
SHGH and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 674
QZHH and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 1465REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President Gary Humphries
2 July 2018
INTRODUCTION
The Applicant, FFVQ, is a young woman living in Canberra. She became a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) in March 2015. Pursuant to s 37 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (the Act) three plans have been produced for her by the National Disability Insurance Agency (the NDIA or the Agency) since then.
Section 33 of the Act provides that a plan must include a Statement of Participant Supports. The supports provided for FFVQ under the second and third plans (Second Plan and Third Plan) are less than those provided under the first plan (First Plan). As a result, she applied to the Tribunal for merits review in relation to the supports provided for in the Second Plan (Matters 2016/3237 and 2017/5072) and the Third Plan (Matter 2017/6358). After hearing the parties, the Tribunal determined that it had jurisdiction to hear the applications in respect of the Second Plan (Matter 2016/3237) and the Third Plan (Matter 2017/6358), but not the other application in respect of the Second Plan (Matter 2017/5072). By consent, the Tribunal dismissed the latter application on 30 April 2018.
FFVQ has made an application to the Tribunal to stay the operation of the Second Plan until the Tribunal’s review is completed with the consequential restoration of the First Plan.[1] The application is supported by a contention that the NDIA had no power to promulgate the Third Plan, in that, by purporting to do so, it breached s 26 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act) which provides that a decision under review by the Tribunal may not be altered except with the consent of the parties and the Tribunal. Since the Third Plan could not be lawfully enacted, it was contended, the Tribunal has jurisdiction to stay the Second Plan with the effect that the First Plan – with its higher level of supports for FFVQ – would be restored to operation.
[1]…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read FFVQ and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] AATA 1968
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether a statement of supports should be conflated with the NDIS plan under which it is made, and consequently, whether the Tribunal possessed jurisdiction to review the plan itself, or to stay its operation. FFVQ argued that the potential for the Tribunal to reject a statement of supports meant that the plan and statement were intrinsically linked, making the review of a statement effectively a review of the plan. Furthermore, FFVQ contended that the NDIA's practice of issuing new plans periodically would oust the Tribunal's jurisdiction to review statements of supports, which could not have been the legislative intention.
The Tribunal found that a statement of supports is distinct from a plan promulgated under section 37 of the NDIS Act. While certain decisions concerning a participant's plan are reviewable by the Tribunal, as exhaustively listed in section 99, the decision to bring a plan into effect under section 37 is not among them, adhering to the principle of *expressio unius est exclusio alterius*. Although a plan is practically dependent on a statement of supports for its operation, this practical dependence does not grant the Tribunal jurisdiction over decisions not clearly intended by the legislature to be reviewable. The Tribunal noted that the legislative and practical separation of these concepts was recognised in *SHGH and NDIA* [2018] AATA 674, where it was held that the review concerned the decision relating to the supports provided, not the plan as a whole.
The Tribunal concluded that it lacked jurisdiction to review the NDIS plan itself or to stay its operation. The decision to make a plan under section 37 is not a reviewable decision under section 99 of the NDIS Act. Therefore, the Tribunal could not entertain an application for review of the plan as a whole, nor could it grant a stay of its operation.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
She went on to argue that the possibility the Tribunal may reject a statement of supports, as part of its function of merits review, means that the plan and its statement are linked, such that merits review of a statement becomes review of the plan under which it is made. With respect to the operation of s 26, she observed that the making by the NDIA of a new plan every 12 months or so would have the effect of ousting the Tribunal’s jurisdiction to review a statement of supports since the plan under which the statement had been promulgated would cease to be in operation. This, she argued, cannot have been the intention of the legislature.CONSIDERATION The contentions of the Agency must be supported. A statement of supports is not to be conflated with a plan promulgated under s 37. Evidently, the legislation ensures that certain decisions made in respect of a participant’s plan are reviewable by the Tribunal. Those decisions are listed exhaustively in s 99. These include a decision to approve a statement of supports (paragraph 99(d)), a decision not to review a plan (paragraph (f)) and a decision to appoint a plan nominee (paragraph (l)). It is passably clear that the architecture of the Act evinces the intention, expressio unius est exclusio alterius, that a decision to bring a participant’s plan into effect under s 37 is not a reviewable decision. It is hard to conceive of a plan having any meaningful operation without a statement of supports, which defines the quantum of assistance which a participant can expect from the NDIA during the life of that plan. But the practical dependence of one concept on the other does not permit the Tribunal to acquire jurisdiction over a category of decision-making in the absence of any clear legislative intent to that effect. FFVQ maintains that a plan without a statement of supports is no Plan at all. In a practical sense, however, it is difficult to imagine a fair-minded decision-maker – whether the CEO or the Tribunal standing in his or her shoes – leaving a plan in that unhappy state. The legislative and practical separation of the two concepts was recognised by the Tribunal in SHGH and NDIA [2018] AATA 674. There, a participant sought review of the Agency’s decision, maintaining that the level of support offered in a plan set up under s 37 did not fully fund the program required and that the plan should be for a period of 12 months rather than six. Deputy President Constance at [11] stated:In this application the decision under review is the decision to include in the plan funding for intensive therapeutic supports calculated on the basis of decreasing therapy hours over the six month period of the plan, being 4 September 2017 to 4 March 2018. The Tribunal is not conducting a review of the plan as a whole. This is made clear by the provisions of the NDIS Act. He later added at [26]:I reiterate that it is the decision relating to the supports being provided, not the Plan itself, which is under review.