QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION
CITATION: | Ferris v Woodlands H.R. Pty Ltd (No. 1) [2024] QIRC 65 |
PARTIES: | Ferris, Timothy v Woodlands H.R. Pty Ltd |
CASE NO: | B/2022/83 |
PROCEEDING: | Application in existing proceedings |
DELIVERED ON: | 20 March 2024 |
HEARING DATES: | 28 November 2023 |
MEMBER: | Pidgeon IC |
| HEARD AT: | Brisbane |
ORDERS: | 1. The application in existing proceedings to include the document marked as TF-10 is dismissed. 2. The application in existing proceedings to include the document marked as TF-11 is granted. |
| CATCHWORDS: | INDUSTRIAL LAW – QUEENSLAND AWARDS – application for unpaid wages – recovery of unpaid pro rata long service leave – where the Appellant applied to reopen the matter so as to tender two further documents – consideration of relevant principles to grant leave to a party to reopen its case – applications opposed by the Respondent – application in existing proceedings dismissed – application in existing proceedings granted |
| LEGISLATION AND OTHER INSTRUMENTS: | Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ss 132, 134(6) |
CASES: | Fowler v Workers’ Compensation Regulator [2019] QIRC 149 Wang v Workers’ Compensation Regulator (No. 2) [2023] QIRC 163 |
| APPEARANCES: | Mr D. Marr and Mr A. Santelises, The Australian Workers’ Union of Employees, Queensland (AWU) for the Applicant. Mr C. Camilleri, Woodlands H.R. Pty Ltd for the Respondent. |
Reasons for Decision
Introduction
The Australian Workers’ Union of Employees (‘the AWU’) lodged an application for recovery of pro rata long service leave on behalf of Mr Timothy Ferris on 31 October 2022. The parties were unable to settle the matter at conciliation and in May 2023, the matter was allocated to me for hearing. The parties filed written submissions and affidavit material. The matter was heard in Brisbane over two days; 28 November 2023 and 12 January 2024. Following the hearing, the parties were directed to file closing written submissions.
On Friday 2 February 2024, Mr Santelises of the AWU wrote to the Registry seeking leave to include further documents. That correspondence noted that the Respondent objected to the inclusion of further documents. During a mention of the matter on Tuesday 6 February 2024, I informed the parties that a request to lead further evidence must be made formally as an application in existing proceedings.
On 16 February 2024, the AWU filed a Form 4 Application in existing proceedings on behalf of Mr Ferris. That application sought leave to include the following further evidence for the Commission’s consideration:
a. Correspondence from Mr Camilleri and Mr Santelises dated 29 January 2024 (attached as TF-10); and
b. Payslips of Mr Timothy Ferris from Forum A Pty Ltd dated 17/10/2017, payment made on (attached TF-11)
The relevant principles regarding the discretion to grant leave to a party to reopen their case
In Wang v Workers’ Compensation Regulator (No. 2) [2023] QIRC 163 (‘Wang v Workers’ Compensation Regulator’), Merrell DP considered applications made in existing proceedings where the Appellant applied to reopen his case so as to tender further documents. In that decision, Merrell DP referred to his…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ferris v Woodlands H.R. Pty Ltd (No. 1) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] QIRC 65
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the new documents were admissible under the principles governing reopening cases and whether the Appellant could demonstrate that the evidence could not have been discovered earlier with reasonable diligence. The court had to balance the interests of justice against the potential prejudice to the Respondent if the new evidence was allowed. The Appellant argued that the new documents were material and necessary for a fair resolution of the case, while the Respondent contended that the Appellant had ample opportunity to obtain the information earlier and that allowing new evidence would cause undue delay and stress.
The court carefully reviewed the content of the proposed new evidence and compared it with the existing submissions and evidence. The court found that one of the proposed documents, an email from January 2024, did not introduce any significant new information and was consistent with previous evidence. Therefore, it did not meet the threshold for being deemed material and necessary to the interests of justice. The court also considered the stress caused to the Respondent by the proceedings but found that this factor did not outweigh the need for fairness and justice in the resolution of the case. Consequently, the court dismissed the application to include the first document but granted the application to include the second document.
In summary, the court dismissed the application to include the document marked as TF-10 but granted the application to include the document marked as TF-11.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application in existing proceedings to include the document marked as TF-10 is dismissed.
2. The application in existing proceedings to include the document marked as TF-11 is granted.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Applicant notes the stress of the Respondent but says that it is not relevant to the question and should not be given any weight. Consideration I have reviewed the material the Applicant seeks to have included. I will deal with each item in turn. The email of 29 January 2024 I note that the email exchange in question occurred on 29 January 2024. This is some two months after the Applicant’s representative informed the Commission of an intention to seek further information from the Respondent. It is also after the second day of hearing. The relevant content of the email from the Respondent is as follows: As per the testimony of Mr Benjamin Haycroft and Mr John Elks on 28th November 2023, Forum A Pty Ltd ATF Forum A Trust set the hourly rate for their staff and Woodlands HR Pty Ltd were not involved or provided with any breakdown on the entitlements included in the hourly rate paid to their staff.Please direct any further requests for this information to Mr Benjamin Haycroft. Nothing in that email offers anything new or significant to the evidence or submissions already before the Commission. The information contained in the email is consistent with the evidence given by Ms Tregenza when she was asked ‘do you have any idea how the all-up rate was worked out’ or what the breakdown was and she answered that she did not know what the breakdown was and that Forum-A worked out the rate.[6] Mr Elks’ evidence with regard to the ‘all-up rate’ was ‘…how it’s derived I can’t answer that…’.[7] [6] T1-90 l 29 (Transcript, 28 November 2023).[7] T1-69 ll 33-34 (Transcript, 28 November 2023). I have considered the matters set out by Merrell DP in Wang v Workers’ Compensation Regulator and listed above at [4]. Regarding the decision in Fowler quoted therein, I find the relevant guiding principles to be applied are specifically those set out at [41](c), (d) and (e). Having had regard to the first document, which the Applicant seeks to introduce as new evidence, I do not find that the further evidence is so material that the interests of justice require its admission. As I have discussed above at [22], the email adds nothing that is not already demonstrated by the evidence before the Commission and the Applicant will be able to make submissions about that matter. If accepted, the evidence would not be likely to affect the result of the case. Regarding the point about whether the evidence could not, by reasonable diligence, have been discovered earlier, I note that on 28 November 2023, Mr Santelises indicated a course of action which may involve seeking the type of information contained in the email. There was an opportunity to do this immediately following the hearing and in fact all the way up until the second day of the hearing in January 2024. I am satisfied that it was well within the Applicant’s capacity to ask for the information it seeks to admit prior to the end of the hearing of the matter. While I do not find there would be a great prejudice to the Respondent if I were to allow the email into evidence, the Applicant has not persuaded me that the email should be admitted. For completeness, I note that Mr Camilleri has made submissions about the stress the case has caused him, however I am not persuaded that to allow the email into evidence would cause further significant stress, nor would it cause a delay in the expected judgment as the application has in any case caused me to vacate directions for closing submissions to be filed.