Ferri v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Ferri v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) [2023] QIRC 086

PARTIES:

Ferri, Jye
(Appellant)

v

State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

PSA/2022/1003

PROCEEDING:

Public Sector Appeal – Fair treatment appeal

DELIVERED ON:

20 March 2023

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

McLennan IC

On the papers

ORDER:

The decisions appealed against are confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

PUBLIC SECTOR – EMPLOYEES AND SERVANTS OF THE CROWN GENERALLY – PUBLIC SECTOR APPEAL – where the appellant made a conflict of interest declaration – where the decision-maker imposed restrictions on the declaration of other employment – where respondent declined request for conference – whether decisions were fair and reasonable  

LEGISLATION & OTHER INSTRUMENTS:

CASES:

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld)
s 562, s 562B, s 562C

Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld) s 131, s 133,
s 134, s 289, s 324

Public Sector Ethics Act 1994 (Qld) s 6

Public Service Act 2008 (Qld) s 186, s 194

Correctional Employees Award – State 2015
cl 7

Queensland Corrective Services – Correctional Employees' Certified Agreement 2021 cl 9

Ferri v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) [2022] QIRC 239

Gilmour v Waddell & Ors [2019] QSC 170

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332

Reasons for Decision

  1. Mr Jye Ferri (Appellant) commenced casual employment as a Custodial Correctional Officer (CCO) at the Brisbane Correctional Centre (BCC), with Queensland Corrective Services (QCS), State of Queensland (Respondent) on 30 December 2019.[1]

    [1] Appellant's submissions filed 13 Dec 2022, 1 [1].

  2. Mr Ferri is an admitted lawyer and is also currently employed with Sibley Lawyers in a casual capacity.[2]

    [2] Ibid Attachment 1, 2.

The original DOOE

  1. Mr Ferri declared his secondary employment with Sibley Lawyers (the firm) on 9 September 2020 (the original DOOE).[3]

[3] DOOE is 'Declaration of Other Employment'.

  1. In that original DOOE, Mr Ferri disclosed that:

Sibley Lawyers offers Employment Law services which I may assist with.  The firm does

represent essential service personnel including Ambulance, Police and Correctional Officers.[4]

[4] Respondent's submissions filed 20 December 2022, 1 [3].

…

Ordinary duties of a Junior Solicitor at a Criminal Law Firm.  It is proposed I be engaged in a casual capacity.  Tasks may include:

-         Drafting court documents;

-         Managing files;

-         Meeting with clients;

-         Making court appearances; and

-         Assisting in the general operations of running a business.[5]

[5] Ibid Attachment 3, 2.

  1. The original DOOE was approved on 10 September 2020 by Chief Superintendent Bernie Kruhse subject to the condition that:

QCS may withdraw approval of any other employment where it is in the interests of QCS to do so after consulting with myself, and that such advice will be provided in writing.[6]

[6] Ibid.

  1. On 10 March 2022 Superintendent Peter Stacey wrote to Mr Ferri (the interim measure):

    [Ethical Standards Group (ESG)] had become aware that, while employed in your role as a CCO, you also currently provide legal representation to other QCS employees, including your colleagues at BCC, in workplace investigations…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ferri v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QIRC 86
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the court involves Mr. Ferri, who is challenging decisions made by Chief Superintendent Henderson concerning his other employment with Sibley Lawyers. The dispute revolves around conditions imposed by Chief Superintendent Henderson on Mr. Ferri's employment, which Mr. Ferri contends are unfair and unreasonable. The court was tasked with determining whether these decisions were indeed unreasonable and whether Chief Superintendent Henderson's refusal to hold a further conference was justified.

The legal issues at hand were whether the conditions imposed on Mr. Ferri's employment were fair and reasonable and whether Chief Superintendent Henderson's decision to decline a further conference was justified. The court examined the relevant statutory framework and the principles of legal reasonableness as articulated in previous cases. It was necessary to assess whether Chief Superintendent Henderson's decisions were within the bounds of legal reasonableness, considering the scope and purpose of the statute conferring the power to impose such conditions.

In its reasoning, the court found that Chief Superintendent Henderson's decisions were fair and reasonable. The court emphasized that a decision is unreasonable only if it lacks intelligent justification within the relevant circumstances. It was noted that Chief Superintendent Henderson had already made a decision on 19 July 2022 and had communicated this to Mr. Ferri, who was also informed of his right to appeal. The court held that Chief Superintendent Henderson's decision to cease further engagement with Mr. Ferri after communicating his decision on 19 July 2022 was neither unfair nor unreasonable. The court also found that Chief Superintendent Henderson's refusal to hold a further conference was justified given that a decision had already been made and Mr. Ferri had been provided with the opportunity to appeal.

The final orders of the court confirmed the decisions appealed against, upholding Chief Superintendent Henderson's conditions on Mr. Ferri's employment and his decision to decline a further conference.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decisions appealed against are confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The relevant principles in considering whether a decision is 'unreasonable' were enunciated by Ryan J in Gilmour v Waddell & Ors (emphasis added, citations removed):[23]The focus of a review of the reasonableness, or unreasonableness, of a decision is on whether the decision is so unreasonable that it lacks intelligent justification in all of the relevant circumstances. The legal standard of unreasonableness is to be considered by reference to the subject matter, scope and purpose of the statute conferring the power. A court considering an argument that a decision is unreasonable is not undertaking a merits review. If a decision may be reasonably justified, then it is not an unreasonable decision, even if a reviewing court might disagree with it.The pluarity in Li said:… when something is to be done within the discretion of an authority, it is to be done according to the rules of reason and justice. That is what is meant by 'according to law'. It is to be legal and regular, not vague and fanciful …… there is an area within which a decision-maker has a genuinely free discretion. That area resides within the bounds of legal reasonableness. The courts are conscious of not exceeding their supervisory role by undertaking a review of the merits of an exercise of discretionary power. Properly applied, a standard of legal reasonableness does not involve substituting a court's view as to how a discretion should be applied for that of a decision-maker … … it is necessary to look to the scope and purpose of the statute conferring the discretionary power and its real object … The legal standard of reasonableness must be the standard indicated by the true construction of the statute. It is necessary to construe the statute because the question to which the standard of reasonableness is addressed is whether the statutory power has been abused. … Unreasonableness is a conclusion which may be applied to a decision which lacks an evidence and intelligible justification.[23][2019] QSC 170, [207]-[210], citing Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332, [63]- Chief Superintendent Henderson's decision included the imposition of three disputed conditions on Mr Ferri's other employment with Sibley Lawyers. For completeness, Chief Superintendent Henderson approved Mr Ferri's DOOE subject to the following conditions:The conditions in relation to which we do have agreement, and will be imposed within 22 days of this letter are:1. That you do not provide legal advice or representation to a person charged with a criminal, traffic or domestic violence offence;2. That you do not access IOMS for any clients for whom you or Sibley Lawyers have previously acted, or for whom Sibley Lawyers are currently acting, except where you have a genuine operational need to access IOMS for a current prisoner and you advise your General Manager in writing within 4 hours of the access setting out the reasons why you required access and the General Manager approves the access; and3. That where a prisoner that you have legally represented in your employment at Sibley Lawyers is not currently at BCC, but is transferred to BCC, within 24 hours of that information coming within your knowledge you complete a further DOOE and advise your Manager via email of the further DOOE and take all steps to remove yourself from the area / management of the prisoner, as a matter of urgency.The conditions in relation to which we do not have agreement, but will be imposed within 22 days of this letter are:4. That you do not provide legal advice or representation to an employee of QCS in matters against QCS, or the State of Queensland / Crown;5. That you do not attend ESG interviews in your capacity as lawyer for QCS employees (both current and former);6. That you do not represent and advise current or former employees of QCS in employment / discipline matters, domestic violence, traffic offences and criminal matters before a court or tribunal and against QCS, or the State of Queensland / Crown.In relation to points 4 and 6 above and points 1 and 2 of my letter dated 20 May 2022, I confirm I have determined that you may complete employment / discipline work for an officer of QPS. This is now reflected in point 4 above. However, in relation to representing / advising an employee of QPS in a criminal matter, I make the following condition:7. That you do not represent and advise current or former employees of QPS in, domestic violence, traffic offences and criminal matters before a court or tribunal.Finally, within 22 days of this letter, you are required to:8. submit a Conflict of Interest Declaration for any prisoner currently accommodated at BCC whom you have represented in the course of your employment with Sibley Lawyers; and9. confirm in writing that you have complied with (1) above.Hereafter, the requirements in paragraphs 1 to 9 will be referred to as 'My Decision'.[24][24] Appellant's submissions filed 13 December 2022, Attachment 3, 5 – 6.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent further asserted that: …while no actual conflict has presently been identified, (Mr Ferri's) conduct has not been beyond reproach in that in his employment as a solicitor with Sibley Lawyers, in responding to a show cause notice on behalf of a CCO as part of a discipline process, he made submissions seeking to discredit the evidence of two of his fellow CCOs at BCC. This is a matter that was addressed in Chief Superintendent Henderson's correspondence dated 20 May 2022…Furthermore, the obligations on QCS to manage a conflict of interest exists regardless of whether it is perceived, potential or real.[46]Consideration[46] Ibid 5 [35](a).Ought Chief Superintendent Henderson have declined the further conference? Chief Superintendent Henderson's correspondence dated 3 November 2022 confirmed his decision of 19 July 2022 to impose conditions on Mr Ferri's other employment with Sibley Lawyers. Mr Ferri clearly did not accept that 19 July 2022 decision, instead continuing to agitate his position and attempt to persuade Chief Superintendent Henderson to change his mind in a subsequent meeting on 26 August 2022 and in correspondence dated 6 September 2022. Such entreaties were ultimately unsuccessful. Chief Superintendent Henderson advised Mr Ferri on 3 November 2022 that "My decision, as outlined in my letter dated 19 July 2022 stands." When Chief Superintendent Henderson communicated his decision to impose conditions on Mr Ferri's other employment with Sibley Lawyers on 19 July 2022, the decision was made. Though I have noted that the Respondent did not raise any jurisdictional objection as to the time of Mr Ferri filing his appeal, and so appeared satisfied for it to be heard on its merits. That 19 July 2022 correspondence also appropriately explained to Mr Ferri that he had the right to appeal to the QIRC if he believed Chief Superintendent Henderson's decision was unfair and unreasonable. Mr Ferri elected not to do so at that time. In my view, Chief Superintendent Henderson may well have determined to cease engagement with Mr Ferri about the matter at that point. A decision had been made and Mr Ferri's rights to appeal set out. It seems to me that Chief Superintendent Henderson chose to invest even more time and resources in the matter thereafter out of an abundance of fairness and goodwill towards Mr Ferri. While Mr Ferri feels clearly aggrieved by Chief Superintendent Henderson's determination not to "entertain any further conference in relation to this matter", that is neither unfair or unreasonable in my view. A decision had been made on 19 July 2022 - the matter was settled. While Mr Ferri complained that Chief Superintendent Henderson had "expressed the possibility" of a conference at their meeting on 26 August 2022 "between myself, himself and QCS Legal" - and that Mr Ferri himself had seen value in the opportunity "to directly engage with my second employer" – that any such musings did not eventuate after 19 July 2022, does not render Chief Superintendent Henderson's decision to be unfair or unreasonable.